You look for the break-even point when the price is already known. Often, though, the seller chooses the price, and then the question is a different one: at which price is the revenue or the profit largest?
Imagine a rental that hires out 40 bikes a day at 15 €. The owner knows that every extra euro on the price drives away two customers. If he raises the price, each bike brings in more, but fewer go out. He tries a few prices:
Price per day, €
15
16
17
18
19
Bikes hired out
40
38
36
34
32
Revenue, €
600
608
612
612
608
Written as a formula, the revenue becomes a parabola. Its vertex gives the exact price, 17.50 €, without any derivative:
This article contains three tasks of this kind: the price rises in steps, the market sets the price, the single supplier sets the price. In all three the profit or the revenue is a parabola, and the answer lies at its vertex. Cost K, revenue E (“Erlös”), profit G (“Gewinn”), demand and the vertex of a parabola are explained in the article “What a function is: cost, revenue, profit and demand”.
Maximum revenue with price steps: how many steps to take
The rental in the introduction moved its price one euro at a time, and each step cost two customers. The exam task about a car wash is built the same way:
Exam-style task
Wie viele Wagen wäscht eine Waschstraße pro Tag, wenn der Preis einer Wäsche so gewählt wird, dass die Tageseinnahmen maximal sind? Derzeit kostet eine Wäsche 980 GE, und täglich werden 65 Wagen gewaschen. Der Betreiber rechnet damit, dass jede Preiserhöhung um 28 GE eine Wäsche pro Tag kostet.
a)35
b)15
c)42
d)49
e)50
In this task the price changes in steps, but the question asks for the number of cars, not the price.
How to recognise the task. You are given a starting price and a starting quantity, plus a rule like “jede Erhöhung um 5 GE kostet eine Buchung” (every increase by 5 GE costs one booking; GE are “Geldeinheiten”, money units) or “jede Senkung um 2 GE bringt drei Kunden mehr” (every cut by 2 GE brings three more customers). You are asked for the price with the largest revenue, the quantity there or the revenue itself.
The whole trick: work in the number of steps n, that is the number of price increases. Then price and quantity both depend linearly on n, and their product, the revenue E(n), is a parabola an2+bn+c that opens downwards. Its vertex (“Scheitel”):
n=−2ab
In the task above it starts at 980 GE and 65 cars; one step means +28 GE and −1 car.
today (n = 0)n = 1: 28 GE dearer, one car fewern = 15revenue largest
Step 1 of 4Set the steps
After n increases a wash costs 980+28n GE, and 65−n cars are washed: 28n is 28 GE for each of the n steps. In the picture the next step takes one price step, n=1: the point on the demand line moves one car to the left and 28 GE up.
E(n)=(980+28n)(65−n)=63700+840n−28n2.
n=−2⋅(−28)840=15 steps.
Price 980+15⋅28=1400 GE, 65−15=50 cars washed, revenue 1400⋅50=70000 GE. The question asked for the number of cars: 50.
A rental with exact numbers: it has 180 bikes. At 28 € a day, 60 % of them are hired out on average. Every price increase of 1 € leaves two more bikes in the yard. At what price is the revenue largest? In the picture in example 2 below the revenue is the area of the rectangle “price × quantity” under the demand line; the steps move the point along the line.
today (n = 0)n = 1: 1 € dearer, two bikes fewern = 13revenue largest
Step 1 of 4Set the steps
Today 0.6⋅180=108 bikes are hired out. After n increases the price is 28+n, the quantity 108−2n. In the picture the next step takes one price step, n=1: the point on the demand line moves two bikes to the left and 1 € up.
E(n)=(28+n)(108−2n)=3024+52n−2n2.
n=−2⋅(−2)52=13 steps.
Price 28+13=41 €, hired out 108−26=82 bikes, revenue 41⋅82=3362 €. The task asked for the price: 41 €.
If the price is cut. With “jede Senkung um …” (every cut by …) the price after n steps is p0−sn and the quantity x0+tn. An example: at 200 €, 50 pieces are sold, and every cut by 5 € brings 3 buyers. E(n)=(200−5n)(50+3n)=10000+350n−15n2, vertex n=30350≈11.67. A step is always a whole number, so compare the neighbours: E(11)=145⋅83=12035, E(12)=140⋅86=12040. Best are 12 cuts, price 140 €.
Four more cases appear in the tasks:
the vertex is negative: then it pays to move the price the other way; work it out again with increases instead of cuts, or the other way round;
the price is per person, but the customers come in pairs: if a step costs one pair, there are 2 people fewer;
the task names a cost per person or a rent, but asks for the revenue: the cost does not enter the calculation;
the revenue is given instead of the quantity: quantity = revenue / price, for example 3150/75=42.
Trap. Giving the number of steps as the answer: 13 instead of the price 41 €. The second mistake: starting with 180 bikes instead of 108; then the whole parabola is wrong.
In short, to review:
Steps: Set the steps → Set up the revenue → Find the vertex → Give the quantity asked for.
Formula sheet (“Formelsammlung”, the printed sheet): vertex of a parabola, S=−2ab, where a and b are the numbers in front of x2 and x, and S is the x of the vertex.
Memorise: Revenue is price times quantity, and both are expressed through the number of steps n.
Your turn1 of 3
A sauna charges 8 € entry and has 240 guests a day at that price. Every increase by 2 € costs 8 guests. At what entry price is the revenue largest?
Profit at the market price: how much to produce
The rental and the car wash chose their own price. If the market sets the price, it cannot be moved. All that is left to choose is the quantity:
Exam-style task
Ein Steinbruch verkauft Schotter zum Weltmarktpreis, den er hinnehmen muss. Die Tageskosten für x Tonnen betragen
K(x)==0.04x2++26x++2830
Der Betrieb fördert gewinnmaximal x=320 Tonnen am Tag. Welchen Preis (in GE) erzielt eine Tonne?
a)45.0
b)47.6
c)51.6
d)38.8
e)3.3
Here the price comes from the market and does not depend on the quantity, and the cost is quadratic. What is unusual is the direction: the quantity with the largest profit, 320 tonnes, is already given, and the price that led to it is what you need.
How to recognise the task. The firm sells at a price it cannot influence (“zum Marktpreis”, at the market price; “unabhängig von der Menge”, independent of the quantity): a price taker (“Preisnehmer”). The cost is quadratic, K(x)=ax2+bx+c, or you get the marginal cost, the cost of one more piece (in the task K′(x)), or the unit cost Kˉ(x) (“Stückkosten”). You are asked for the profit-maximising quantity, the profit itself or, conversely, the market price at a known quantity.
At a given price p the revenue is the line p⋅x and the profit G(x)=px−K(x) is again a downward parabola, whose vertex gives the quantity (how to find the vertex is shown in the section “Parabola: zeros and vertex”). For K(x)=ax2+bx+c the profit is G(x)=−ax2+(p−b)x−c, and the vertex lies at
x=2ap−b
A short rule gives the same quantity: at the maximum the price equals the marginal cost (“Grenzkosten”), the cost of one more piece. With quadratic cost it is 2ax+b, and p=2ax+b again gives x=2ap−b. Tasks write the marginal cost as K′(x); the prime means the derivative, which the chapter “Differential calculus” explains.
First the usual forward route, from price to quantity. A candle maker supplies drugstore chains at a set price of 17.1 GE (money units) per box, and its cost for x boxes is K(x)=0.02x2+11x+170. Which production quantity maximises profit?
Step 1 of 3Write down the profit
G(x)=17.1x−(0.02x2+11x+170)=−0.02x2+6.1x−170.
x=−2⋅(−0.02)6.1=152.5 boxes. Check: the marginal cost 2⋅0.02⋅152.5+11=17.1, which is the price.
The question asked for the quantity: 152.50 boxes. The profit there is G(152.5)=295.125 GE.
A firm sells at the market price of 40 €, and its cost is K(x)=0.02x2+16x+3000. What is the largest profit it can make?
G(x)=40x−(0.02x2+16x+3000)=−0.02x2+24x−3000.
x=−2⋅(−0.02)24=600 pieces. Check: the marginal cost 2⋅0.02⋅600+16=40, which is the price.
G(600)=−7200+14400−3000=4200 €.
This is the task from the sheet above. A quarry sells gravel at the world market price, its daily cost is K(x)=0.04x2+26x+2830 for x tonnes, and it extracts 320 tonnes a day for maximum profit. What price does it get per tonne?
At the maximum the price equals the marginal cost, p=2ax+b. Going forwards you plug in p and look for x; here x=320 is known, and the marginal cost at this quantity already is the price. From the cost you read off a=0.04 and b=26. The fixed cost of 2830 plays no part, because it does not move the vertex.
p=2⋅0.04⋅320+26=25.6+26=51.6 GE per tonne, option (c).
With this price the profit is G(x)=51.6x−(0.04x2+26x+2830)=−0.04x2+25.6x−2830, and its vertex lies at x=0.0825.6=320, as given. Two options come from wrong routes: 38.8, option (d), drops the factor 2 when differentiating x2, 0.04⋅320+26; 47.6, option (b), is the average cost 320K(320)=32015246=47.64, the cost per tonne on average rather than the cost of the last tonne.
Variants of the task are solved by the same rule:
K′(x) is given, say K′(x)=0.5x+16 at a price of 24.6: set 0.5x+16=24.6, which gives x=17.2;
the unit costKˉ(x) is given: first the total cost K(x)=x⋅Kˉ(x), then as above;
the quantity at the maximum is given, and the price is asked for: the price equals the marginal cost 2ax+b; for K(x)=0.1x2+35x+8 and x=15 that is 0.2⋅15+35=38 €;
the revenue is given as E(x)=17.1x: that already is the price, p=17.1.
The size of the whole market and the number of other firms are not needed in such tasks: the price is already given.
Trap. Forgetting the fixed cost: −7200+14400=7200 € instead of 4200. It does not move the quantity, but it enters the profit. The second mistake: giving the quantity 600 where the profit is asked for.
In short, to review:
Steps: Write down the profit → Find the vertex → Work out the profit.
Formula sheet: vertex of a parabola; the marginal cost is not on it as a line of its own.
Memorise: At the maximum the price equals the marginal cost; for K(x)=ax2+bx+c it is 2ax+b.
Your turn2 of 3
A farm sells potatoes at the market price of 50 € per tonne. Its cost is K(x)=0.1x2+20x+1500 for x tonnes. What is the largest profit it can make?
Maximum profit of the monopolist: price and quantity
The firm at the market price had no say in the price. A single supplier sets it himself, and demand tells how much is bought at that price.
How to recognise the task. The firm is the only supplier and sets the price itself. Demand is linear, as a formula or through two prices with the quantities sold at them. The cost is linear. You are asked for the price with the largest profit, the quantity or the profit itself.
The demand p(x) gives a price for every quantity. The prohibitive pricepmax (“Prohibitivpreis”) is the price at which nobody buys any more. How demand is built from two observations and where its prohibitive price lies is shown in the article “Demand: price and quantity”. With linear cost K(x)=F+vx the profit G(x)=(p(x)−v)x−F is a parabola: profit per piece times quantity, minus the fixed cost. Its vertex gives the quantity. The price there always lies in the middle between the prohibitive price and the cost per piece:
p=2pmax+v
A maker sells 16 pieces at a price of 22 € and only 8 at 26 €; demand is linear. The cost is K(x)=160+6x. Where is the profit largest? In the picture, profit per piece and quantity form a rectangle between the demand line and the line of the cost per piece of 6 €.
rectangle 288 minus fixed cost 160: profit 128 €
Step 1 of 4Set up the demand
4 € more cost 8 pieces: x=60−2p, so p(x)=30−2x. Prohibitive price 30 €.
G(x)=(30−2x−6)x−160=−0.5x2+24x−160.
x=−2⋅(−0.5)24=24 pieces, price p(24)=18 €.
G(24)=12⋅24−160=128 €. Check: (30+6)/2=18.
If the demand is given as x(p), it is easier to work in the price: G(p)=(p−v)x(p)−F. For example, with x(p)=200−4p, v=10 and F=900 the factor (p−10)(200−4p) is zero at p=10 and p=50, and the vertex lies in the middle, p=30. There 80 pieces are sold, and G=20⋅80−900=700 €.
Trap. Taking the revenue maximum instead of the profit maximum. The revenue alone, E(x)=30x−0.5x2, is largest at 30 pieces and a price of 15 €, but the profit there is only 110 € instead of 128.
In short, to review:
Steps: Set up the demand → Write the profit as a parabola → Find the vertex → Find the price and the profit.
Formula sheet: linear demand D(p)=−ap+α, where D is the demand at the price p, α the demand at price 0, and a how many pieces it drops per euro of price; vertex of a parabola.
Memorise: The price is (prohibitive price + variable cost per piece) / 2.
Your turn3 of 3
A monopolist has the price-demand function (“Preis-Absatz-Funktion”) p(x)=48−0.4x and the cost K(x)=500+12x. At what price in € is its profit largest?
Demand equals supply: equilibrium and a tax t per piece
The monopolist set the price alone. With many sellers nobody sets it: it settles where demand equals supply. How a tax per piece shifts that price is shown in the panel below.
Formula sheet and what to memorise
The answer of each of the three methods lies at the vertex of a parabola. The cards below remind you how to get there:
The market sets the price (“Marktpreis”), the cost is quadratic: K(x)=ax2+bx+c. You produce more while one more unit costs less than the price: at the maximum p equals the marginal cost 2ax+b.
p==2ax++b
Trap:forgetting the fixed cost in the profit: G=px−K(x) with the whole K.