Giving Advice (Rat geben)

16 min · 3 drills

The first task of the speaking part is the shortest. A friend on campus describes a small problem from everyday student life and asks what you would do. You have about 30 seconds of preparation and 45 seconds of speaking time (German: Sprechzeit) to give advice and justify it.

The task

Through the headset you hear a simulated person who addresses you directly; the screen shows the situation and the instruction, for example „Geben Sie ihr einen Rat und begründen Sie ihn.“ Then the phases run automatically: first the preparation, then the speaking time with a countdown. There are no follow-up questions and nobody nodding at you. Notes on paper are allowed.

Because the situation is private, you address the person with du. That is part of the task: you play the role of a friend, and the tone may be relaxed as long as it stays correct.

The recording is assessed later by trained raters. The provider names five criteria: relevance to the topic, task fulfilment (German: Erfüllung der Aufgabe), use of the sources, fluency and pronunciation, and language use. The result of all seven tasks is converted to a scale of 0 to 20: 5–9 points correspond to TDN 3, 10–15 points to TDN 4, 16–20 points to TDN 5. The provider does not publish raw-score cut-offs.

For this task that means in practice:

CriterionHow you gainHow you lose
Relevance to the topicYou respond to the person's specific problem.You hand out general wisdom about studying.
Task fulfilmentOne clear piece of advice, at least two reasons, a tone that suits a friend.No advice, only „Das musst du selbst wissen“, a single reason, or a tone fit for an official letter.
Use of the sourcesYou pick up details from what the person told you.You overlook a condition the person mentioned.
Fluency and pronunciationYou speak in full sentences without long pauses.You read sentences off your notes or stay silent for the first ten seconds.
Language useSubjunctive II, modal verbs and connectors are accurate.„Ich an deiner Stelle werde …“, wrong verb position after weil.

Time plan

At a calm pace of 120 to 140 words per minute, 45 seconds correspond to about 90 to 105 words. That is enough for five to seven sentences: enough for advice with two reasons and a short alternative, too little for a list.

PhaseDurationWhat you do
Hear the situationas long as the person speaksNote: Who? What problem? What exactly is being asked?
Preparationabout 0:30Decide what you advise and write keywords for the advice and two reasons.
Speaking, openingabout 5 secondsPick up the situation in one sentence.
Speaking, adviceabout 5–10 secondsState the advice clearly.
Speaking, justificationabout 20 secondsGive two reasons and link at least one of them to a detail from the situation.
Speaking, alternative and closeabout 5–10 secondsPlan B or a condition, then a short closing sentence.

For the preparation (German: Vorbereitung), a three-line note template is enough, one you know by heart before the exam:

Rat: … weil: 1. … 2. … sonst: …

More does not fit into 30 seconds, and you do not need more. Write keywords, not sentences: a fully worded sentence tempts you to read it out, and reading out sounds halting.

When you run out of things to say. Make the advice concrete: how exactly, when, with whom. „Schreib ihr am besten heute noch eine kurze Mail“ fills five seconds with content that belongs to the task. A short sentence about your own experience („Mir ging es letztes Jahr ähnlich …“) also fits. Do not stay silent until the countdown ends; close with a sentence that sharpens the advice once more.

When time gets short. Because the advice comes first, it is already recorded when the countdown runs out. Drop the alternative and finish the current sentence calmly instead of speeding up. A broken-off half-sentence is not a problem; a rushed ending full of pronunciation errors is more likely to be one.

Step by step

  1. Hear the actual question. The person often tells you more than they ask. Note the question as an either-or: „Verlängerung beantragen oder nicht?“ Your advice must answer exactly this question, or relevance to the topic suffers.
  2. Decide at once. Choose a side in the first seconds of the preparation, even if both are defensible. What is rated is not whether your advice is the wisest, but whether it is clear and justified. If you weigh things up for twenty seconds, you end up with no notes.
  3. Take at least two reasons from the situation. Plan at least two reasons; with only one, the task is not fully fulfilled. The best justification uses a detail the person mentioned: a deadline, an amount, a worry. This shows that you listened and at the same time covers use of the source.
  4. Open with the situation, not with the advice. A first sentence such as „Puh, das ist wirklich ungünstig, dass beides auf einmal kommt“ links your answer to what you heard and gives you two seconds to collect yourself. The opening should not be longer than one sentence.
  5. State the advice without detours. A phrase with Subjunctive II (Ich an deiner Stelle würde …) or a recommendation (Ich würde dir raten, …) makes the advice audible. Advice in question form (Hast du schon mal überlegt, …?) sounds friendly, but it needs a following sentence that shows you really recommend it.
  6. Add an alternative or a condition. A plan B shows that you have thought the situation through: „Und falls das nicht klappt, …“ With 45 seconds, this is the part you may drop.
  7. End with a short close. A sentence like „Ich würde es auf jeden Fall versuchen“ rounds things off and shows that you have finished, instead of the recording ending in mid-thought.

Your turn1 of 3

A friend asks whether she should give her presentation alone or with a fellow student. Which opening of the answer is best?

Typical pitfalls

No advice. „Das hängt wirklich von dir ab, es gibt Vor- und Nachteile.“ The sentence sounds balanced but does not answer the question. The task asks for advice, and without it the task is only partly fulfilled.

Advice without a reason. „Ich würde die Verlängerung beantragen. Ja. Mach das.“ Unjustified advice does not fill 45 seconds and shows little language. Every reason needs a weil, denn or sonst.

Only one reason. „Ich würde früh schreiben, weil das einen guten Eindruck macht.“ That is justified advice, but thin. With only one reason the task is not fully fulfilled, and that costs points for task fulfilment. Give at least two reasons, ideally linked with außerdem or zum einen … zum anderen.

Commonplaces instead of the situation. „Im Studium ist es immer wichtig, gut zu planen.“ The sentence fits every task and therefore none. If your friend mentions a deadline in ten days, the deadline belongs in your answer.

Wrong register. „Ich möchte Ihnen dringend empfehlen …“ to a friend on campus sounds like a letter from the authorities. Conversely, „Alter, mach einfach blau“ is too slangy. What is wanted is friendly, correct everyday German with du.

Five pieces of advice in telegram style. „Mail schreiben, Chef fragen, früher anfangen, Bibliothek, Lerngruppe.“ A list sounds like notes being read aloud. Two developed thoughts sound more fluent and show more grammar.

Silence at the start. The recording runs from the first second of the speaking time. If you start speaking only after eight seconds, you have given away almost a fifth of the time. A prepared opening sentence prevents that.

Subjunctive built wrongly. „Ich an deiner Stelle werde …“ is a future tense, not advice; „Ich würde es machen würde“ doubles the auxiliary. Practise the three or four advice formulas until they come out right without thinking.

Useful phrases

These useful phrases (German: Redemittel) are meant for a conversation between friends: polite, but not formal. Learn two from each group that you can pronounce confidently.

Picking up the situation

RedemittelMeaning and use
Oh, das ist echt blöd, dass …'Oh, that's really annoying that …'; showing sympathy, colloquial
Ich kann gut verstehen, dass du …'I can well understand that you …'; showing sympathy, neutral
Wenn ich dich richtig verstehe, geht es darum, ob …'If I understand you correctly, the question is whether …'; summing up the question
Das ist wirklich eine schwierige Entscheidung.'That's a really difficult decision'; gaining time without faltering

Giving advice

RedemittelMeaning and use
Ich an deiner Stelle würde …'If I were you, I would …'; clear advice, Subjunctive II
Ich würde dir raten, … (with zu + infinitive)'I'd advise you to …'; recommendation
Hast du schon mal überlegt, … zu …?'Have you ever thought about …?'; advice as a question, gentle
Es könnte sich lohnen, … (with zu + infinitive)'It might be worth …'; cautious recommendation
Am besten wäre es, wenn du …'The best thing would be for you to …'; clear recommendation
Du solltest auf jeden Fall …'You should definitely …'; firm advice

Justifying the advice

RedemittelMeaning and use
…, weil du dann …'…, because then you …'; reason in a subordinate clause
Dann hättest du nämlich …'Because then you would have …'; showing the result of the advice
Sonst riskierst du, dass …'Otherwise you risk …'; consequence of not acting
Der Vorteil wäre, dass …'The advantage would be that …'; naming the benefit
Außerdem … / Zum einen …, zum anderen …'Besides …' / 'On the one hand …, on the other …'; adding a second reason

Naming an alternative or a condition

RedemittelMeaning and use
Und falls das nicht klappt, könntest du immer noch …'And if that doesn't work, you could still …'; plan B
Eine andere Möglichkeit wäre, … (with zu + infinitive)'Another option would be …'; alternative
Das würde ich allerdings nur machen, wenn …'I'd only do that, though, if …'; condition
Was ich eher lassen würde, ist …'What I'd rather not do is …'; advising against

Closing

RedemittelMeaning and use
Ich würde es auf jeden Fall versuchen.'I'd definitely give it a try'; reinforcing the advice
Viel verlieren kannst du dabei nicht.'You haven't got much to lose'; encouraging
Sag mir dann Bescheid, wie es gelaufen ist.'Let me know how it went'; friendly close

A worked example

Practice task, entirely invented. People and situation are made up.

Nach der Vorlesung erzählt Ihnen Ihr Freund Lukas, dass er seine Hausarbeit in Soziologie in zehn Tagen abgeben muss. Gleichzeitig hat ihn sein Chef im Café gefragt, ob er in den nächsten zwei Wochen zusätzliche Schichten übernimmt, weil eine Kollegin krank ist. Lukas überlegt, die Dozentin um eine Verlängerung zu bitten, fürchtet aber, dass das einen schlechten Eindruck macht. Geben Sie Lukas einen Rat und begründen Sie ihn.

The question: apply for an extension or not? What Lukas himself mentions: a ten-day deadline, extra shifts for two weeks, worry about the impression he makes.

Notes during the preparation:

Rat: Dozentin jetzt anschreiben, neuen Termin vorschlagen weil: 1. früh = kein schlechter Eindruck 2. Schichten + Hausarbeit = zu viel sonst: mit Chef reden, weniger Schichten

This turns into the following answer:

① Picking up the situation

Oh, das ist echt ungünstig, dass das beides gleichzeitig kommt.

② Advice

Ich an deiner Stelle würde der Dozentin aber gleich heute schreiben und nicht erst kurz vor der Abgabe.

③ Two reasons, the first linked to Lukas's worry

Wenn du dich früh meldest und gleich einen neuen Termin vorschlägst, wirkt das nicht unzuverlässig, sondern organisiert. Außerdem schaffst du die Hausarbeit neben den Extraschichten kaum ordentlich, und dann leidet am Ende die Note.

④ Alternative

Und falls sie Nein sagt, würde ich mit deinem Chef reden. Vielleicht reicht es ja, wenn du nur ein, zwei Schichten mehr übernimmst.

⑤ Close

Aber frag sie auf jeden Fall, viel verlieren kannst du dabei nicht.

97 words, about 45 seconds when spoken.

The first reason takes up exactly the worry Lukas mentioned and dispels it; the second links the deadline to the extra shifts. That is why the advice is convincing although it is short. The alternative builds on the boss. If the countdown ran out after move ③, the advice and both reasons would already be recorded.

Practise yourself

Fill in the advice formulas.

Your turn2 of 3

Ich an deiner ··· würde zuerst mit der Dozentin sprechen. Hast du schon mal ···, die Prüfung zu verschieben? Es könnte sich ···, früher anzufangen. Am besten ··· es, wenn du heute noch schreibst.

Your turn3 of 3

Your advice and two reasons have been given, about 15 seconds remain, and no new argument comes to mind. What do you do?

Key takeaways

  • Hear the actual question and note it as an either-or.
  • Decide at once; what is rated is clear advice with at least two reasons, not the wisest one.
  • Note template for 30 seconds: Rat, weil (two reasons), sonst.
  • Order: the situation in one sentence, advice, two reasons (at least one with a detail from what you heard), alternative, close.
  • Address your friend with du, friendly and correct, without officialese.
  • About 90 to 105 words fill 45 seconds; make the advice concrete if you run out of things to say.

Now practise it

Giving advice

Trainer · Sprechen

Practise
Next: Weighing options
0/3

Was this article helpful?