Elementary Financial Mathematics (Elementare Finanzmathematik)

40 min · 10 drills

The tasks in this topic describe an investment, a series of payments or a choice between two offers: an amount, an interest rate, a term, sometimes a bonus or an instalment that recurs every year. Below them stand five claims, and each one is true or false on its own. Some ask for a number, usually in the form 'lies above' or 'lies below' a threshold; others ask about a principle, for instance what a higher interest rate does to a present value. Both kinds need the same three tools: compounding, discounting and the sum of a series of payments.

The formula sheet (German: Formelsammlung) gives you exactly one formula for this, the sum of the geometric series (formula 12). It contains no formula for compound interest, for present value or for an annuity. Compound interest and discounting are yours to bring along; the annuity formulas you do not need to memorise, because they follow from the geometric sum, and this article shows how.

An interest rate becomes a tool once it is written as a factor

Interest rate

The interest rate i states what share of the capital is added as interest in one period. A rate of p percent corresponds to i=p100: 5% becomes i=0.05, 0.75% becomes i=0.0075. Unless something else is said, the period is one year, marked 'p. a.' (per annum).

Accumulation factor

The accumulation factor (German: Aufzinsungsfaktor) q=1+i is the number by which capital is multiplied in one period. At 5% it is q=1.05, at 0.75% it is q=1.0075.

The factor merges two steps into one. Investing 8,000 euros at 5%, you have after one year the capital itself plus the interest 8 000⋅0.05=400 euros, together 8 000⋅(1+0.05)=8 400 euros. Multiplying by 1.05 straight away saves the addition and, above all, lets you repeat the step as often as needed.

Your turn1 of 10

A savings account pays 0.8% interest per year. By which number do you multiply the balance to get the amount after one year?

Simple interest adds, compound interest multiplies

For the years after the first there are two rules. They differ in a single question: is the interest of one year itself earning interest in the years that follow?

Simple interest

With simple (linear) interest (German: einfache Verzinsung) the same amount K0⋅i is paid on the initial capital K0 every year. After n years the capital is Kn=K0(1+ni).

Compound interest

With compound interest (German: Zinseszins) the interest is added to the capital at the end of each period and earns interest from then on. Every year the capital is multiplied by q, so after n years it has been multiplied n times.

Kn=K0⋅qn=K0⋅(1+i)n

With 10,000 euros at 5% you can see where the two rules part ways.

Yearsimple interestcompound interestgap
110 500.0010 500.000
211 000.0011 025.0025.00
311 500.0011 576.2576.25

After the first year both values agree, because until then there was no interest that could have earned interest. In the second year the first year's interest, 500⋅0.05=25 euros, earns interest too, and from then on compound interest pulls ahead. After exactly one period the two values are therefore equal; that compound interest stays ahead afterwards is shown by multiplying out in the next section.

Interest earned

The interest earned (German: Zinsertrag) is the future value minus the capital put in, Kn−K0. For 10,000 euros over three years at 5% compound interest that is 1,576.25 euros.

The exponent counts the years: the capital after one year is K0q, after two years K0q2, after n years K0qn. An expression such as K0⋅n⋅q, by contrast, is no interest calculation at all: it would grow with the term even at i=0.

Your turn2 of 10

Capital sits in an account for nine years at 6% compound interest. By which factor is the initial capital multiplied in total?

The lead of compound interest grows every year

Multiplying out shows why compound interest never falls behind simple interest. For two years (1+i)2=1+2i+i2: the first two terms are exactly the linear factor 1+2i, and i2 is the interest on the interest. For more years further terms are added.

(1+i)n=1+ni+(n2)i2+⋯+in

The binomial coefficient comes from formula 11 of the formula sheet, here (n2)=n(n−1)2. For n≥2 at least the term (n2)i2 remains after 1+ni, and for i>0 all these terms are positive. That is why K0qn>K0(1+ni), and the gap widens because the coefficients grow with n.

Each single year shows the same. The linear interest is K0i every year. Under compound interest the interest of year k is Kk−1⋅i=K0qk−1i, and since the capital grows, so does this amount. A late year therefore brings more growth than an early one.

This tells you how to compare stretches of time. Between two points a<b the capital grows by Kb−Ka=K0(qb−qa). Of two stretches of equal length the later one brings more. For stretches of unequal length only the calculation decides, because the earlier one has more years and the later one the more productive years. For 10,000 euros at 6% over ten years:

Stretchgrowth in euros
year 0 to 53 382.26
year 5 to 104 526.22
year 0 to 75 036.30
year 7 to 102 872.17

The two halves of equal length follow the rule. With the split after seven years, however, the early stretch wins clearly: seven smaller yearly gains add up to more than three larger ones.

Your turn3 of 10

An amount is invested once with simple interest and once with compound interest, both times at the same positive rate. How does the gap between the two balances develop?

At usual rates, compounding within the year brings only a little more

Nominal annual rate

When interest is credited several times a year, say monthly or quarterly, this is called compounding within the year (German: unterjährige Verzinsung). The bank then usually quotes a nominal annual rate i, and each period earns im, where m is the number of periods in a year: m=12 for monthly, m=4 for quarterly crediting. After n years, m⋅n periods have passed.

Kn=K0⋅(1+im)mn
Effective annual rate

The effective annual rate is the rate that would give the same result with crediting once a year: ieff=(1+im)m−1.

At a nominal 6%, depending on how often interest is credited, this gives:

Creditingfactor for one yeareffective annual rate
yearly, m=11.066%
quarterly, m=41.0154≈1.0613646.136%
monthly, m=121.00512≈1.0616786.168%
daily, m=365≈1.0618316.183%

Every crediting within the year lets the interest already credited earn from then on: interest credited in March itself earns interest in April. That is why crediting within the year comes out above yearly crediting. Multiplying out as above, with im instead of i and m instead of n, gives (1+im)m=1+i+(m2)i2m2+…, and for i>0 and m≥2 that is more than 1+i. The same argument compares monthly with quarterly: three monthly creditings give (1+i12)3>1+i4, that is, more than one quarterly crediting.

At such rates, however, the gain is small. On 10,000 euros, monthly crediting brings 16.78 euros more in one year than yearly crediting, and daily crediting only 1.53 euros more than monthly. The difference grows with capital, rate and term; at rates of a few percent and usual terms it stays a small fraction of the interest earned, and a claim that gives it the size of the interest earned itself is false there. Only high rates over decades make it noticeable.

Your turn4 of 10

A bank quotes a nominal annual rate of 8% and credits interest quarterly. Which expression gives the effective annual rate?

The present value brings a future payment into the present

Compound interest calculates from today into the future. Often the question is put the other way round: what is a payment that falls due only in a few years worth today?

Present value

The present value (German: Barwert) of a payment Kn due in n years is the amount that, invested today at rate i, grows to exactly Kn in n years. From K0⋅qn=Kn it follows that K0=Knqn. The amount Kn itself is also called the nominal value.

Discount factor

The discount factor (German: Abzinsungsfaktor) 1qn is the number by which an amount due in n years is multiplied to obtain its present value. Discounting is compounding in reverse.

K0=Knqn=Kn⋅1(1+i)n
Discount rate

The rate used for discounting is called the discount rate (German: Kalkulationszinssatz), or the alternative rate of return. It stands for what the money could earn elsewhere: whoever receives a payment only later forgoes exactly this interest until then.

An example: 10,000 euros fall due in five years, and the discount rate is 5%. The discount factor is 11.055≈11.276282≈0.783526, so the present value is about 7,835.26 euros. Investing 7,835.26 euros today at 5% gives 10,000 euros after five years.

Three properties follow from the form Knqn alone, and many claims ask about them.

  • The present value lies below the nominal value. For i>0 and n≥1 we have qn>1, and dividing by a number larger than 1 makes any positive amount smaller.
  • A higher discount rate lowers the present value. As i grows, qn grows, and dividing by a larger number gives less. At 4% instead of 5% the 10,000 euros from the example are worth 8,219.27 euros today.
  • The later a payment falls due, the smaller its present value. Every extra year puts one more factor q into the denominator. The same 10,000 euros, due only in six years instead of five, are worth just 7 835.261.05≈7 462.15 euros today.

Your turn5 of 10

A payment of 50,000 euros falls due in eight years, and the discount rate is 4%. Which expression is its present value?

Payments can only be compared at a common point in time

A euro today and a euro in four years are different quantities, like a metre and a centimetre: they can be compared or added only once they are expressed in the same unit. For money that unit is the point in time. Every amount is therefore first moved to a common point in time, compounded if it flows earlier, discounted if it flows later.

Which point in time you choose does not change the order, because compounding and discounting multiply both sides by the same positive factor. Choose the one that needs the least arithmetic. An example at 5%: 10,000 euros in one year or 10,800 euros in three years?

  • Discounted to today: 10 0001.05≈9 523.81 euros against 10 8001.053≈9 329.45 euros.
  • Compounded to year three: 10 000⋅1.052=11 025 euros against 10 800 euros.

Both routes show the same thing: the earlier, smaller payment is worth more. In general a payment that comes d years later must be more than qd times the earlier one to win; here that would be more than 10.25% extra, and 8% is offered. With different due dates, which nominal value is larger does not decide which present value is larger.

Whether a later payment is worth waiting for depends on the discount rate. 8,000 euros today or 10,000 euros in five years: at 5% the 10,000 euros are worth 7,835.26 euros today and the immediate payment wins; at 4% they are worth 8,219.27 euros and the later payment wins.

A bonus, a one-off extra payment or the residual value of an item that still belongs to you at the end is also a payment at a particular point in time and is treated like any other. A bonus at the start is compounded together with the capital over the whole term; a bonus or residual value at the end enters a comparison of future values without any factor.

For 24,000 euros over three years, bank A offers 5%, bank B 4% plus a bonus of 300 euros at the end. Bank A delivers 24 000⋅1.053≈27 783.00 euros, bank B 24 000⋅1.043+300≈26 996.74+300=27 296.74 euros. The bonus does not make up for the lower rate, and simple interest already shows why: one percentage point on 24,000 euros is 240 euros a year, at least 720 euros over three years, and 300 euros is too little against that. Only a bonus of the same order as this shortfall can reverse the order.

Your turn6 of 10

At a discount rate of 6%, 5,000 euros in two years stand against 5,500 euros in four years. Which comparison is set up correctly?

The future value of an annuity is a geometric sum

Ordinary annuity

An ordinary annuity (German: nachschüssige Rente) is a sequence of n equal payments R, one at the end of each period. Whether money is paid in, as with a savings plan, or paid out, as with an insurance benefit, makes no difference to the calculation.

Future value of an annuity

The future value of an annuity (German: Rentenendwert) is the value of all instalments at the time of the last instalment, each instalment compounded separately up to that point.

In a five-year savings plan at 4% with 1,000 euros at the end of every year, the first instalment sits in the account for four years, the second for three, the third for two, the fourth for one and the fifth for none at all: it is being paid in at the very moment the future value is read off.

Instalmentpaid at end of yearearns interest forvalue at end of year 5
114 years1 000⋅1.044≈1 169.86
223 years1 000⋅1.043≈1 124.86
332 years1 000⋅1.042=1 081.60
441 year1 000⋅1.041=1 040.00
550 years1 000⋅1.040=1 000.00
Sum5 416.32

The highest exponent is n−1, not n, and the lowest is 0. Letting the exponents run from 1 to n compounds every instalment one year too long. Read from the last instalment backwards, the future value is a geometric sum with n terms:

E=R+Rq+Rq2+⋯+Rqn−1

Formula 12 of the formula sheet reads a+ar+ar2+⋯+arn=a⋅1−rn+11−r, valid for r≠1. Because its exponents start at 0, it has n+1 terms. Put a=R and r=q, where q≠1 for any non-zero rate; the highest exponent of the annuity, n−1, takes the place of the sheet's n, and rn+1 becomes qn:

E=R⋅1−qn1−q=R⋅qn−1q−1

The second fraction comes from the first by multiplying numerator and denominator by −1; it is more convenient because both parts are positive when q>1. In the example: 1 000⋅1.045−10.04≈1 000⋅0.2166530.04≈5 416.32 euros, the same number as in the table. The interest earned is 5 416.32−5⋅1 000=416.32 euros: future value minus the sum of all instalments.

The most common slip shows in the number of terms: with q6 instead of q5 in the numerator you would get 6,632.98 euros, the future value of six instalments instead of five.

In an annuity due (German: vorschüssige Rente) each payment flows at the start of the period, one period earlier, and earns interest one period longer. Every term gains one factor q, and the future value is q times as large: in the example 5 416.32⋅1.04≈5 632.98 euros. When a task says 'at the end of each year', the annuity is ordinary.

Your turn7 of 10

An ordinary annuity consists of seven instalments of R each, compounded with q. Which expression is its future value immediately after the last instalment?

The present value of an annuity is smaller than the sum of its instalments

The present value of an annuity answers the question of which amount today replaces the same series of payments. Two equivalent routes lead there.

Present value of an annuity

The present value of an annuity (German: Rentenbarwert) is the sum of the present values of all instalments: B=Rq+Rq2+⋯+Rqn. Since the future value brings all instalments to time n, the present value is also this future value discounted by n years.

B=Eqn=R⋅qn−1(q−1)⋅qn

In the example, 5 416.321.045≈4 451.82 euros. The sum of the five separately discounted instalments gives the same number, from 1 0001.04≈961.54 euros for the first to 1 0001.045≈821.93 euros for the last. The first instalment is discounted with q1, not with q0: it falls due only after one year.

Three properties can be checked without calculation.

  • The present value stays smaller than the sum of the instalments. Every instalment is discounted and loses something; with five instalments of 1,000 euros, 4,451.82 euros remain instead of 5,000 euros.
  • A higher discount rate lowers the present value, because every term becomes smaller.
  • A longer annuity with the same instalment has a higher present value. Every extra year adds a positive term and takes none away. The late instalments, however, contribute less and less.

With the present value an annuity can be set against a lump sum. Suppose that instead of the five instalments of 1,000 euros, 4,500 euros were offered today. The instalments add up to more, namely 5,000 euros, and yet their present value of 4,451.82 euros is smaller than 4,500 euros: the lump sum wins. Compared at the end of the term the order is the same, 4 500⋅1.045≈5 474.94 euros against 5 416.32 euros. The larger sum of the instalments does not decide such a comparison, because it ignores the points in time.

Your turn8 of 10

An annuity pays 1,000 euros at the end of each year for seven years, and the discount rate is positive. Which statement about its present value is correct?

Estimate before you calculate

Most numerical claims read 'lies above X' or 'lies below X'. What is asked is not the exact value but on which side of the threshold it lies, and that can often be settled with a bound you can work out in your head.

  • Simple interest is a lower bound. We have K0qn≥K0(1+ni). If the linear value is already above the threshold, 'lies above' is true; if it is below, the bound decides nothing, and you need an upper bound or the exact calculation. With the third term of the expansion, (n2)i2, the bound becomes tighter and stays a lower one: for 10,000 euros at 5% over five years it gives 10 000⋅(1+0.25+10⋅0.0025)=12 750 euros, while the exact value is 12,762.82 euros.
  • A present value lies between two linear bounds. We have Kn(1−ni)≤Knqn≤Kn1+ni. The right-hand bound follows from the previous point, because the denominator qn is at least 1+ni; the left-hand one deducts the full interest from the nominal value every year, which is more than discounting actually takes off. For 10,000 euros in five years at 5% the present value therefore lies between 7,500 and 8,000 euros; exactly, it is 7,835.26 euros.
  • The interest earned by an annuity is at least R⋅i⋅n(n−1)2. Calculated linearly, the first instalment earns n−1 years of interest, the second n−2 and the last none, together 0+1+⋯+(n−1)=n(n−1)2 years of interest at R⋅i each. For five instalments of 1,000 euros at 4% that is 400 euros; the exact interest earned is 416.32 euros.
  • Doubling after roughly 72p years. At 6% capital doubles in about twelve years, since 1.0612≈2.01. That is enough to spot a claim that is far off.

If the threshold falls between the bounds, only calculation helps. Then type qn into the calculator once and keep working with that value: present value, future value of an annuity and interest earned are basic arithmetic from there. Do not round the factor to two decimal places, or the result flips as soon as the threshold lies only a few euros from the exact value.

Comparisons between two offers often need no future value at all. Same capital, same term, higher rate: higher future value, without calculation. Calculation is needed only when an offer is ahead in one respect and behind in another, such as a higher rate against a bonus, or larger instalments against later payment. Then estimate each side's lead separately, as above with the bonus of 300 euros against one percentage point.

Your turn9 of 10

An amount of 60,000 euros falls due in five years, and the discount rate is 2%. In which range does its present value lie?

Five claims under time pressure

As throughout the mathematics part, you make five independent decisions: how many claims are true is open, and scoring uses partial points. An approach that works well for this topic:

  1. Write down the points in time. When does which amount flow, and which point in time does the claim refer to: today, the end of the term, the moment of the last instalment?
  2. Principle or number? Claims about a direction (higher rate, longer term, more frequent crediting) are decided with the properties from this article, without calculation.
  3. Bounds before calculation. For every claim with a threshold, take the linear bound first; compute qn only when the threshold falls between the bounds.
  4. Compute a value once, use it several times. Future value, interest earned and the gap to another offer often hang on the same number.
  5. Check the reference quantity. Interest earned is future value minus everything paid in; the sum of the instalments is neither a future value nor a present value.

A complete example. A student can receive 14,500 euros today or, instead, 5,000 euros at the end of each year for three years. The discount rate is 2%.

  • The three payments together come to more than the immediate amount. True, but irrelevant to the decision: 3⋅5 000=15 000 euros is a sum of amounts at different points in time.
  • The present value of the series of payments lies below 15,000 euros. True, without calculation: every instalment is discounted, so the present value stays below the sum of the instalments.
  • The future value of the series after three years lies above 15,400 euros. False. The linear bound gives 15 000+5 000⋅0.02⋅3=15 300 euros; it lies below the threshold and therefore decides nothing, so here you must calculate. The exact future value is 5 000⋅(1.022+1.02+1)=15 302 euros. Interest on interest amounts to only 2 euros here, far too little for the missing 100 euros.
  • The series of payments is the better choice. False, and the upper linear bound is enough: 5 000⋅(11.02+11.04+11.06)≈14 426.63 euros is already below 14,500 euros; the exact present value is 14,419.42 euros. The comparison at the end shows the same: 14 500⋅1.023≈15 387.52 euros against 15,302 euros.
  • At a discount rate of 1% the series of payments would be the better choice. True, and the lower linear bound is enough: 5 000⋅(0.99+0.98+0.97)=14 700 euros is already above 14,500 euros; exactly, it is about 14,704.93 euros. The immediate amount itself is not discounted and stays what it is.

Two of the five decisions were made without calculation and two with the linear bounds of the present value. Only the future value had to be calculated exactly, because the threshold of 15,400 euros lies above its linear bound.

Your turn10 of 10

The choice is between 9,000 euros today and 10,000 euros in four years, and the discount rate is 3%. Claim: "The later payment is the better choice." Which decision together with its reason is correct?

Common mistakes

  • Calculating linearly instead of with compound interest. K0(1+ni) is only a lower bound for K0qn; used as the result, it underestimates every future value from the second period on.
  • Comparing amounts at different points in time directly. A higher nominal value or a larger sum of instalments decides nothing as long as the payments flow at different points in time.
  • Compounding one instalment too many or too few. For an ordinary annuity the exponents run from 0 to n−1 in the future value and from 1 to n in the present value. Formula 12 therefore gives qn−1q−1, not qn+1−1q−1.
  • Getting the direction of the present value wrong. Multiplying by qn instead of dividing gives a present value above the nominal value, which is impossible with a positive rate.
  • Measuring interest earned against the wrong amount. It is future value minus everything paid in: for a single investment minus K0, for an annuity minus n⋅R.
  • Overestimating compounding within the year. Crediting within the year brings more than yearly crediting, but at rates of a few percent and usual terms only a little; a difference of the order of the entire interest earned takes high rates over decades.

What to take away

  • Compounding: Kn=K0qn with q=1+i. Simple interest K0(1+ni) consists of the first two terms of K0qn; from n=2 on it lacks the interest on interest, and this gap grows.
  • Within the year: K0(1+im)mn; crediting within the year brings more than yearly crediting, but at small rates only a little more.
  • Discounting: K0=Knqn. The present value lies below the nominal value and falls with a higher rate and a later due date.
  • Comparing: only at a common point in time; which one it is does not change the order.
  • Annuity: the future value follows from formula 12 with a=R, r=q and n terms; the present value is this future value divided by qn and lies below n⋅R.
E=R⋅qn−1q−1,B=Eqn

Now practise it

Elementary Financial Mathematics (Elementare Finanzmathematik)

Trainer · Mathematics

Practise
Next: Elementary Probability (Elementare Wahrscheinlichkeitsrechnung)
0/10

Was this article helpful?