The Circular Flow and GDP (Wirtschaftskreislauf, BIP)

25 min · 12 drills

Whoever works draws a wage. Whoever draws a wage goes shopping. Whoever shops gives a firm the turnover out of which wages get paid again. The movement runs in a circle and stops nowhere. It is called the Wirtschaftskreislauf, and the second half of this article answers the question of how the volume moving around that circle is measured.

Three participants, and the state is one of them

Two groups take part in economic life to begin with: private households (private Haushalte) and firms (Unternehmen). A household is not the same thing as a family. Someone living alone forms a private household just as a shared flat or a family with children does.

The third participant is the state (Staat), and it is regularly misplaced. What is meant is not only the government and parliament but every public institution: authorities, schools, courts, hospitals, the local council. And the state does not merely set the legal frame within which exchange happens. It joins the exchange itself, because it levies taxes and other charges, places contracts with firms, pays teachers, police officers and judges for their work, and makes support payments.

Wirtschaftskreislauf (the circular flow)

All three participants exchange goods against money. Those exchange relations produce movements that run in a circle, and the whole of them is called the Wirtschaftskreislauf.

Your turn1 of 12

A classmate leaves the state out of the simple circular flow: it only sets the legal framework, she says, and the exchanging happens between households and firms. Which statement from the textbook refutes her?

Every flow has a counter-flow

An exchange has two sides. Whoever receives goods hands over money for them, and whoever supplies labour receives a wage for it. On the diagram that means every arrow has a second one pointing the opposite way. That is why the number of arrows in the circuit is always even, and why any flow you know lets you work out its partner instead of memorising it.

Two such pairs run between households and firms, and one pair runs between the state and each of the other two:

What goes outWhat comes back
Güter (products and services) from firms to householdsZahlungen, the payments for the goods bought
Arbeitsleistungen, labour supplied by households to firmsLöhne und Gehälter, wages and salaries
Steuern und andere Abgaben, taxes paid by householdsStaatliche Leistungen, what the state provides to households
Steuern und andere Abgaben, taxes paid by firmsStaatliche Leistungen, what the state provides to firms

With taxes the counter-flow is not an exchange case by case: whoever pays taxes acquires no claim to a particular service in return, and the state's services stand against the taxes only as a whole. What the state gives back is of two kinds, and the next section returns to that. On one side there are public goods: roads, cycle paths, parks, schools, hospitals, digital infrastructure. On the other there are payments, for instance support for families with children or grants for people starting a business.

Your turn2 of 12

An electrician works as an employee of an installation firm. Which flow of the simple circular flow is the counter-flow to his labour?

Build the circuit yourself

In the first tab of the diagram the eight arrows carry no labels. Put the labels on yourself, and while doing so watch less where the boxes sit than which way a flow runs: that is what exam statements ask about. The other two tabs belong to the next two sections, so leave them alone for now.

Pick an arrow, then the label that belongs on it. A wrong label goes back to the list and tells you where it does belong.

StaatEvery public institution, not onlythe governmentPrivate HaushalteAnyone living alone, in a familyor in a shared flatUnternehmenBanks belong here in this simplemodel12345678

The eight arrows

The labels

Labelled: 0 / 8

Your turn3 of 12

You are labelling the arrows of the simple circular flow. Which three arrows lead away from the box of private households?

The goods circuit, the money circuit and the banks

Inside the circular flow two circuits are distinguished, and they run against each other. The Güterkreislauf covers everything produced or performed: products, services, labour and the public goods the state provides. The Geldkreislauf covers the payments flowing the other way in return. The state's two arrows back to households and firms sit in both circuits, because what the state returns is precisely both: a public good and a payment.

Switch the second tab to the money circuit and count the boxes through. At least one money arrow leads into each of them and at least one leads out. So money runs in a circle on its own, without leaving the circuit anywhere. On the full diagram this cannot be seen, because the two circuits lie on top of one another.

The money circuit is the banks' business, and where they belong is not self-evident. Banks do not form a separate, fourth participant in the simple circuit. They belong to the firms, because they offer services around money: they run payment traffic, take in savings, provide credit and advise on financial matters. An exam statement declaring banks a fourth participant of the simple model is false.

Your turn4 of 12

A classmate draws the banks in the simple circular flow as a fourth box of their own alongside households, firms and the state. Which statement from the textbook refutes him?

Why a problem at one participant reaches all of them

Because every flow hangs on another one, no disturbance stays where it arose. The teaching example is the lockdown during the coronavirus pandemic: private households consumed less, which put firms under pressure, firms with nothing to sell had to shed staff in part, and household incomes fell. The state in turn supported households and firms during that time, while its own tax revenue was shrinking.

Watch the order in that chain. It is not arbitrary: a flow moves because the flow before it moved, and once you have walked the route yourself you can ask the same question about a new disturbance without knowing the chain by heart. In the third tab of the diagram you pick one of several events and work through the chain step by step. A wrong answer blocks nothing; it shows which flow actually comes next.

Your turn5 of 12

In a district town a plant with 1,500 employees closes. What follows if you walk through the flows of the circuit in order?

The Ausland as a fourth participant

The simple circular flow shows economic relations inside one country. Cross-border relations do not appear in it, which is why the Ausland is often added as one more actor. Remember that boundary: the Ausland belongs to the extended version, not to the simple circuit. In the second tab of the diagram you can switch it on and take it away again.

For Austria this extension is no fine detail. About 70 percent of Austrian foreign trade runs with member states of the European Union, and the export quota, meaning the share of exports in total economic output, sits at around 50 percent. Roughly every second euro earned in Austria therefore comes out of foreign trade. That is how the WU text counts, and that is how it is examined. Strictly speaking, exports also contain imported inputs, so the quota does not exactly measure the share of value created at home. Imports and exports both stand at about two hundred billion euros, with imports slightly ahead of exports and staying so.

The lion's share of exports is not made up of the famous confectionery but of machinery, vehicles, processed goods and chemical products; among services it is mainly tourism, transport and technical services. This is not a figure to memorise but a direction: a small open economy sells intermediate products and equipment to other economies rather than consumer articles to end customers.

Your turn6 of 12

A claim reads: the simple circular flow shows four participants, namely households, firms, the state and the Ausland, because Austria exports about half of its economic output. How should it be judged?

Gross domestic product measures exactly that flow

The diagram shows that something flows. How much flows is what gross domestic product, BIP for short, answers. It is therefore no foreign body in this chapter but the measure belonging to the very diagram you have just built.

Bruttoinlandsprodukt (BIP, gross domestic product)

The BIP covers all goods, meaning products and services, produced within the borders of a country during a given period, valued at market value, that is quantity times market price. Intermediate products and inputs are deducted.

Three parts of that definition get tested. First a period: the BIP is a quantity per stretch of time, usually per year, not a stock. Second a territory: what counts is what arises inside the country's borders, no matter who owns the means of production. Third the deduction of inputs, and that is the real stumbling block.

Take a joinery that buys timber for 3,000 euros and turns it into tables worth 8,000 euros. Adding both amounts would give 11,000 euros, although the timber already sits inside the finished tables and its value would be captured twice. So the input is deducted: the joinery contributes 5,000 euros to the BIP and the sawmill its own 3,000 euros, together exactly the 8,000 euros the final product is worth on the market.

Your turn7 of 12

A tax advisory office bills 240,000 euros of services a year and buys in software and outside services for 40,000 euros to do so. A classmate credits it with the full 240,000 euros as its contribution to the BIP: an office processes no raw materials, he says, so its purchases stay in the figure. Which statement from the textbook shows his mistake?

Your turn8 of 12

A mill sells flour for 1,200 euros to a bakery, which bakes bread from it and sells it for 4,000 euros. How much do the mill and the bakery contribute to the BIP together?

Nominal and real BIP

If the BIP rises from one year to the next, the economy has grown. That holds only if prices have stayed the same, though, because the BIP values goods at market prices. Had the same quantities been produced in a year while everything got more expensive, the figure would still go up.

Two measures are therefore distinguished. The nominal BIP is calculated at current prices. Adjusted for inflation it yields the real BIP, and only the latter shows whether more was actually produced. Real economic growth is accordingly spoken of only in terms of the real BIP.

Your turn9 of 12

A country's nominal BIP rises by 3 percent in one year, and the general price level by 5 percent in the same year. Which statement is true?

What the BIP does not measure

Related to population size, as BIP per head, it allows a quick comparison of countries of different sizes. On the latest figures it stands at about 49,400 euros in Austria and around 35,430 euros on average across the European Union; Luxembourg leads and Bulgaria comes last. What matters for the exam is the order of magnitude, not the exact amount.

As a measure of prosperity the BIP is rightly criticised, and the objections are all of one kind: the figure rises without anyone being better off.

  • It rises after a natural disaster or an industrial accident, because clean-up and reconstruction have to be produced.
  • It rises when goods harmful to the environment or to health are made, whose consequences fall due later.
  • About the quality and sustainability of economic output it says nothing at all.
  • Whatever arises without a market value is missing from it entirely, for instance unpaid care work done by relatives.

Even so, BIP per head correlates positively with measures such as the health status and the education level of the population. It is therefore usable with reservations and alongside other indicators; unusable is what it is not.

Your turn10 of 12

A politician says: BIP per head rose markedly last year, so people in the country are better off. Which fact calls this conclusion into question?

BIP and BNP: the ground or the owners

Alongside the BIP stands gross national product, BNP for short. Both count the same kind of output but draw the line in a different place: the BIP asks where production happened, the BNP asks who owns the factors of production employed. So the BNP captures everything residents produce worldwide with the factors of production belonging to them, and leaves out what foreigners earn inside the country.

An example makes the difference concrete. Someone commuting into Austria from abroad to work has their income counted in the Austrian BIP but not in the Austrian BNP. Conversely, the income of a person from Austria who commutes abroad to work counts towards the BNP but not the BIP. For large economies the two measures usually lie close together, while for small and heavily interlinked ones they can diverge markedly.

The BNP is often called gross national income as well, BNE for short. The older name Bruttosozialprodukt, BSP for short, denotes the same measure and is no longer in use today.

Your turn11 of 12

A German group runs a plant in Graz. A colleague thinks that what is made there counts towards the German and not the Austrian BIP, because the plant belongs to a German owner. Which statement from the textbook refutes him?

Your turn12 of 12

A woman from Vienna commutes to Bratislava every day and works there. Where does her income count on the Austrian side?

Now practise it

The Circular Flow and GDP (Wirtschaftskreislauf, BIP)

Trainer · Basic economics

Practise
Next: Market, Price Formation and Competition (Markt, Preisbildung, Wettbewerb)
0/12

Was this article helpful?