Equations (Gleichungen)

40 min · 12 drills

The tasks in this topic show an equation at the top, sometimes with a parameter or as a short word problem, and five claims about it underneath: how many solutions there are, which number is a solution, what a particular transformation yields, how large the sum or the product of the solutions is. The question asks which claims are correct, and the tick column is headed "Richtig". Most claims are settled as soon as you know the solution set. Some, however, aim at the route to it, and that is where the traps lie: a candidate outside the domain (Definitionsbereich), a squaring step that produces an extraneous solution (Scheinlösung), a factor that is never zero.

For this topic the formula sheet (Formelsammlung) gives you exactly one formula, formula (1) for the solutions of the quadratic equation ax2+bx+c=0 with a≠0. The discriminant (Diskriminante) is not listed as an entry of its own, but it is the expression b2−4ac under the square root in that formula. The sheet also has interval notation, but only for bounded intervals such as [a,b] and (a,b]; a domain such as [2,∞) you write yourself on the same pattern. Everything else is missing: the rules for equivalence transformations, Vieta’s formulas, the zero product, substitution, the binomial formulas, and how to handle fractions and square roots. You bring those yourself, and this article builds them up one by one.

A transformation is harmless if it can be undone

Solution set

The solution set (Lösungsmenge) L of an equation consists of all admissible numbers that turn the equation into a true statement when substituted. It can be empty, L=∅, it can contain individual numbers, and it can be the whole domain.

Equivalence transformation

An equivalence transformation (Äquivalenzumformung) turns an equation into a new one with exactly the same solution set. That works whenever the step can be reversed: if you add 4 to both sides, you can subtract the 4 again and arrive back at the original equation.

Whether a step is harmless you test with a single question: can it be undone for every x? Adding or subtracting a number passes this test, and multiplying by a number k passes it as long as k≠0, because then dividing by k undoes the step. It gets delicate as soon as a term with x is involved or a sign gets lost. Three examples show the three dangers.

  • Multiplying by a term that contains x. The equation x+3=5 has only the solution 2. Multiplied by x−1 it becomes (x+3)(x−1)=5(x−1), and this equation has the additional solution 1, because there the factor is zero and both sides give 0. The solution set can grow.
  • Dividing by a term that contains x. The equation (x−7)(x+2)=6(x−7) has the solutions 7 and 4. If you divide by x−7, you keep x+2=6, that is, only 4, and the solution 7 is lost. The right move is to bring everything to one side and factor: (x−7)(x+2−6)=(x−7)(x−4)=0.
  • Squaring. The equation 2x−1=x has only the solution 1. Squared, it becomes (2x−1)2=x2, that is, 3x2−4x+1=0 with the solutions 1 and 13. The reason: A2=B2 only implies A=B or A=−B, and 13 solves the second equation 2x−1=−x, not the given one. The solution set can grow.

This gives the working rule for the whole article: a step that may enlarge the solution set is allowed, provided you afterwards substitute every candidate into the original equation; this substitution is called the check (Probe). A step that may shrink it is allowed only if you examine the case where the term is zero separately, because no check brings back a lost solution.

Your turn1 of 12

Both sides of the equation x(x−5)=3x are divided by x. What happens to its solution set?

A linear equation has one solution, none, or every number as a solution

Every linear equation can be brought into the form ax=b by equivalence transformations: expand the brackets, move all terms with x to the left and all numbers to the right, combine like terms. In this way 5(x−1)=2x+7 becomes 5x−5=2x+7, then 3x=12 and x=4. Whether you may then divide by a decides the number of solutions.

CaseSolution set of ax=bwhat remains after rearranging
a≠0{ba}an equation that fixes x
a=0, b≠0∅a false statement without x
a=0, b=0the whole domainthe true statement 0=0

Whether a is zero is often not visible in the original equation, because the terms with x sometimes cancel only after expanding, even terms with x2. In (x+1)2=x2+2x+5 the left side is x2+2x+1 by the binomial formula; x2 and 2x drop out, and 1=5 remains, so there is no solution. In (x−3)(x+3)=x2−9 all terms cancel, 0=0 remains, and every real number is a solution. An equation that looks quadratic can thus turn into a statement without a variable, and its truth value then decides everything. So count solutions only once the equation has been rearranged.

If the equation contains fractions with numbers in the denominator, first multiply both sides by the common denominator (Hauptnenner), the least common multiple of the denominators. That is an equivalence transformation, because the common denominator is a nonzero number. Two traps lie in this step: every term is multiplied, including one without a fraction, and a minus sign in front of a fraction applies to the whole numerator, which therefore gets brackets.

x6−x−29=x3−2∣⋅183x−2(x−2)=6x−36x+4=6x−36x=8

Without the brackets, that is, with −2x−4 instead of −2x+4, you get 5x=32 and x=325. If you do not multiply the 2 on the right by 18, you get x+4=6x−2 and x=65. The check decides: for x=8 the left side is 43−23=23 and the right side 83−2=23.

Your turn2 of 12

What is the solution set of the equation 4(x+1)−(2x−3)=2(x+3)−5?

The discriminant decides how many solutions a quadratic equation has

For the quadratic equation ax2+bx+c=0 with a≠0, the formula sheet gives formula (1):

x1,2=−b±b2−4ac2a
Discriminant

The discriminant (Diskriminante) is the expression under the square root in formula (1): D=b2−4ac. In this article the letter D stands only for it; the domain is written D.

Why its sign fixes the number of solutions becomes clear once you split formula (1) into two parts:

x1,2=−b2a±D2a

The first part is a midpoint, the second a distance by which you step away from it to both sides. If D is positive, the distance is positive, and the two solutions lie symmetrically to the left and right of the midpoint. If D is zero, the distance is zero, and both coincide at the midpoint −b2a. If D is negative, there is no real square root of D, hence no distance and no real solution.

An example with every step: for 2x2+3x−2=0 we have a=2, b=3, c=−2. The discriminant is D=9−4⋅2⋅(−2)=9+16=25, the midpoint is −34, the distance 54, and the solutions are x1=12 and x2=−2. The most frequent slip lies in the sign of c: with c=−2, the term −4ac becomes positive. For −2x2+3x−4=0, on the other hand, a=−2 and c=−4, so D=9−4⋅(−2)⋅(−4)=9−32=−23; the equation has no real solution, and you need not calculate any further.

Two special cases do not need the formula at all. If the linear term is missing, as in 2x2−72=0, you have x2=36, and the solutions are ±6. If the constant term is missing, as in x2−4x=0, factor out x: x(x−4)=0 gives 0 and 4.

The case D=0 has a shape of its own: the left side is then, up to the factor a, a perfect square. For −3x2+30x−75=0 we get D=900−4⋅(−3)⋅(−75)=900−900=0. Factor out −3, and x2−10x+25 remains, which by the binomial formula (u−v)2=u2−2uv+v2, not on the formula sheet, equals (x−5)2: the outer terms x2 and 25 are the squares of x and 5, and the middle term is twice their product. So −3x2+30x−75=−3(x−5)2, and the only solution is x=5. The sign of the middle term fixes the sign inside the brackets: x2+10x+25=(x+5)2 would have the solution −5. Factoring out −3 is safe, because dividing by the number −3 is an equivalence transformation.

Your turn3 of 12

How many real solutions does the equation 4x2−12x+9=0 have?

The sum and the product of the solutions are already in the coefficients

Add the two solutions from formula (1), and the square roots cancel, leaving 2⋅(−b2a)=−ba. Multiply them, and the third binomial formula gives b2−D4a2=4ac4a2=ca. These are Vieta’s formulas (Satz von Vieta), and they are not on the formula sheet.

x1+x2=−bax1⋅x2=ca

Two points need attention. The sum carries a minus sign, the product does not. And both fractions have a in the denominator: only for a=1 is the sum simply −b and the product simply c. For 2x2+3x−2=0 from above, the sum is −32 and the product −22=−1, and indeed 12+(−2)=−32 and 12⋅(−2)=−1.

Vieta presupposes real solutions, that is, D≥0. At D=0 the single solution counts twice: for −3x2+30x−75=0 the formulas give the sum −30−3=10=5+5 and the product −75−3=25=5⋅5. Conversely, the formulas help with factoring: for x2+x−20=0 you look for two integers with product −20 and sum −1, and with −5 and 4 you have the factorization (x+5)(x−4).

Your turn4 of 12

The equation 2x2−6x−7=0 has two real solutions. What holds for their sum and their product?

With zero on the right, each factor is examined on its own

u⋅v=0⇔u=0 or v=0

If an equation is given in factored form, with zero on the right side, there is nothing to expand: each factor is set equal to zero on its own, and each yields its own solutions or none. For (2x−3)(x2−2x+2)=0 the first factor gives x=32. For the second, only the discriminant shows that it is never zero: D=4−8=−4<0. Expanded, the equation would have degree three, and yet it has exactly one real solution. The degree is only an upper bound for the number of solutions, not the number itself.

Watch the sign as well: the factor 2x−3 is zero at x=32, not at −32 and not at 3. And the rule needs the zero on the right. From (x−3)(x+2)=6 it by no means follows that x−3=6 or x+2=6; there you expand first, x2−x−12=0, with the solutions 4 and −3.

Double zero

A zero (Nullstelle) of a term is a number at which it takes the value 0. If the factorization contains the factor (x−r) exactly as (x−r)2, then r is called a double zero (doppelte Nullstelle) of the left side. As a solution of the equation, r still counts only once: the solution set is a set, and in a set each element appears once.

For (x2−4x)2=0, first factor the inner term: x2−4x=x(x−4), so the left side is x2(x−4)2. Both zeros, 0 and 4, are double. The equation has degree four, but only two distinct solutions, L={0,4}. Vieta’s formulas count a double zero twice, the solution set counts it once, and claims about the number of solutions almost always mean distinct solutions.

Your turn5 of 12

How many distinct real solutions does the equation (x+4)2(x2+2x+5)(3x−1)=0 have?

A substitution lowers the degree, and back-substitution fixes the count

If a term appears in an equation only as itself and as its square, replace it by a new unknown u, and the equation becomes quadratic in u. This technique is called substitution (Substitution). Then you substitute back, and this second step decides how many values of x one value of u yields. That depends solely on what u stands for.

SubstitutionSubstituting backvalues of x per value of u
u=x2x=±utwo for u>0, one for u=0, none for u<0
u=x3x=u3exactly one, also for u<0
u=xx=u2one for u≥0, none for u<0
u=2x−1x=u+12exactly one

For x6−7x3−8=0 set u=x3, because x6=(x3)2. This gives u2−7u−8=0 with u=8 and u=−1. Substituting back, x3=8 yields the solution 2 and x3=−1 the solution −1. A negative value of u is no reason to discard it here, because a cube can be negative; with u=x2 it would be.

Substituting back does not always give integers either. x6−9x3+14=0 becomes u2−9u+14=0 with u=2 and u=7, and from these x=23 and x=73. Both solutions are irrational, even though the values of u are integers. Whether a solution is an integer you therefore read off the values of x, not those of u.

The same approach works when a whole term recurs. In (2x−1)2−6(2x−1)+8=0 set u=2x−1 and obtain u2−6u+8=0 with u=2 and u=4. Back: 2x−1=2 gives x=32, and 2x−1=4 gives x=52. Which row of the table applies when substituting back is decided by the recurring term, not by the equation in u.

Your turn6 of 12

What is the solution set of the equation x6+7x3−8=0?

In a cubic equation, one guessed solution brings the rest

For equations of degree three there is no formula in the exam. Usually the task is built so that an integer solution exists, and for an equation x3+bx2+cx+d=0 with integer coefficients every integer solution must be a divisor of d. Try these divisors in turn, positive and negative.

For x3−x2−x−2=0 the candidates are ±1 and ±2. Substituting gives −3 both at 1 and at −1, but 8−4−2−2=0 at 2. So the factor (x−2) is contained in the left side, and the rest is quadratic. You find the second factor by polynomial division or by comparing coefficients in (x−2)(x2+mx+n): expanded, this gives x3+(m−2)x2+(n−2m)x−2n, hence n=1 and m=1.

x3−x2−x−2=(x−2)(x2+x+1)

You examine the quadratic factor with the discriminant: D=1−4=−3<0, so it is never zero. The equation of degree three therefore has exactly one real solution, x=2. Only the factorization shows how many solutions there are; the degree alone does not.

If the constant term is missing, x=0 is already the guessed solution, and factoring replaces trial. 2x3−7x2+3x=0 becomes x(2x2−7x+3)=x(2x−1)(x−3)=0 with the three solutions 0, 12 and 3. x3+2x=0 becomes x(x2+2)=0, and since x2+2 is never zero, only x=0 remains.

Your turn7 of 12

How many real solutions does the equation x3+x2−4x+6=0 have?

In a fractional equation the domain comes first

Domain

The domain (Definitionsbereich) D of an equation contains all numbers for which both sides have a value. For a fraction, the zeros of the denominator drop out; for a square root, the numbers for which the expression under the radical sign is negative. A solution must lie in the domain; a candidate outside it is not a solution, whatever the calculation produced.

So write the domain down before you calculate. In a fractional equation (Bruchgleichung), an equation with x in a denominator, this is the first step. In 2xx−5=50x2−5x the second denominator is x(x−5), so D=R∖{0,5}. Multiplying by the common denominator x(x−5) is allowed only on D, because there it is not zero, and it gives 2x⋅x=50, that is, x2=25 with the candidates 5 and −5. The candidate 5 is not in D, and L={−5} remains. The check confirms it: the left side is −10−10=1, the right side 5025+25=1. The same holds when you cancel a fraction: the cancelled expression has a value at the excluded point, the original equation does not, and a candidate there is not a solution.

If there are different denominators containing x, multiply by their common denominator, just as with numbers in the denominator, and again multiply every term, including one without a fraction. A forgotten term falsifies the equation, and a candidate from the falsified equation says nothing about the given one.

Your turn8 of 12

What is the solution set of the equation x3−3x2−4xx+1=0?

In a radical equation the check decides

In a radical equation (Wurzelgleichung), x stands under a radical sign. The square root is removed by squaring, and squaring can add solutions. The procedure therefore has four fixed steps: determine the domain, isolate the square root on one side, square, substitute every candidate into the original equation. A candidate rejected by this check is called an extraneous solution (Scheinlösung).

For x2+9=2x−3 the expression under the radical sign is never negative, so D=R. Squaring gives x2+9=4x2−12x+9, hence 3x2−12x=3x(x−4)=0 with the candidates 0 and 4. The check separates them: at x=4 the left side is 25=5 and the right side 5. At x=0 the left side is 9=3 and the right side −3. The candidate 0 is still not a solution, because a square root is never negative. The solution set is {4}. Since every real number lies in the domain here, only the check can filter out this candidate.

You can also spot the extraneous solution in advance: a square root is never negative, so the right side must satisfy 2x−3≥0, that is, x≥32, and that rules out x=0 without substituting.

If two square roots appear in the equation, each expression under a radical sign must be nonnegative, and both conditions must hold at once. For x−2⋅x+14=15 the square roots require x≥2 and x≥−14; together they mean x≥2, so D=[2,∞). A product of two square roots disappears with one squaring: (x−2)(x+14)=225, hence x2+12x−253=0 with the candidates 11 and −23. The candidate −23 is not in D, and L={11} remains, as the check 9⋅25=15 confirms. Had you first combined the square roots into (x−2)(x+14), −23 would have seemed admissible, because there the product under the radical sign is positive.

With a sum or difference of two square roots, the situation is different. By the binomial formula, (A±B)2=A±2AB+B, and the mixed term 2AB carries a radical sign again. The usual route: isolate one square root on one side, square, isolate the remaining radical term on one side, square a second time. Each of these steps can add candidates, and the check at the end is compulsory.

Sometimes a look at the signs saves the calculation. In x+1=−x2−1 the left side, being a square root, is never negative, while the right side is at most −1 for every x. The two sides can never be equal, and the equation has no solution, without any squaring.

Your turn9 of 12

What is the solution set of the equation 2x2−7=x+1?

A parameter shifts the discriminant and sometimes the degree

If the equation contains a parameter, it describes many equations at once, and the claims ask for which values which case occurs. For x2+kx+k+8=0 we have a=1, b=k and c=k+8, so D=k2−4(k+8)=k2−4k−32=(k−8)(k+4). Here the discriminant is itself a quadratic expression in k, with the zeros −4 and 8.

ParameterDiscriminantSolutions
k<−4 or k>8D>0two distinct
k=−4 or k=8D=0exactly one, x=2 or x=−4 respectively
−4<k<8D<0none

The trap lies in the shape of the ranges: as an expression in k, D describes an upward-opening parabola, so the values with two solutions lie outside, on both sides, and those without a solution lie in between. Check the boundary values by substituting: at k=8 the equation becomes x2+8x+16=(x+4)2=0, at k=−4 it becomes x2−4x+4=(x−2)2=0.

If the parameter stands in front of x2, it can lower the degree, and formula (1) then does not apply, because it requires a≠0. So check this value first. In (m−3)x2−12=0 the coefficient of x2 becomes zero at m=3, and −12=0 remains: no solution. For m≠3 you have x2=12m−3. For m>3 the right side is positive, and there are two solutions ±12m−3; for m<3 it is negative, and there are none. Exactly one solution occurs for no value of m, because the right side is never zero.

Your turn10 of 12

For which values of the parameter k does x2+kx+16=0 have no real solution?

A word problem becomes an equation before any calculation

In word problems the claims often ask about the equation that was set up. So first fix what the unknown stands for, and then translate sentence by sentence. Tank A holds 120 litres, tank B 30 litres. Every minute 5 litres are pumped from A to B. After how many minutes does A hold 40 litres more than B?

  • Fix the unknown. x is the number of minutes until that moment.
  • Express both amounts in x. A then holds 120−5x litres and B 30+5x litres; what A loses, B gains.
  • Translate the comparison into an equation. "A holds 40 litres more than B" means: the smaller amount plus 40 gives the larger one, so 120−5x=(30+5x)+40. Before calculating, check which side the 40 belongs to: it is added to the amount that is smaller.
  • Solve and interpret. 120−5x=70+5x gives 10x=50, so x=5. Then A holds 95 litres and B 55 litres, and 95−55=40 confirms the result.

Pay attention to what is asked: the number x=5 is a time in minutes, while the amount in A at that moment is 95 litres. And the context can rule out a solution of the equation. If two consecutive natural numbers have the product 132, then n(n+1)=132 leads to n2+n−132=0 with D=529=232 and the solutions 11 and −12. Only n=11 is a natural number; the numbers sought are 11 and 12.

Your turn11 of 12

Account A holds 900 euros, account B 300 euros. Every month 50 euros are transferred from A to B. After x months, A is to hold twice as much as B. Which equation describes this?

Five claims under time pressure

The task format demands five independent decisions, and at least one claim is always correct. Scoring uses partial credit: every correct tick earns a share, every wrong one deducts a share, and a question never drops below zero. If only one claim is correct, the points come only for exactly that one tick, and any further tick sets the question to zero. With equations a fixed routine pays off, because many of the five claims depend on the same solution set.

  1. Note the domain. Denominators and square roots first; this step costs seconds and in fractional and radical equations often decides several claims.
  2. Recognize the type. Linear, quadratic, factored, with substitution, cubic, with a fraction, with a square root, with a parameter: each type has its own procedure from this article.
  3. Determine the solution set completely. Strike out candidates outside D, do the check after squaring, substitute back after a substitution.
  4. Test cheap claims by substitution. "x=r is a solution" you decide in seconds without solving the equation, provided r lies in D.
  5. Read counting words exactly. "exactly one", "exactly two distinct", "none": double zeros count once, numbers outside D not at all.

The table summarizes which procedure belongs to which shape and where the claims usually take hold.

ShapeProceduretypical trap
linear after rearrangingrearrange, divide by aa=0: none or every number
ax2+bx+c=0formula (1), D firstsign in −4ac
sum, product of the solutionsVietasum −ba with minus, denominator a
product =0set each factor to zerofactor without a zero, double zero
a term and its squareinsert u, substitute backhow many x one u yields
degree threetry divisors of d, split offquadratic remainder without a zero
x in a denominatornote D, multiply by the common denominatorcandidate outside D
x under a square rootD, isolate, square, checkextraneous solution, second square root

A complete example. Consider the equation x−2x−8=0 with x∈R. Since x=(x)2 for x≥0, the substitution u=x fits: it gives u2−2u−8=0 with D=4+32=36 and the values u=4 and u=−2. Because x is never negative, only u=4 leads back, namely to x=16. So L={16}.

  • The domain is [0,∞). Correct. Under the radical sign stands x, and it must not be negative.
  • The substitution u=x leads to u2−2u−8=0. Correct. x is (x)2=u2, and 2x becomes 2u.
  • The equation has exactly two solutions. False. The value u=−2 requires x=−2, which no number satisfies; one solution remains.
  • x=4 is a solution. False. 4 is a value of u, not of x. Substituting gives 4−2⋅2−8=−8≠0.
  • x=16 is a solution. Correct. Substituting gives 16−2⋅4−8=0.

The claim about the number of solutions hinges on the discarded value u=−2, the two claims about individual numbers hinge on substituting back, x=u2. That is typical: the false claims are almost always the result of a route on which one step from this article is missing.

Your turn12 of 12

Consider the equation x+6=x. Which claim is correct?

Common mistakes

  • Dividing by a term with x. The solution at which the term is zero gets lost. Bring everything to one side, factor, and apply the zero product.
  • Copying the sign in Vieta or forgetting a. The sum of the solutions is −ba, the product ca.
  • Computing −4ac with the wrong sign. If a and c have different signs, −4ac is positive, and the discriminant grows.
  • Confusing the degree with the number of solutions. A factor with a negative discriminant has no zero, a value of u may lead to no x, and a double zero counts once in the solution set.
  • Forgetting the domain. A candidate that makes a denominator zero is not a solution, even if it comes from a correct calculation; after cancelling, the denominator is no longer visible.
  • Skipping the check after squaring. A candidate can lie in the domain and still set a square root equal to a negative number.
  • Confusing u and x. After a substitution the values of u are not yet the solutions; sum, product, count and being an integer refer to the values of x.
  • Translating a comparison the wrong way round. With "… more than" and "… times as much as", the extra amount or the factor belongs to the smaller quantity; checking with the numbers found shows at once whether the equation matches the text.

Key takeaways

  • Equivalence transformations can be undone: adding a number, and multiplying by a number k≠0. Multiplying by a term in x and squaring can add solutions; dividing by a term in x can remove some.
  • ax=b has exactly one solution for a≠0; for a=0 it has none or every number of the domain, depending on whether b≠0 or b=0.
  • Formula (1) is on the formula sheet; the expression under its square root, D=b2−4ac, counts the solutions: two, one, none.
  • Vieta is not there: x1+x2=−ba and x1⋅x2=ca.
  • Fractions and square roots: the domain first, the check last.
u⋅v=0⇔u=0 or v=0

Now practise it

Equations (Gleichungen)

Trainer · Mathematics

Practise
Next: Linear Equations in Two Unknowns (Lineare Gleichungen mit zwei Unbekannten)
0/12

Was this article helpful?