Editing

22 min · 11 drills

Editing is worth 5 points of the twenty in Language in Use, and it is the one task on the exam where the right answer is sometimes a tick rather than a word.

Three worked examples

On the real sheet three lines come solved for you, before the first scored one. The extra word goes into the right-hand column, exactly as it is printed. This is what that looks like.

LineAnswer
0. Every Saturday she set up a small stall behind the old fountain.✓
00. She soon developed the confidence, one sale at a time.the
000. She mentioned about the sale to everyone waiting near her stall.about
  • 0: ✓, nothing to strike out, the line stands exactly as it is.
  • 00: the is the extra word, because confidence here takes no article.
  • 000: about is the extra word, because mention takes its object directly.

The first line

From here on it is your text. Mira has been selling second-hand clothes at the Saturday market for almost a year.

Your turnBelow exam level1 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Below exam level
  1. 01

The rule and the table

The clean line. A line with no extra word scores exactly as much as a corrected one, and there are two to four of them in every ten. What it looks like: subject and predicate occur once each, every article and preposition has work to do, and there is nothing to strike out.

The rule behind the first line is worked through above. A summary of the rules of the task:

What you see in the lineWhat to strike out
the before an abstract idea nothing points atthe
the subject named twice, the second time by a pronounit, he, they
which, who or that, but only one verb in the linewhich
a preposition right after the verb, the object already thereabout, on, to, with
because or although at the front, so in the second halfso, but
been next to was or werebeen
none of the abovenothing, answer ✓

Lines 2–3

Two more lines of the same text, and in each of them the extra word hides somewhere else in the sentence.

Your turn2 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 02

A line like this is settled by asking what each word in it is doing there. Read the next line to the end before you strike anything.

Your turn3 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 03

Lines 4–7

Four more lines of the same text.

Your turn4 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 04

The check does not change from line to line: the extra word is the one with no work to do in the sentence. One more line from Mira's story.

Your turn5 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 05

A line is judged as a whole sentence, so it is read to its full stop before any single word in it is. The next line of the same text.

Your turnAbove exam level6 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Above exam level
  1. 06

Each line gets the same question afresh, whatever the lines before it held.

Your turnAbove exam level7 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Above exam level
  1. 07

Lines 8–10

Three lines of Mira's story are left.

Your turn8 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 08

What a line holds is told by its own words, never by the lines around it. The next line of the same text.

Your turn9 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 09

The last line of Mira's story, and the same check.

Your turn10 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 10

Ten lines done: eight mistakes, two clean lines, and three of the rules came up twice, each time with the account right after the answer. Next comes a check with none of that support.

The last pass, on a different text

Now as on the real sheet: ten lines of one text in a row, with no account after each line. The line-by-line account comes after you check. The text is new: neighbours are putting a garden on the roof of their building. Three of its lines break rules the table above does not hold; the section after this one names them.

Your turn11 of 11

Click the word that does not belong. If the line is correct as it stands, choose “no extra word”.

Exam level
  1. 01
  2. 02
  3. 03
  4. 04
  5. 05
  6. 06
  7. 07
  8. 08
  9. 09
  10. 10

What to take with you

Points for the text5
Lines in the exam10 scored + 3 unscored examples (0, 00, 000)
Clean lines2 to 4 out of ten
What you writethe extra word exactly as printed, or ✓

The table above covers the patterns the lines of this article were built on. Real texts plant other extra words as well, and each of them is a rule you can check, not a guess:

What you see in the lineWhat to strike out
more before an -er form, most before an -est formmore, most
both in front of three or more thingsboth
each right before a plural nouneach
of between most or many and a bare plural nounof
do or to between can, will, must and another verbdo, to
have or has beside a finished time (last spring, in 2019)have, has
been between have, has, had and a third form, when the subject does the actionbeen
been right after is or arebeen
up or out after a verb that needs no particleup, out
a or an before a noun you cannot count (advice, news)a, an
a sentence that opens with Although or Because and has no second halfAlthough, Because
or after a list already closed by andor

Two of these need a second look before you strike. A line that opens with Because and ends at the full stop is a fragment only when nothing else in it could be the main clause: Because the bus was late. is one, Because the bus was late, we walked. is not. And of after most is extra only before a bare plural noun: in most of days it is extra, in most of the days and most of them it is not.

The articles the lines point to:

Articles: when a noun needs no the at all Relative clauses: one subject, and a which with work to do Prepositions after a verb: when the object already holds the slot Connectors: one clause, one master The passive: where been sits on the ladder of tenses Tenses: the present perfect takes no date Adjectives: one marker of comparison, not two

Now practise it

Editing

Trainer · Language in Use

Practise
Next: Letter-Hint Cloze (Buchstaben-Lückentext)
0/11

Was this article helpful?