Break-even point and several plants

22 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 1.1.3 Kosten und Erlöse1.2.2 Lineares Marktmodell (Monopol)

You can already write down cost, revenue and profit. This article answers the question every business plan starts with: how much do you have to sell, or at what price, so that the cost is covered?

Imagine you are holding an evening in a rented hall. The hall costs 2400 €, the food per guest 18 €, a ticket 30 €. Every guest leaves 12 € on top of their food, and that money goes towards the rent. How many guests cover the rent?

240030−18=240012=200

With fewer guests the evening makes a loss, and every guest beyond 200 already brings profit.

In the exam the calculation is just as short. Mistakes happen in two places: when setting up the cost from the task and when rounding. In the second method of the article the quantity is already known, and the price or the revenue is wanted. The third method is harder: a single supplier makes the goods in several identical plants, and you need the quantity of each plant. Fixed cost, variable cost, contribution margin and the straight line through two points are explained in the article “What a function is: cost, revenue, profit and demand”. The third method also builds on the maximum profit of the monopolist.

Break-even point and minimum profit: from how many pieces

The evening in the hall from the introduction paid for itself at 200 guests. The exam task is about the same kind of evening, only with other prices:

Exam-style task

Ein Eventveranstalter mietet einen Saal für 10291 GE. Pro Gast fallen 40 GE für das Catering an; die Eintrittskarte kostet 81 GE. Bei wie vielen Gästen sind die Kosten genau gedeckt?

  1. a)85
  2. b)125
  3. c)251
  4. d)257
  5. e)127

This task asks at how many guests the costs are covered exactly, that is, where the profit is zero.

How to recognise the task. “Ab welcher Stückzahl” (from how many pieces), “die Kosten genau decken” (cover the cost exactly), “mindestens 1000 GE Gewinn” (at least 1000 GE profit; GE are “Geldeinheiten”, money units). The cost is rarely given ready-made: it comes as total cost at two quantities or as the sum of several items.

Each piece brings in the contribution margin (“Deckungsbeitrag”) p−v: the price minus its own cost. The profit is G(x)=(p−v) x−F. The break-even point (“Gewinnschwelle”) is where G=0; for a profit of at least Z you need G≥Z:

x=Fp−v,x=F+Zp−v

In the task above the fixed cost is F=10291 GE (the hall rent), per guest v=40 GE, the ticket price p=81 GE.

cost 10291 + 40x

Break-even at 251 guests−10000−5000050001000015000200002500030000050100150200250300guests xGEcost 10291 + 40x
Step 1 of 4Set up the cost

The hall rent does not depend on the number of guests, the catering does: K(x)=10291+40x.

Example 2 below builds the cost from two months: a workshop sells shelves at 85 € each. In May 200 shelves cost 14000 € in total, in June 320 shelves cost 19400 €. How many shelves does it have to sell a month so that at least 3100 € of profit remain? In its picture the cost line passes through the figures of the two months, and the profit grows from the break-even point on.

The profit reaches 3100 € at 202.5 shelves−5000050001000015000200002500030000050100150200250300shelves x€May 200 | 14000June 320 | 19400cost 5000 + 45x
Step 1 of 4Set up the cost

v=5400/120=45 €, F=14000−200⋅45=5000 €, K(x)=5000+45x.

If the task asks “die Kosten genau decken” (cover the cost exactly) and the division comes out even, the quotient itself is the answer. If it asks for “erstmals Gewinn” (the first profit) and the quotient is a whole number, the answer is one piece more, because the profit is exactly 0 at the threshold. If the fixed cost is given as several items (rent, staff, insurance), add them up first; do the same with all the cost per piece.

Trap. Rounding down: at 202 shelves the profit is 3080 €, a little short of 3100. The rounded-down answer is often among the options.

  • Steps: Set up the cost → Find the contribution margin → Solve the inequality → Round up.
  • Formula sheet (“Formelsammlung”, the printed sheet): not on it.
  • Memorise: x=F/(p−v) for the break-even point, always round up.

Your turn1 of 3

A print shop has a fixed cost of 1400 €; each poster costs it 7.5 € to make and sells for 12 €. How many posters does it have to sell at least so that it makes no loss?

Price, revenue or capacity use asked for: what covers the cost

Guests and shelves were counted at a known price. In the second method the number of places or customers is fixed in advance. What you look for is the price or the revenue that covers the cost.

How to recognise the task. The quantity is already known: “bei vollem Boot” (with a full boat), “der Kurs ist ausgebucht” (the course is fully booked). Or the variable cost is a share of the revenue: “35 % des Umsatzes” (35 % of turnover). You are asked for a minimum price, a minimum revenue or the share of the seats that has to be taken (“Auslastung”, capacity use).

In short, the order of work; the calculation below explains where it comes from:

  • Steps: Find the fixed cost → Cost at the given quantity → Express the price → Round up.
  • Formula sheet: not on it.
  • Memorise: The minimum price equals the unit cost at this quantity, p=K(x)/x.

The calculation is the same as for the break-even point above: you set the profit equal to zero. Only now the quantity is known, and the price or the revenue is unknown. If the cost is a share s of the revenue, each euro of revenue leaves 1−s for the fixed cost:

p=K(x)x,E=F1−s

A tour bus has 48 seats. Each passenger costs 14 € (lunch and museum entry). With 30 passengers the total cost of the trip is 1630 €. What is the minimum price you have to charge so that the cost is covered with a full bus? Round up to two decimal places.

F=1630−30⋅14=1210 €.

K(48)=1210+48⋅14=1882 €.

48p=1882, p=1882/48≈39.2083 €.

p=39.21 €: at 39.20 a few cents would be missing.

Share of the seats. Sometimes each empty seat brings a loss (it is paid for in advance) and each taken seat a profit after all expenses. An example: a hall has 160 seats, an empty seat means a loss of 18 €, a taken one brings 30 €. With k seats taken, 30k−18 (160−k)≥0 gives 48k≥2880, so k≥60 seats, 60/160=37.5 %. The share needed is always the loss of an empty seat divided by the sum of loss and profit: 1818+30=0.375.

Trap. Dividing the given cost of 1630 € by 48 seats: 33.96 €. This cost belongs to 30 passengers; for the full bus it is higher. If you divide 1630 by 30, you get 54.33 €: that is the price for 30 passengers, not for 48.

Your turn2 of 3

An online shop has a fixed cost of 2400 € a month. The variable cost (goods and shipping) makes up 40 % of the revenue. What is the minimum revenue it has to reach in a month to cover all its cost?

Several identical plants: how much each one makes

Up to here the price did not depend on the quantity. In the last task of the article a single supplier sets the price, a cooperative of five cheese dairies:

Exam-style task

Eine Sennerei hat bei x Käselaiben im Monat die Kosten C(x)=0.4 x2+55 x+5300 (in GE). 5 solche Sennereien bilden eine Genossenschaft, die als einzige einen Bergkäse mit geschützter Herkunft erzeugen darf und die Menge gleichmäßig unter ihren Sennereien aufteilt. Der Käsehandel nimmt bei 206 GE je Laib monatlich 80 Laibe ab; verlangt die Genossenschaft 270 GE oder mehr, nimmt er keinen. Die Nachfrage ist linear. Zu welchem Preis je Laib verkauft die Genossenschaft, wenn sie den größten Gewinn erzielt? Runden Sie auf zwei Nachkommastellen.

  1. a)172.27
  2. b)198.33
  3. c)224.99
  4. d)191.91
  5. e)250.45

Here the question goes one quantity further: not the quantity at which the profit of the whole cooperative is largest, but the price at which it sells that quantity.

How to recognise the task. A single supplier, for example a cooperative (“Genossenschaft”), produces in n identical plants (“Betriebe”). Each has the same quadratic cost C(x)=ax2+bx+F, and the quantity is split evenly. Demand is linear; you are given one price with its quantity and the highest price, from which on nobody buys any more. The quantity per plant is asked for, or one quantity further, such as the price at the profit maximum.

Let X be the total quantity. Each plant makes x=X/n, and the cost of all plants together is

K(X)=n⋅C ⁣(Xn)=an X2+b X+nF
  • Steps: Set up the demand → Cost of all plants → Profit as a parabola → Split among the plants.
  • Formula sheet: linear demand, vertex of a parabola.
  • Memorise: The answer is usually X/n, the quantity per plant; if the price is asked, put the total quantity X into the demand.

In the task above there are n=5 dairies, the highest price is 270 GE per wheel, the known point is 80 wheels at 206 GE, and one dairy costs C(x)=0.4x2+55x+5300 GE.

From 270 GE down to 206 GE, 80 wheels are added, so the price falls by 270−20680=0.8 GE per wheel: p(X)=270−0.8X.

K(X)=5⋅C(X/5)=5⋅(0.4⋅X225+55⋅X5+5300)=0.08X2+55X+26500.

G(X)=(270−0.8X)⋅X−K(X)=−0.88X2+215X−26500, vertex at X=2152⋅0.88≈122.16 wheels.

Each dairy makes 122.16/5≈24.43 wheels, but the question is the price. The demand gives it at the total quantity: p=270−0.8⋅122.16≈172.27 GE per wheel, option (a). Putting in the quantity of one dairy, 270−0.8⋅24.43=250.45, option (e), gives the price for a quantity the trade does not actually take. Working with the cost of one dairy for the whole quantity, C(X) instead of 5⋅C(X/5), leads to 198.33, option (b).

A smaller example: each of two plants has the cost C(x)=x2+25x+1000. At a price of 345 €, 45 pieces are bought, from 435 € on none; demand is linear. How much does each plant make at the profit maximum?

From 435 € down to 345 €, 45 pieces are added, so 2 € per piece: p(X)=435−2X.

K(X)=2⋅C(X/2)=0.5X2+25X+2000.

G(X)=(435−2X) X−K(X)=−2.5X2+410X−2000, vertex at X=82.

Each makes 82/2=41 pieces; the price is p(82)=271 €.

Trap. Giving the total quantity 82 instead of 41 per plant, or working with the cost of one plant for the whole quantity, C(X) instead of 2⋅C(X/2). It is just as wrong to set the price equal to the marginal cost (“Grenzkosten”) as for the profit at the market price: the single supplier sets the price itself.

Your turn3 of 3

Four identical plants each have the cost C(x)=4x2+10x+500 and split the quantity evenly. At 260 €, 50 pieces are bought, from 410 € on none; demand is linear. How much does each plant make at the profit maximum?

Formula sheet and what to memorise

The first two methods solve an equation for the profit; the third looks for the vertex of a parabola. The cards below put them side by side:

  • Break-even point and minimum profit

    From what quantity does the good pay for itself (“Gewinnschwelle”, break-even point)? Each unit brings p−v, and this money covers the fixed cost F and the wanted profit Z.
    x=F+Zp−v

    Trap: rounding the quantity down; the target is only reached when you round up.

  • Price, revenue or capacity use asked for

    The quantity is known, or the cost is a share s of the revenue; a price or a revenue is asked for. Of every euro of revenue, 1−s is left, and that is how the revenue E must cover the fixed cost F.
    E=F1−s

    Trap: using a cost given for one quantity at another; work it out again for the quantity asked about.

  • Several identical plants

    A seller has n identical plants with cost C(x), and the output is split equally. At the total output X each plant makes X/n, and the total cost K(X) is n equal parts.
    K(X)=n⋅C ⁣(Xn)

    Trap: giving the whole output X instead of one plant's output X/n.

On the formula sheet:

  • linear demand and vertex of a parabola: several identical plants

Memorise yourself:

  • cost from two figures: v = cost difference / quantity difference, then F from either of the two figures
  • break-even point x=F/(p−v), profit of at least Z: x=(F+Z)/(p−v); always round up (break-even point)
  • minimum price at a given quantity p=K(x)/x; cost as a share s of revenue: E=F/(1−s); share of the seats = loss of an empty one / (loss of an empty one + profit of a taken one) (price, revenue or capacity use asked for)
  • n identical plants: cost of all n⋅C(X/n), profit as a parabola in X, answer X/n (several plants)

Now practise it

Break-even point and several plants

Trainer · Linear and quadratic functions

Practise
Next: Arithmetic sequences: term and sum
0/3

Was this article helpful?