Two curves: the area between them and market surplus

25 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 4.3 Anwendungen von Integralen4.1 Stammfunktionen und Integrale

The area under a curve is measured from the x-axis, which is the lower border of the figure. Sometimes, though, a second graph bounds the figure from below, and then the axis plays no part.

In a park, a flower bed lies between a path in the shape of the parabola g(x)=10x−x2 and a straight fence h(x)=3x, all in metres.

How large is the flower bed?

The area under the parabola down to the axis does not fit here: the bed is bounded below by the fence, not by the axis. No limits are given either; you find them where the path meets the fence.

The flower bed covers about 57.17 m². The limits are where the path meets the fence: 10x−x2=3x at x=0 and x=7. In between, the path lies above the fence; at x=1 it is 9 m against 3 m. So the height of the bed at x is the difference (10x−x2)−3x=7x−x2, and its integral from 0 to 7 gives 171.5−114.33=57.17 m². The area under the path alone, 130.67 m², is not the answer: the 73.5 m² under the fence still have to come off.

In the same way, between two graphs, the exam has you work out:

  • a panel between a straight line and a parabola;
  • the difference in income of two investments over a few years;
  • the buyers' gain between the demand curve and the price line.

On the exam you are asked for the area “enclosed between the curves”, or for a surplus on a market. Both questions are worked through here, including the case where the curves cross inside the interval.

The basics: area and sign

For the flower bed the area between the curves came down to the integral of a single difference. Everything below rests on the article “What the integral measures: area and average value”:

  • the integral ∫abf(x) dx=F(b)−F(a), where F′=f, is the signed area under the curve;
  • a piece below the axis gives a minus, so the area of a figure whose curve crosses the axis is worked out piece by piece between the zeros, adding the numbers without the minus: the absolute value ∣−2∣=2;
  • an area in graph units is converted into m² or dm² as in the article “Area under a curve in m², ha and dm²”.

Area between two curves

The flower bed had a parabola on top and a line below. The panel in the exam task has the line on top and the parabola below, and the crossing points are already given in the task:

Exam-style task

Ein Fliesenleger schreibt ein Angebot für 20 gleiche Badezimmer. In jedes kommt an der Wand ein Mosaikfeld, das die Gerade g(x)=2x und die Parabel h(x)=x212 einschließen; die beiden Kurven schneiden sich bei x=0 und x=24 (x, g(x) und h(x) in cm). Das Mosaik kostet 4 GE pro dm2. Welche Materialkosten setzt er für alle Felder an (in GE)? Runden Sie auf zwei Nachkommastellen.

  1. a)153.60
  2. b)1536.00
  3. c)130.10
  4. d)172.65
  5. e)63.59

Incomes and surpluses in the tasks are given in GE, money units: that is how the exam names an amount of money.

How to spot it: the figure is bounded by two graphs (“enclosed by the line”, “and the parabola”), and the x-axis is not one of its borders. The limits are the points where “the two curves meet”.

The area between the curves is the area under the upper curve minus the area under the lower one. Under the line g(x)=2x from 0 to 24 lies the area ∫0242x dx=576. Under the parabola h(x)=x212 lies ∫024x212 dx=24336=384. The panel is what lies under the line but above the parabola: 576−384=192. Two integrals with the same limits are subtracted under one sign:

A=∫ab(g(x)−h(x)) dx,g≥h on [a,b]

Here g is the upper curve, h the lower one, and a and b are their intersection points (“Schnittpunkte”). Which curve is on top you check by substituting one point between a and b.

Panel between the line g(x) = 2x and the parabola h(x) = x²/12: area under the upper curve minus area under the lower one01224122448x in cmheight in cm(24; 48)g(x) = 2xh(x) = x²/12
Step 1 of 4Take the limits from the intersection

The limits are given in the statement: x=0 and x=24. Check at 24: g(24)=48 and h(24)=57612=48, the curves meet.

Here the statement gives no intersection points, you find them yourself.

What is the area between the graphs of g(x)=6x−x2 and h(x)=x?

  1. Intersection: 6x−x2=x, that is 5x−x2=0, that is x⋅(5−x)=0. The limits are a=0 and b=5.
  2. Upper curve: at x=1 the values are g(1)=5 and h(1)=1. g is on top.
  3. The difference g−h=5x−x2, the antiderivative 5x22−x33.
  4. At x=5: 5⋅252−1253=62.5−41.67=20.83. At x=0 zero. The area is 20.83.
The parabola g(x) = 6x − x² and the line h(x) = x: the figure ends where the curves meet, not at the zeros of the parabola01515x(5; 5)area 20.83g(x) = 6x − x²h(x) = x

In the figure, the shape with area 20.83 is shaded. Compare its edges: the parabola g on top, the line h below, and on the right the meeting point (5; 5), not the parabola's zero at x=6.

Both borders of the figure are curves again.

What is the area between the graphs of g(x)=4x−x2 and h(x)=x2?

  1. Intersection: 4x−x2=x2, that is 4x−2x2=0, that is 2x⋅(2−x)=0. The limits are a=0 and b=2.
  2. Upper curve: at x=1 the values are g(1)=3 and h(1)=1. g is on top.
  3. The difference g−h=4x−2x2, the antiderivative 2x2−2x33.
  4. Substitute the limits, subtract and round to two places.

Your turn2 of 3

A house's power consumption is B(x)=−x2+0.5x+4, the output of its solar panels S(x)=−2x2−1.5x+7 (in kW, x in hours). What is the area between the two curves (in kWh)? Round to two decimal places.

The curves swap places

Exam-style task

Zwei Wachstumsraten von Kapitalanlagen lauten r1(x)=−0.5x3+0.5x2+9.5x+8.5 und r2(x)=x+1 (in 1000 GE pro Jahr, x in Jahren). Wie groß ist die Fläche, die beide Kurven einschließen (in 1000 GE)? Runden Sie auf zwei Nachkommastellen.

  1. a)85.33
  2. b)140.77
  3. c)149.10
  4. d)94.67
  5. e)170.87

How to spot it: you are asked for “the area enclosed by the two curves”, and the statement gives no limits. The limits are the points where the curves meet, and there can be three of them. Then the curves swap places in between.

Why are absolute values needed? Here r1(x) and r2(x) are the yearly incomes of two investments, in thousand GE, depending on the year x. The height of a strip between the curves is the difference d(x)=r1(x)−r2(x). Where r2 is on top, the difference is negative, like a curve below the axis in the section “Area and sign”. So you treat the difference d as one curve and the axis as its second border: cut at the zeros of d, take the integral of each piece as an absolute value and add.

Difference d = r₁ − r₂: the piece below and the piece above the axis are each taken without their sign and added, otherwise the minus eats part of the area−3−10257.5x, yearsd, thousand GE per yeard = r₁ − r₂
Step 1 of 6Form the difference

d(x)=r1(x)−r2(x)=−0.5x3+0.5x2+9.5x+8.5−(x+1).

The terms with x: 9.5x−x=8.5x. The numbers: 8.5−1=7.5. Together d(x)=−0.5x3+0.5x2+8.5x+7.5.

This is the same case with h(x)=0: the second border of the figure is the x-axis itself, and the curve crosses it.

What is the area between the graph of f(x)=3⋅(x2−1) and the x-axis on [0,2]?

  1. Zero: x2−1=0, x=1 or x=−1. Only 1 lies in [0,2]. At x=0.5 the value is 3⋅(0.25−1)=−2.25<0, the piece [0,1] is below the axis. At x=1.5 the value is 3⋅(2.25−1)=3.75>0, the piece [1,2] is above the axis.
  2. Antiderivative F(x)=x3−3x: F(0)=0, F(1)=1−3=−2, F(2)=8−6=2. Pieces: F(1)−F(0)=−2 and F(2)−F(1)=2−(−2)=4.
  3. Add the pieces the way an area requires.

Traps with area below the axis and between curves

  • Taking one integral across a zero. In the investment task this is −4.67+90=85.33 instead of 94.67, option a; in the example with 3⋅(x2−1) it is F(2)−F(0)=2 instead of 6. The temptation: in the field task the area was simply the integral, and the limits −3 and 5 seem to be the only ones. To catch it: substitute a point on each piece. If the value is negative, the piece is below the axis (or the second curve is on top), and you take its absolute value.
  • Taking only the piece above the axis. In the example with 3⋅(x2−1) this is 4 instead of 6, for the investments 90 instead of 94.67. The temptation: a small piece below the axis is easy to miss by eye. To catch it: find all zeros between the limits, not only the visible ones.
  • Converting cm² to dm² by dividing by 10. In the method's task 192/10=19.2 dm² gives 1536.00 GE, option b. To catch it: 1 dm² has 10⋅10=100 cm².
  • Computing the area under a single curve. Under the line alone ∫0242x dx=576 cm², that is 460.80 GE; in the solar panel exercise B alone gives 4.67. The temptation: the habit from the field task, “area down to the axis”. To catch it: if the axis is not a border of the figure, subtract the lower curve.
  • Taking limits that are not from the intersection. In the example with 6x−x2 and x the zeros of the parabola are 0 and 6, and ∫06g dx=36. But the figure ends where g and h meet, at x=5. In the solar panel exercise the lower limit 0 instead of −3 gives 1.67. The temptation: x is hours, and you want to start at zero. To catch it: the limits are the solutions of g(x)=h(x).

On the sheet: the basic integrals. There is no formula for the area between curves on the sheet, “upper minus lower” you remember yourself.

Consumer and producer surplus: the area between the curve and the price p*

For the bed and the panel both borders were curves from the task. On a market one border is a horizontal line, the price at which trading happens:

Exam-style task

Auf dem Markt für Äpfel gilt die Nachfragefunktion pN(x)=31−4x und die Angebotsfunktion pA(x)=13+2x (x in Tonnen, p in GE pro Einheit). Wie groß ist die Konsumentenrente im Marktgleichgewicht (in GE)?

  1. a)12
  2. b)18
  3. c)14
  4. d)10
  5. e)57

How to spot it: you are given a demand function pN and a supply function pA, and asked for the consumers' or producers' gain, that is, their surplus.

  • The demand function pN(x) says what price per unit buyers are willing to pay when x units are on the market.
  • The supply function pA(x) says at what price sellers are willing to sell.

At the market equilibrium both prices are equal: pN(x∗)=pA(x∗)=p∗. Here x∗ is the equilibrium quantity and p∗ the equilibrium price (equilibrium is covered in the article Maximum revenue and profit: price steps, monopoly, unit tax).

Think of the buyer who needs the apples most: he would have paid pN(0)=31 GE, but pays the equilibrium price p∗.

What does he gain? Below, the equilibrium price comes out at 19 GE, and his gain is 31−19=12.

Add up such gains of all buyers up to x∗: you get the area between the demand curve and the price line p∗. It is the area under the demand minus the rectangle “price × quantity”, that is, minus what the buyers actually paid:

KR=∫0x∗pN(x) dx−x∗⋅p∗

KR is the consumer surplus (“Konsumentenrente”). The same for the sellers: a seller was willing to sell for pA(x) and received p∗. The producer surplus (“Produzentenrente”):

PR=x∗⋅p∗−∫0x∗pA(x) dx

These formulas are not on the formula sheet.

Demand and supply: the consumer surplus is the area under the demand without the rectangle the buyers paid061331319x, tonnesp, GE per tonne(3; 19)demandsupply
Step 1 of 4Find the equilibrium

31−4x=13+2x, so 18=6x and x∗=3 tonnes. The price p∗=31−4⋅3=19. Check with the supply: 13+2⋅3=19.

Now the same apple market from the sellers' side.

What is the producer surplus?

  1. The equilibrium is the same: x∗=3, p∗=19, the sellers received x∗⋅p∗=57.
  2. Area under the supply: ∫03(13+2x) dx=[13x+x2]03=39+9=48.
  3. PR=57−48=9 GE. Check: a triangle with legs 3 and 19−13=6, area 3⋅62=9.

Your turn3 of 3

On a bicycle market the demand function is pN(x)=160−x2 and the supply function is pA(x)=16+3x2 (x in units, p in € per unit). What is the producers\' gain at the market equilibrium (in €)?

Surplus traps

  • Answering with the revenue. x∗⋅p∗=57 (option e) instead of the surplus 18. The temptation: the rectangle “price × quantity” is computed last and looks like the result. To catch it: the surplus is only the part between the curve and the price line, it is smaller than the revenue.
  • Answering with the area under the curve. The area under the demand, 75, without subtracting the rectangle 57; in the exercise the area under the supply, 312. The temptation: in the field task the area under the curve was the answer. To catch it: the consumer surplus is “were willing to pay minus paid”, the subtraction is required.
  • Answering with the equilibrium price. 19 for the apples, 124 in the exercise. The temptation: the price is found first, and it is the first “finished” number. To catch it: the surplus is measured in GE for the whole quantity, the price in GE per unit.

Formula sheet and what to memorise

The flower bed, the panel, the investments and the surpluses were all worked out the same way: subtract the lower function from the upper one and integrate the difference. For this the sheet gives only the antiderivatives.

On the formula sheet:

  • the basic integrals ∫xα dx=xα+1α+1 and ∫ex dx=ex: they give the antiderivative of the difference g−h and the antiderivatives of pN, pA for the surpluses.

Remember yourself:

  • the integral is signed area: a piece below the axis counts with a minus;
  • the area of a figure whose curve crosses the axis: cut at the zeros, add the absolute values of the pieces;
  • 1 dm2=100 cm2; a length unit of 100 m gives a unit of area of 1 ha;
  • between curves: limits at the intersection points, upper minus lower, A=∫ab(g−h) dx;
  • surpluses: KR=∫0x∗pN dx−x∗⋅p∗, PR=x∗⋅p∗−∫0x∗pA dx.

In short

  • Area below the axis and between two curves

    The curve crosses the x-axis, or the figure lies between two graphs. Pieces below the axis are taken as absolute values; between curves you integrate the upper g minus the lower h.
    A=∫ab(g(x)−h(x)) dx,g≥h

    Trap: one integral across a zero, or the area under just one curve.

Area between curves and market surplus are in the same trainer “Applications of integrals”. From here on the integral counts money rather than area: “Continuous payment stream: the integral as a sum of small payments”.

Now practise it

Two curves: the area between them and market surplus

Trainer · Integral calculus

Practise
Next: Continuous payment stream: the integral as a sum of small payments
0/3

Was this article helpful?