Which method? Differential calculus

11 min · 4 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 3 Differentialrechnung

That the tasks in this chapter need a derivative, you see at once. What you do not see is what to take it of and what to do with it next.

Here is how it looks. A cheese dairy has costs K(x)=x3−6x2+15x+32 GE (money units), where x is hundreds of kilograms of cheese a week. These costs come with two tasks:

  1. The cheese sells at the market price of 51 GE per hundred kilograms. How much should the dairy make?
  2. Down to what price is it still worth the dairy working, at least for a short time?

Both have a price and costs, and in both you are tempted to take the marginal cost K′(x)=3x2−12x+15.

In the first that is all it takes: the price is set equal to K′(x), from 3x2−12x+15=51 comes x2−4x−12=0 and x=6 hundred kilograms. In the second you reach for the lowest point of K′: it lies at x=2 and equals 3 GE. But at a price of 3 the cheese does not even cover its variable costs: at two hundred kilograms they come to kv(2)=4−12+15=7 GE per hundred kilograms. What is needed is the minimum of average variable cost kv(x)=x2−6x+15: it lies at x=3 and equals 6 GE. The costs are the same; the question chose the method: how much at a given price, or down to what price at all.

So the page runs in this order:

  • the decision table: the method from the words of the task;
  • two almost identical questions with different methods;
  • the pairs that get mixed up most often;
  • each method on a short task, with the first line of its solution and a link to the full solution;
  • four tasks to practise on.

The decision table

With the cheese dairy, the words “down to what price” gave the method away. The table collects such words for all methods of the chapter:

How you recognise itMethod
An expression in brackets raised to a power, under a root, under ln⁡ or in the exponent of e; the derivative at a point is asked forDerivative of a nested function at a point
Two factors with x, one with e or ln⁡; the value of the derivative at a point is asked forDerivative of a product with an exponential or a logarithm
A root inside a root, “momentane Änderungsrate”Nested roots: write them as one power and differentiate
x in the base and in the exponentDerivative when x is in the base and the exponent
Market price given, a cost function, the quantity or the profit is asked forHow much to produce at the market price: maximum profit
“Betriebsminimum”, “Betriebsoptimum”, lowest price, smallest unit costDown to which price to produce: shutdown point and optimum point
Ordering cost and storage cost, the order quantity or the interval is asked forHow much per order: cost-minimising order quantity
“Um wie viel Prozent”, “elastisch”, “einheitselastisch”By how many percent: elasticity at a point
Asked: at which x or in which month the value is largest; the function has e or ln⁡Maximum of a function with e or ln: at which x it is largest
“Welche Aussagen sind richtig?” about rising, extrema, curvatureWhich statements about extrema are true
A demand function, a single supplierMaximum profit of the monopolist: price and quantity

Reads the same, different method

The decision table above finds the method from the words of the task. Sometimes, though, two tasks share almost all their words. Here the difference is one word in the question. Demand for a good is x(p)=1200−30p, the price is now 16 €, and 720 pieces are sold. Two questions about this demand are almost the same.

Task ATask B
Question“Um wie viele Stück sinkt die Nachfrage ungefähr, wenn der Preis um 1 € steigt?” (by about how many pieces does demand fall if the price rises by 1 €?)“Um wie viel Prozent sinkt die Nachfrage ungefähr, wenn der Preis um 1 % steigt?” (by about what percentage does demand fall if the price rises by 1 %?)
Deciding word“Stück” and “1 €”: units“Prozent” and “1 %”: percentages
Methodvalue of the derivativeelasticity at a point
First stepx′(p)=−30ε=−30⋅16720
Answerby 30 piecesby 0.67 %

The derivative is the same, −30. In task B it is multiplied by px as well, and without that factor the answer comes out 45 times too large. If the question says “Prozent”, the factor px is what is missing after the derivative.

The pairs people mix up

The word “Prozent” settled one pair. A few more pairs get mixed up so often that they deserve a look of their own. The first of them you already know from the cheese dairy.

Marginal, average and average variable cost.

Marginal K′(x)Average K(x)xAverage variable K(x)−K(0)x
what the next piece costsall cost per piecewithout fixed cost
minimum at the inflection point of Kminimum: “Betriebsoptimum”minimum: “Betriebsminimum”

Write down the right function before you differentiate.

Market price or monopoly.

Market priceMonopoly
price equals marginal costthe price depends on the quantity; marginal revenue equals marginal cost

ax or xa. x3 becomes 3x2, but 3x becomes 3xln⁡3. The result of the wrong rule is usually among the answers.

Point or value. “In welchem Monat” (in which month) asks where the maximum is, “wie hoch ist der größte Umsatz” (how high is the largest revenue) asks for the function value there.

Every method on one example

The pairs showed where the methods part. Below each method stands on its own: a short task and the first line of the solution, which shows at once whether the path is right.

Chain rule at a point

  • Task. “Berechnen Sie die Steigung von f(x)=(x2+3)4 an der Stelle x=1” (find the slope of f at this point).
  • First step. f′(1)=4⋅(1+3)3⋅2⋅1=4⋅64⋅2=512.
  • Worked through in: Derivative of a nested function at a point

Product with an exponential or a logarithm

  • Task. Given f(x)=x2ln⁡x. “Wie groß ist f′(e)?” (what is f′(e)?)
  • First step. f′(x)=2xln⁡x+x2⋅1x=2xln⁡x+x, so f′(e)=2e+e=3e≈8.15.
  • Worked through in: Derivative of a product with an exponential or a logarithm

Nested roots as one power

  • Task. Find the “momentane Änderungsrate” (instantaneous rate of change) of f(x)=xx at x=16.
  • First step. xx=x3/2, its root is x3/4, f′(x)=0.75 x−1/4 and f′(16)=0.75⋅0.5=0.375.
  • Worked through in: Nested roots: write them as one power and differentiate

x in the base and in the exponent

  • Task. Find the derivative of f(x)=xx at x=2.
  • First step. xx=exln⁡x, f′(x)=xx (ln⁡x+1), f′(2)=4 (ln⁡2+1)≈6.77.
  • Worked through in: Derivative when x is in the base and the exponent

Maximum profit at the market price

  • Task. “Der Marktpreis beträgt 39 GE” (the market price is 39 GE; GE, Geldeinheiten, money units), the cost is K(x)=x3−12x2+60x+50. At which quantity is profit largest?
  • First step. 39=K′(x)=3x2−24x+60, so x2−8x+7=0, roots 1 and 7; take the larger one, where K′ is rising: x=7.
  • Worked through in: How much to produce at the market price: maximum profit

Shutdown point and efficient scale

  • Task. The cost is K(x)=0.1x3−3x2+40x+250. Where is the “Betriebsminimum” (shutdown point), and what is the “kurzfristige Preisuntergrenze” (short-run price floor)?
  • First step. kv(x)=0.1x2−3x+40, minimum at x=15, price floor kv(15)=17.5 €.
  • Worked through in: Down to which price to produce: shutdown point and optimum point

For the “Betriebsoptimum” (efficient scale) take the minimum of average total cost K(x)x, fixed cost included.

Optimal order quantity

  • Task. A shop sells 4500 bags of cement a year at an even rate. One order costs 60 €, storing one bag for a year 1.50 €. What is the “optimale Bestellmenge” (optimal order quantity)?
  • First step. x∗=2⋅60⋅45001.5=360000=600 bags.
  • Worked through in: How much per order: cost-minimising order quantity

Elasticity at a point

  • Task. Demand is x(p)=800−20p. “Ist die Nachfrage bei p=25 elastisch?” (is demand elastic at this price?)
  • First step. ε=x′(p)⋅px(p)=−20⋅25300=−1.67; its absolute value is above 1, demand is elastic.
  • Worked through in: By how many percent: elasticity at a point

Maximum of a function with e or ln

  • Task. The extra profit from an advertising campaign lasting x weeks is f(x)=90 x2e−x. “Bei welcher Dauer ist er maximal?” (for which length is it largest?)
  • First step. f′(x)=90 (2x−x2) e−x=0; e−x is never zero, so x (2−x)=0 with roots 0 and 2; at x=0 the value is 0, which is the minimum, so x=2.
  • Worked through in: Maximum of a function with e or ln: at which x it is largest

Statements about extrema

  • Task. About f(x)=x3−6x2+9x: “Welche Aussagen sind richtig?” (which statements are true?) Among them “f hat bei x=1 ein Maximum” (a maximum at that point) and “f ist auf (2,4) konvex” (convex on that interval).
  • First step. f′(x)=3(x−1)(x−3), f′′(x)=6x−12; f′′(1)=−6<0, so there is a maximum at x=1, and f′′(x)>0 for x>2, so f is convex on (2,4): both statements are true.
  • Worked through in: Which statements about extrema are true

If the price falls with quantity along a demand function and there is a single supplier, it is the monopoly from the chapter on functions: marginal revenue equals marginal cost.

Practise recognising

In the examples above the method was named in the heading. Below it is not. Read each task below as in the first half minute of the exam: what do you differentiate, and what happens next? Ask the task what is asked for (a value, a point, a price, a percentage) and which words name the method.

Your turn1 of 4

A firm sells each unit for 50 € and can sell any quantity at this price. Its cost is K(x)=0.01x3−0.6x2+20x+400. At what quantity is the profit largest?

Your turn2 of 4

The demand function is p(x)=120−0.5x, the cost is K(x)=20x+800. Which price brings the largest profit?

Your turn3 of 4

The turnover of a new product in month t is U(t)=400 t e−0.2t. In which month is it largest?

Your turn4 of 4

A firm's cost is K(x)=0.5x3−4x2+15x+160. Down to what price does the firm still produce in the short run?

Now practise it

Practice exercises

Trainer · Differential calculus

Practise
Next: The integral: how much builds up when only the rate is known
0/4

Was this article helpful?