Checking Claims about Numbers
The tasks in this topic place five claims about real numbers or functions under a short assumption, and you decide which of them are correct. Correct means correct for every choice the assumption allows; a single admissible choice at which the claim fails refutes it. How to read implication, converse and quantifiers is explained in the article Statements and Implications.
This article supplies the material on which the claims stand or fall: the order on the real numbers, squares, roots and absolute values, and what an assumption about a function gives you. The formula sheet (Formelsammlung) contains none of these rules; you have to bring them along.
The order on the real numbers supplies the rules the claims are tested against
Almost every claim in this topic is a comparison, and four properties of the order stand behind the answers.
- Trichotomy. For two real numbers exactly one of the three relations , and holds. That is why the negation of is precisely , why never follows from , and why " or " fails to hold for every real number: zero satisfies neither part.
- Transitivity. If holds and holds as well, then holds too.
- Antisymmetry. If and hold at the same time, only equality is left for the two numbers.
- Splitting . The statement means the same as " and ", and equally the same as . In the other direction does not follow from alone, since expressly permits equality.
The second half concerns the arithmetic: what does an operation do to a comparison?
| To both sides of | Result | Condition |
|---|---|---|
| add the same number | none | |
| multiply by | ||
| multiply by | ||
| take reciprocals | or | |
| square |
The case is the most frequent of all: from follows . And the reciprocal rule really does need its condition. For and we have , yet is smaller than , because the two numbers lie on opposite sides of zero.
The sign rule follows from the same calculation: a product, and likewise a quotient, is positive precisely when the two numbers involved carry the same sign, and negative precisely when their signs differ. For the quotient there is the extra demand that the denominator not be zero, and an assumption such as aims at exactly that.
Two inequalities pointing the same way may be added: from and follows . You may multiply them when all numbers involved are positive: from and follows . Watch the sign while doing so. Since and are allowed to take the value , the number is reachable, and the strict version would be wrong: a promises less than a .
Your turn1 of 6
The real numbers and satisfy . Which inference is correct?
Squares, roots and absolute values lose the sign
The absolute value is itself when , and when . It is never negative, and it coincides with itself precisely when is not negative.
Squaring throws the sign away, and the root does not bring it back. The root always returns the non-negative value.
For we get and not . The rule that settles most claims in this topic hangs on that: from only follows, that is or , and equally does not follow from . The other direction is harmless: from it always follows that , since inserting produces the same expression twice.
Between square and absolute value there is a genuine equivalence: holds precisely when , because squaring increases strictly on the non-negative numbers. About the order of and themselves this says nothing: for and we have , while .
How much a power gives away about the sign depends on whether the exponent is even or odd.
| Exponent | From follows | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| even, such as or | a number and its opposite share the same power | |
| odd, such as or | such a power increases strictly on all of |
The same distinction answers the question about the number of solutions, which tasks often phrase as "exactly one" or "none".
- with has two solutions, namely and .
- has exactly one solution, : a product is zero only when one factor is zero, and here both factors are .
- with has no solution in , since a square is never negative.
- has exactly one solution for every , because the third power takes each value exactly once.
For the sum, holds. Equality occurs precisely when , that is when the two numbers do not point in opposite directions. For and the left side is and the right side is .
Your turn2 of 6
Which inference holds for all real numbers and ?
Your turn3 of 6
For which real numbers does the equation have exactly two real solutions?
What an assumption about a function gives you, and what it does not
Many tasks replace the numbers with functions and give away only two things about them: which values they may take and whether they are monotone. Exactly as much follows as is written there, and the claims live off claiming a little more.
If is given, every function value is positive, and nothing further. Positivity carries over to sum, product, quotient, reciprocal and square: all five are positive again, and the quotient is additionally always defined, because the denominator never becomes zero. It does not carry over to the difference, since the assumption says neither which of the two numbers is larger nor whether they differ at all. Nor does it say anything about sizes: a product of positive numbers is positive but can be smaller than each factor, for example .
The more frequent fallacy concerns the point: information about holds at the point and nowhere else. From nothing follows for another point . With and constantly , the value is smaller than , while at the point the value is larger.
A function is injective when different points have different values, that is when always follows from . Without such information you may not assume it: a constant function takes the same value at every point.
is strictly increasing when always follows from . Such a function is automatically injective, and the inference also runs backwards: from follows .
Both additions follow from the same reasoning, and it shows the contrapositive at work. Were , monotonicity would give , contradicting the assumption ; so only remains. Injectivity is the same inference for the equals sign: were the points different, one would be smaller, and then the values would differ as well.
Your turn4 of 6
The functions take positive values only. Which claim holds for every ?
Your turn5 of 6
Again take positive values only. Which claim can be refuted by a counterexample?
Five claims under time pressure
The task format demands five independent decisions. How many of them hold is open: all five may, and just as easily only one, but at least one always holds. Anyone who ends up calling all five wrong has got one of them wrong.
Marking is by partial credit. Full marks for a question go only to someone who ticks every claim that holds and none that does not. If more than one claim is correct, every correct tick earns a share and every wrong tick subtracts a share, and a question does not fall below zero; if only one is correct, the points come only for exactly that one tick, and any further tick sets the question to zero. A tick without a reason can therefore cost points you had already secured, and with only one correct claim all of them; tick what you can justify. A procedure that works:
- Read the assumption. Which letters are fixed, which are free, which values are excluded? An excluded value such as is usually the hinge of one of the five claims.
- Classify the claim. If-then, if and only if, for all, there is, and, or: every shape has its own refutation, and the shape is visible in the wording.
- Look for the counterexample first. It is cheaper than a proof, and if you find none, the search has usually already shown you which argument carries the claim.
- Try the standard values. The value exposes the zero product and the reciprocal, and the sign, and the square, a fraction such as the question of whether a number grows or shrinks when squared. For functions the constant functions and do the same service.
- Read the five claims against each other. Contrapositives share a truth value, exactly one of two mutual negations is correct, and two claims that differ only in the direction of an inequality sign cannot both be correct.
A full example. Let and be two real numbers with .
- If , then . Correct. Since , dividing by is allowed, and is what remains. Without that assumption the claim would be wrong, because for the equation holds for every .
- If , then . Wrong. The number satisfies the assumption and violates the conclusion; from the square only follows.
- It holds that . Correct. A square is never negative, and it becomes zero only at , which is excluded.
- If , then . Wrong. For and we have , yet is larger than : squaring reliably keeps the comparison only when neither number is negative.
- There is a with . Correct. The reciprocal does it, and it exists because is not zero.
Three of the five decisions hang on the same piece of information, namely on . That is typical for these tasks: what the assumption excludes is excluded because it would otherwise be the value at which the claim breaks.
Your turn6 of 6
Let and be real numbers with . Which claim is correct?
Common mistakes
- Overlooking the sign and the zero. The reciprocal rule flips a comparison only when both numbers have the same sign, and follows from only once is secured.
- Confusing with . A reachable bound refutes the strict version, not the loose one, and does not follow from .
- Carrying information from one point to another. What is said about holds at ; about nothing has been said.
What to take away
- Comparisons. Adding keeps an inequality sign, multiplying by a negative number flips it, and taking reciprocals flips it only when both numbers have the same sign.
- Square, root, absolute value. holds; from only follows, whereas gives .
- Functions. Positive values carry over to sum, product, quotient and reciprocal, but not to the difference, and information about holds only at the point .
Was this article helpful?