Elasticity and extrema

22 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 3.3.7 Elastizitäten

In the last article elasticity turned the derivative into percent. What that is good for is easiest to see in one decision about a price.

A concert promoter sells 2700 tickets a month at 16 €. He is thinking of raising the price by 1 %, to 16.16 €. There will be fewer buyers, but each will pay more. Which wins?

Ticket priceSold a monthRevenue
16 €270043200 €
16.16 €about 2674about 43216 €

The price went up by 1 %, and sales fell by about 0.95 %, less than one percent. That is why revenue rose slightly. The ratio of these two percentages, −0.95, is the elasticity of demand at a price of 16 €. Its absolute value is below 1, demand is inelastic, and the price rise does not eat up the revenue. With an absolute value above 1 it would be the other way round: sales would fall by more than the price rises.

Finding the derivative is not enough in the tasks of this article; you also have to read it. There are three tasks:

  • the elasticity at a point, as with the tickets;
  • the point of the maximum of a function with e or ln⁡, such as sales after an advertising campaign;
  • a set of statements about the graph, from which you pick the true ones.

Where elasticity and the signs of an extremum come from is explained in the article “Marginal cost and elasticity: what they mean”. How to take the derivative itself is shown in the article “The derivative at a point: roots, the chain rule, x to the power x”.

At a glance

The tickets gave the first of the three tasks. The other two look not for a percentage but for a place on the graph: where the function is largest and where it rises, falls or changes its bend. The overview shows which derivative each one needs:

  • Elasticity at a point

    By how many percent does demand change if x rises by 1 % (“Elastizität”, elasticity)? You multiply the derivative f′(x) by the ratio of x to f(x).
    εf(x)=f′(x)⋅xf(x)

    Trap: forgetting the factor x/f(x) or turning it over; the right form is f′(x)⋅x/f(x), sign included.

  • Maximum of a function with e or ln

    A quantity rises and then falls, and the formula has e to a negative power or ln⁡x. The factor e−kx is never zero, so the zero comes from the other bracket.
    (x e−kx)′=(1−kx) e−kx

    Trap: looking for a zero of the exponential; only the bracket (1−kx) becomes zero.

  • Statements about extrema

    “Welche Aussagen sind richtig?” (which statements are true?) about growth, extrema and curvature. Check each statement on its own: f′ decides growth, f′′ decides curvature.
    f′′>0⇒convex,  f′′<0⇒concave

    Trap: giving the location of the extremum instead of its value, or forgetting the ends; on an interval you also compare the ends.

Full list: Formula sheet and what to memorise.

By how many percent: elasticity at a point

For the concert promoter the elasticity came from a table with two prices. In the exam there is no table, only a formula, and the elasticity is computed from the derivative at one point:

Exam-style task

Die wöchentliche Nachfrage nach Grillkohle hängt vom Preis p (in GE pro Sack) ab:

x(p)=3980−5 p2

Berechnen Sie die Preiselastizität der Nachfrage beim Preis p=16.

  1. a)0.95
  2. b)−1.05
  3. c)1.05
  4. d)−0.47
  5. e)−0.95

How to recognise the task. “Berechnen Sie die Elastizität von f an der Stelle …” (work out the elasticity of f at the point …), for example with a root, a power or an exponential function; “Preiselastizität der Nachfrage” (price elasticity of demand); “bei welchem Preis ist die Nachfrage einheitselastisch” (at which price does demand have unit elasticity).

εf(x)=f′(x)⋅xf(x)

Where the formula comes from is explained in the section “Elasticity”.

  • Steps: Work out f(x) → Differentiate → Put in → Interpret.
  • Formula sheet (“Formelsammlung”, the printed sheet): ε(x0)=f′(x0)f(x0)x0.
  • Memorise: absolute value below 1 inelastic (“unelastisch”), above 1 elastic (“elastisch”); the sign stays in the answer.

Let us solve the charcoal task. Here the variable is p and the function is x(p): in the elasticity formula they take the place of x and f.

x(16)=3980−5⋅256=2700.

x′(p)=−10p, at p=16 this is −160.

ε=−160⋅162700≈−0.948, rounded −0.95.

If the price rises by 1 %, demand falls by about 0.95 %. The absolute value is below 1: demand is inelastic. The flipped fraction 2700−160⋅16 would give −1.05.

Take f(x)=203x+4 and find its elasticity at the point x=4.

f(4)=2016=80.

f′(x)=20⋅323x+4, f′(4)=608=7.5.

εf(4)=7.5⋅480=0.375.

An x larger by 1 % makes f larger by about 0.375 %: inelastic.

Demand. The same formula with the variable p: ε(p)=x′(p)⋅px(p). The picture below shows the demand x(p)=120−4p and the revenue p⋅x(p) over the same price axis: at 10 the elasticity is −0.5, at 15 exactly −1 with the largest revenue, at 20 already −2.

  • Linear demand x=a−b p (with positive numbers a and b from the task) has unit elasticity, ε=−1, at the price p=a2b (from −b⋅pa−bp=−1 follows bp=a−bp); for 120−4p that is 15. If the price is given in terms of the quantity, say p(x)=120−0.5x, first solve for x(p)=240−2p: the answer is p=60.
  • Exponential demand x(p)=A e−kp (with positive numbers A and k from the task): ε=−k p (x′=−k A e−kp, and A e−kp cancels with x(p)). For 141 e−0.04p at p=13 that is −0.52.
  • Elasticity of the unit cost (“Durchschnittskosten”, “Stückkosten”): first form k(x)=K(x)x, then the formula for k. For K=x2+10x+400 at x=10: k=60, k′=1−400100=−3, ε=−3⋅1060=−0.5.

Trap. f′f without x is the growth rate (a separate formula on the sheet), ff′⋅x the reciprocal. With demand, the minus belongs in the answer.

Your turn1 of 3

What is the elasticity of g(x)=82x+1 at the point x=12? Round to three decimal places.

Maximum of a function with e or ln: at which x it is largest

The elasticity was computed at a point the task supplied. In the second task you find the point yourself: the function first rises, then falls, and its peak is what is wanted:

Exam-style task

Der Umsatz eines Produkts nach der Markteinführung ist f(t)=(8+8t) e−0.4t (t in Monaten). An welcher Stelle t ist f maximal?

  1. a)0.97
  2. b)1.00
  3. c)1.50
  4. d)1.38
  5. e)2.50

How to recognise the task. The function first rises and then falls: sales after an advertising campaign, the revenue of a new product, the concentration of a drug. It is written as a polynomial times a falling exponential function, or with ln⁡x. You are asked for the point or the value of the maximum.

The plan; the formula below shows what it rests on:

  • Steps: Differentiate with the product rule → Set the factor without e to zero → Check the type → Function value.
  • Formula sheet: product rule.
  • Memorise: e…>0 always; the maximum of x e−kx is at x=1k.
(x e−kx)′=(1−kx) e−kx

Let us solve the task on the new product's revenue: the factor e−0.4t is never zero, so only the bracket decides.

u=8+8t, u′=8; v=e−0.4t, v′=−0.4⋅e−0.4t. Together f′(t)=e−0.4t⋅(8−0.4⋅(8+8t))=e−0.4t⋅(4.8−3.2t).

4.8−3.2t=0, so t=1.5.

Before t=1.5 the bracket is positive, after it negative: f′ changes from plus to minus, a maximum. The question asks for the place, not the value, so the answer is 1.50.

Sales in ME (“Mengeneinheiten”, quantity units) at advertising spending x (in 1000 €) are N(x)=40x e−0.2x. At what spending are they largest, and how large are they there? The picture shows the sales curve with its peak at x=5.

Sales as a function of advertising spending
Sales N(x) = 40 x e to the power minus 0.2 x010152020406080573.58advertising x (1000 €)sales, MEx = 5

N′(x)=40 e−0.2x (1−0.2x).

1−0.2x=0, x=5.

Left of 5 the bracket is positive, right of it negative: a maximum.

N(5)=200 e−1≈73.58 ME.

Other forms from the tasks, the same route:

  • 10 ln⁡xx: by the quotient rule f′=10 1−ln⁡xx2, zero at ln⁡x=1, that is x=e, the value 10e≈3.68;
  • x (10−3ln⁡x): f′=10−3ln⁡x−3, zero at ln⁡x=73, x=e7/3≈10.31;
  • 10 (e−0.1t−e−0.4t): from 0.1 e−0.1t=0.4 e−0.4t follows e0.3t=4, t=ln⁡40.3≈4.62.

Trap. In the example with sales N(x)=40x e−0.2x it is easy to look for a zero of e−0.2x or to forget the inner derivative −0.2: then 1−x=0 gives x=1. Read the question again: it asks for the point 5 or the value 73.58.

Your turn2 of 3

The concentration of a drug in the blood is y(t)=12t e−0.5t (t in hours). When is it largest?

Which statements about extrema are true

So far there was one question and one number as the answer. The third task brings four statements at once, and each is checked with its own derivative, the first or the second:

Exam-style task

Eine Funktion ist festgelegt durch

f(x)=x4−8x3+5

Welche der folgenden Aussagen sind richtig?

(1) Die Anzahl der lokalen Extremstellen von f ist 1.

(2) f hat bei x=6 ein lokales Maximum.

(3) f ist auf (2,4) streng monoton steigend.

(4) f ist auf (1,3) konvex (linksgekrümmt).

  1. a)nur (1), (3) und (4)
  2. b)nur (1)
  3. c)keine
  4. d)nur (2)
  5. e)nur (2) und (3)

How to recognise the task. “Welche der folgenden Aussagen sind richtig?” (which of the following statements are true?) and four statements about a function, for example about cost: extrema (“Extremstellen”), rising, curvature, inflection point (“Wendepunkt”), the smallest marginal cost (“Grenzkosten”), the largest value on an interval. The answer is a combination like “nur (1) und (3)”. Sometimes the hint “Substitution u=x2” is given. In the wording: “Hochpunkt” and “Tiefpunkt” (maximum and minimum point), “streng monoton steigend/fallend” (strictly increasing/decreasing), “waagrechte Tangente” (f′=0), “linksgekrümmt” = convex, “rechtsgekrümmt” = concave.

You check each statement on its own and choose the combination at the end. The tests are explained in the section “Rising, maximum and minimum”:

StatementChecked with
rises or falls on an intervalsign of f′ there
local maximum or minimum at x0f′(x0)=0 and a change of sign: from + to − maximum, from − to + minimum
convex (“konvex”) or concave (“konkav”)f′′>0 or f′′<0 on the interval
inflection point at x0f′′(x0)=0 and a change of sign of f′′
smallest marginal costat the inflection point xw of the function K: the minimum of K′ lies where its derivative K′′=0 (for cost of third degree with a plus before x3 it is a minimum, not a maximum); the value is K′(xw)
largest value on [a,b]compare the extrema and both ends
  • Steps: First derivative and its zeros → Sign of f′ → Second derivative → Compare the end values.
  • Formula sheet: the rules of differentiation; the tests themselves are not on it.
  • Memorise: f′ decides rising and extremum, f′′ curvature and inflection point.

Let us solve the task with f(x)=x4−8x3+5: each statement is checked on its own.

f′(x)=4x3−24x2=4x2⋅(x−6), zeros x=0 and x=6.

The factor x2 does not change sign, so f′ keeps its sign at x=0: f′(−1)=−28, f′(1)=−20. There is no extremum there. At x=6 the sign changes from − to + (f′(7)=196): a minimum. So there is exactly one extremum, (1) is true; at x=6 it is a minimum, not a maximum, (2) is false. On (2,4) the factor x−6<0, so f′<0, for example f′(3)=−108: the function is decreasing there, (3) is false.

f′′(x)=12x2−48x=12x⋅(x−4). On (1,3), x>0 and x−4<0, so f′′<0, for example f′′(2)=−48: the function is concave there, not convex, (4) is false.

Only (1) is true, answer (b).

Given are f(x)=x3−6x2+9x+1 and four statements about it. (1) f has a local maximum at x=1. (2) f is strictly increasing on (1,3). (3) f is convex on (2,∞). (4) On [0,5], f takes its largest value at x=1. The picture shows the graph with the maximum at 1, the inflection point at 2, the minimum at 3 and the highest point of the interval at the right end.

Graph of f(x) = x³ − 6x² + 9x + 1 on [0, 5]0123451015521xmaximum (1, 5)inflectionminimum (3, 1)end (5, 21)

f′(x)=3x2−12x+9=3 (x−1)(x−3), zeros 1 and 3.

+ up to 1, − between 1 and 3, + after 3: (1) true, (2) false.

f′′(x)=6x−12>0 for x>2: (3) true.

f(0)=1, f(1)=5, f(3)=1, f(5)=21: (4) false. True are (1) and (3).

Via a substitution. If x appears only as x2 (or x3), set u=x2:

  • extrema: f(x)=x4−8x2+12 becomes u2−8u+12, by the chain rule f′(x)=(2u−8)⋅2x=4x (x2−4); zeros x=0 and x=±2, the sign of f′ changes from − to + at ±2 (minima, f=−4) and from + to − at 0 (maximum, f=12);
  • with u=x3 the factor 3x2 gives a zero at x=0 without a change of sign: there is no extremum there;
  • the zeros of f itself come from the same substitution: u2−8u+12=0 gives u=2 or u=6, and from that four zeros ±2, ±6;
  • a negative u drops out, because x2 is never less than zero: x4−8x2−9 (u=9 or u=−1) has only two zeros, ±3.

Three more cases:

  • K′(x)=0 has no solution: then K′>0 everywhere (for cost K′(0)>0), and K rises without an extremum;
  • f′ has a factor ex: take it outside the bracket, only the other factors give zeros;
  • unit cost such as Kˉ(x)=2x+15+18x: the derivative is 2−18x2, and the minimum is at x=3.

Trap. Giving the point instead of the value: the smallest marginal cost is K′(xw), not xw. Forgetting the ends of the interval.

Your turn3 of 3

A firm's cost is K(x)=x3−12x2+60x+100 for x≥0. What is the smallest marginal cost?

Formula sheet and what to memorise

The sheet gives the elasticity formula ready-made. How to read the result is not there: what a magnitude above 1 means, why the exponential is never zero, which derivative is in charge of the bend.

On the formula sheet:

  • elasticity ε(x0)=f′(x0)f(x0)x0 and growth rate c=f′(x0)f(x0): section “By how many percent”
  • the rules of differentiation, also the product and quotient rules: page “The derivative at a point: roots, the chain rule, x to the power x”, sections “Derivative of a product with an exponential or a logarithm” and “Second derivative at a point, the quotient u/v and the change Δf ≈ f′·Δx”

Memorise yourself:

  • absolute value of the elasticity below 1 inelastic, above 1 elastic; the linear demand a−bp has unit elasticity at p=a2b; A e−kp gives ε=−kp (section “By how many percent”)
  • the exponential function is never zero; the maximum of x e−kx is at x=1k (section “Maximum of a function with e or ln”)
  • f′ for rising and extremum, f′′ for curvature and inflection point; the smallest marginal cost at the inflection point of K; on [a,b] also the ends (section “Which statements about extrema are true”)

Now practise it

Elasticity and extrema

Trainer · Differential calculus

Practise
Next: Which method? Differential calculus
0/3

Was this article helpful?