Weighing Options (Optionen abwägen)

23 min · 5 drills

In the second task of the speaking part, a friend makes a proposal that affects you and other students and wants to know what you think. You say what speaks for it and what against it, weigh the two sides and say at the end what you decide. You have about 45 seconds of preparation and 1:30 minutes of speaking time (German: Sprechzeit) for this.

The task

The simulated person describes the proposal through the headset, and the screen shows the situation with the instruction, for example „Wägen Sie Vor- und Nachteile ab und begründen Sie Ihre Meinung.“ Then preparation and speaking time run automatically with a countdown. Notes on paper are allowed. The situation is private, so you address the person with du; that is part of the role.

The task has three parts, and each one counts: name both sides, weigh them against each other (German: abwägen), decide. If you only list arguments, you have left out one of the three parts; if you only decide, two.

The recording is assessed later by trained raters according to the provider's five criteria: relevance to the topic, task fulfilment, use of the sources, fluency and pronunciation, and language use. The result of the whole part is converted to 0 to 20 (5–9 TDN 3, 10–15 TDN 4, 16–20 TDN 5); the provider does not publish raw-score cut-offs.

CriterionHow you gainHow you lose
Relevance to the topicEvery argument concerns exactly this proposal.You talk in general about study methods or money.
Task fulfilmentAdvantages, disadvantages, weighting and a decision are audible.One side is missing, or the decision is missing.
Use of the sourcesYou use the details of the proposal: cost, duration, people involved.You overlook a condition that was mentioned.
Fluency and pronunciationYou link your thoughts audibly and keep speaking to the end.After 40 seconds you have run out of material.
Language useConnectors vary, anything hypothetical is in Subjunctive II, the tone is spoken.„Und dann … und auch …“, or sentences that sound like an essay.

Time plan

At 120 to 140 words per minute, ninety seconds correspond to about 180 to 210 words, a good ten sentences. That is enough for two developed arguments per side and a justified decision.

PhaseDurationWhat you do
Hear the proposalas long as the person speaksNote: what exactly, who, when, what does it cost?
Preparationabout 0:45Two columns with at least two keywords each, the decision underneath.
Speaking, openingabout 10 secondsPick up the proposal and hint at your leaning.
Speaking, forabout 25 secondsAt least two advantages with an example.
Speaking, againstabout 25 secondsAt least two disadvantages with an example.
Speaking, weighingabout 15 secondsSay what weighs more and why.
Speaking, decisionabout 15 secondsFor or against, ideally with a condition.

The note template for the preparation fits on half a sheet:

+ … / … − … / … → dafür/dagegen, wenn …

Write the decision down during the preparation, not while speaking. If you know where the answer ends, you can present the other side so that the weighing builds on it later.

When you run out of things to say. Develop an argument with an example that concerns you personally („Ich zum Beispiel arbeite donnerstags …“), or propose a compromise that softens the biggest disadvantage. Both deepen the weighing instead of starting something new.

When time gets short. Unlike in giving advice, the most important part comes at the end here: the decision. Keep an eye on the countdown and jump to „Unterm Strich …“ at about 20 seconds remaining at the latest, even if a disadvantage is still missing. If the fourth argument is missing, the task is only partly fulfilled; a missing decision weighs more heavily. As a safeguard, your opening already hints at your leaning.

Step by step

  1. Capture the proposal precisely. While listening, note the details: what exactly, for how long, for whom, at what price. Good arguments tie in with these details, and that is exactly how the rating notices that you used the source.
  2. First the decision, then the columns. Decide in the first seconds of the preparation which side you will take at the end. Then collect at least two keywords for each side. The other side must be genuine: a straw-man argument that nobody takes seriously makes the weighing worthless.
  3. Open with a leaning. A sentence such as „Spontan finde ich die Idee gut, aber es gibt auch einiges, was dagegen spricht“ picks up the proposal, announces both sides and secures a position in case time gets short at the end.
  4. Name the side you want to weaken last. If you are in favour in the end, the disadvantages come directly before the weighing. Then the weighing can pick them up at once, and the answer audibly leads to your decision.
  5. Develop every argument. Claim, reason, example: „Zu fünft motiviert man sich gegenseitig: Wenn einer morgens keine Lust hat, ziehen ihn die anderen mit.“ Two developed arguments per side fill the time better than four bare ones.
  6. Really weigh. Weighing means assigning weight: which argument counts more, and why? Can a disadvantage be solved? „Das Geld ist ein Problem, aber eins, das man lösen kann“ is weighing; „Es gibt Vor- und Nachteile“ is not.
  7. End with a clear decision. Yes, no, or yes under one condition. A condition shows that the decision follows from the weighing, and it makes a natural ending.

Your turn1 of 5

Which sentence really weighs things up in conversation instead of just adding another argument?

Typical pitfalls

Only one side. If you are enthusiastic about the idea, you name three advantages and then say „Also, ich bin dafür.“ The task asks for both sides, and the disadvantages are missing entirely.

Listing instead of weighing. „Dafür sprechen A und B. Dagegen sprechen C und D. Ich bin dafür.“ The arguments stand neatly side by side, but nobody learns why A and B weigh more than C and D.

No decision. „Ich glaube, das muss jeder selbst entscheiden.“ The sentence sounds diplomatic but leaves out the third part of the task. „Ich weiß nicht so recht“ is not a position either.

The position flips. At the start „Super Idee!“, at the end „Na ja, eher nicht.“ If you notice while speaking that you are changing your mind, say so: „Je länger ich darüber nachdenke, desto skeptischer werde ich.“ Then the change is justified rather than contradictory.

Essay language. „Zusammenfassend lässt sich konstatieren, dass die Vorteile überwiegen.“ Said to a friend in the cafeteria, this sounds read out. In conversation, „Unterm Strich finde ich die Vorteile stärker“ fits.

Leaving the topic. The proposal concerns a study week, the answer is about exam anxiety in general. Every sentence may be correct, and still relevance to the topic is missing.

Done after 40 seconds. Four arguments in one sentence each, a decision, then silence. Ninety seconds call for developed thoughts; otherwise fluency suffers and the raters hear too little language.

Subjunctive II for the proposal

The proposal has not been put into practice yet. Talking about its advantages and disadvantages therefore means describing not facts but an imagined situation: what would happen if the group did it this way. German has Subjunctive II for this. It marks the plan as an idea still under discussion, and that is exactly what the TDN 5 criterion names: anything hypothetical is in Subjunctive II. The indicative is not wrong here, but it is the weaker choice.

With most verbs you form it with würde + infinitive: Wir würden viel Zeit sparen ('we would save a lot of time'). A handful of frequent verbs have a form of their own, and in conversation it sounds more natural than the paraphrase. With the modal verbs it is obligatory: könnte, not würde können.

InfinitiveSubjunctive IIExample
seinwäreDas wäre für alle billiger. ('That would be cheaper for everyone.')
habenhätteDann hätten wir abends frei. ('Then we would have the evenings off.')
könnenkönnteIch könnte freitags im Café arbeiten. ('I could work in the café on Fridays.')
müssenmüssteJemand müsste die Räume buchen. ('Someone would have to book the rooms.')
es gibtes gäbeDann gäbe es keine Ausreden mehr. ('Then there would be no more excuses.')
bleibenbliebeEs bliebe mehr Zeit für die Hausarbeit. ('There would be more time left for the term paper.')
kommenkämeDazu käme die lange Anfahrt. ('On top of that would come the long journey.')
gehengingeDas ginge nur mit einem festen Plan. ('That would only work with a fixed plan.')

A condition takes Subjunctive II in both halves of the sentence. With regular verbs the form of its own sounds like the simple past (wenn wir verlegten), so in conversation you use würde there:

Indicative, like a fixed plan: Wenn wir die Lerngruppe auf den Abend verlegen, kommen weniger Leute, und wir sind schneller fertig.

Subjunctive II, as a thought experiment: Wenn wir die Lerngruppe auf den Abend verlegen würden, kämen wahrscheinlich weniger Leute, und wir wären schneller fertig.

The indicative stays where you talk about facts: what the proposal lays down, what already applies today and what is generally true. Die Wohnung kostet 150 Euro pro Person ('the flat costs 150 euros per person') reports a detail of the proposal, Das wäre für mich zu teuer ('that would be too expensive for me') assesses the imagined situation. Zu fünft motiviert man sich gegenseitig ('in a group of five you motivate each other') describes a general experience and needs no subjunctive. Your opinion is in the indicative too (Ich finde die Vorteile stärker); only what would follow from your decision goes back into Subjunctive II (Dann würde ich mitfahren).

Two habits weaken language use here most often. If you describe the consequences in the indicative or the future tense (Das wird teuer, Dann haben wir keine Zeit mehr), you talk about the idea as if it were a fixed plan. That is not wrong, but it gives away the form the TDN 5 criterion names. If you combine würde with a modal verb or double it within one sentence (Wenn wir fahren würden, würden wir mehr lernen können), you build a clumsy form where könnten wir mehr lernen is enough.

The proposal under discussion: from now on, the study group would meet on Fridays in the laboratory building on campus instead of in the city library. Fill in the right form.

Your turn2 of 5

Ein großer Vorteil ···, dass wir weniger pendeln. Dann ··· ich vorher noch im Labor arbeiten. Allerdings ··· ich dann keine Mensa in der Nähe. Wenn uns der Hausmeister einen Schlüssel ···, wäre ich dabei.

Useful phrases

These useful phrases (German: Redemittel) are spoken German for a conversation between students: factual in content, relaxed in tone. Learn two from each group that you can recall without thinking.

Picking up the proposal

RedemittelMeaning and use
Interessante Idee, darüber hab ich noch gar nicht nachgedacht.'Interesting idea, I hadn't thought about that at all'; gaining time, showing interest
Spontan finde ich das gut/schwierig, aber …'My first reaction is that it's good/difficult, but …'; hinting at a leaning
Lass mich mal kurz überlegen, was dafür und was dagegen spricht.'Let me think for a moment about what speaks for and against it'; announcing both sides

Naming advantages

RedemittelMeaning and use
Was auf jeden Fall dafür spricht, ist …'What definitely speaks for it is …'; strongest argument in favour
Ein großer Vorteil wäre, dass …'A big advantage would be that …'; advantage in Subjunctive II
Und noch was: …'And another thing: …'; further argument, colloquial
Das hätte außerdem den Vorteil, dass …'That would also have the advantage that …'; further argument, neutral

Naming disadvantages and concerns

RedemittelMeaning and use
Der Haken dabei ist …'The catch is …'; strongest argument against
Was mich ein bisschen stört, ist …'What bothers me a bit is …'; concern, personal
Ich hab auch ein bisschen Angst, dass …'I'm also a bit worried that …'; naming a risk
Man darf aber nicht vergessen, dass …'But we mustn't forget that …'; introducing a counter-argument

Conceding and contrasting

RedemittelMeaning and use
Einerseits …, andererseits …'On the one hand …, on the other …'; contrasting two sides
Klar, …, aber …'Sure, …, but …'; conceding, colloquial
Das stimmt schon, nur …'That's true, it's just that …'; conceding and qualifying

Weighing

RedemittelMeaning and use
Wenn ich beides abwäge, …'When I weigh up both sides, …'; introducing the weighing (the verb follows directly: …, finde ich …)
… ist mir ehrlich gesagt wichtiger als …'To be honest, … matters more to me than …'; assigning weight
Das ist ein Problem, aber eins, das man lösen kann, zum Beispiel …'That's a problem, but one that can be solved, for example …'; softening a disadvantage
Das würde für mich nur dann ins Gewicht fallen, wenn …'That would only matter to me if …'; condition for a counter-argument

Deciding

RedemittelMeaning and use
Unterm Strich bin ich dafür/dagegen.'All in all, I'm for/against it'; decision
Ich wär dabei, aber nur unter einer Bedingung: …'I'd be in, but only on one condition: …'; decision with a condition
Also, ich würde es machen/lassen, weil …'So I'd do it/not do it, because …'; decision with a reason

Many phrases from written argumentation have a more relaxed counterpart in conversation. Match them:

Your turn3 of 5

A worked example

Practice task, entirely invented. People, places and prices are made up.

Ihre Freundin Sophie lernt mit Ihnen und drei anderen für die Statistikklausur in drei Wochen. Sie schlägt vor, dass die Gruppe für eine Woche gemeinsam eine Ferienwohnung an einem See mietet und dort nur lernt. Das würde etwa 150 Euro pro Person kosten. Sophie fragt, was Sie davon halten. Wägen Sie Vor- und Nachteile ab und begründen Sie Ihre Meinung.

What Sophie mentions: one week, five people, a holiday flat by a lake, 150 Euro per person, the exam in three weeks.

Notes during the preparation:

+ keine Ablenkung / zu fünft motiviert − 150 Euro / Urlaub statt Lernen? → dafür, wenn fester Plan + billiger

This turns into the following answer:

① Picking up the proposal, hinting at a leaning

Eine Lernwoche am See? Spannende Idee, spontan finde ich sie gut, aber es gibt auch einiges, was dagegen spricht.

② What speaks for it

Was auf jeden Fall dafür spricht, ist die Konzentration. Hier zu Hause lenkt einen ja ständig irgendwas ab, der Job, die WG, das Handy. Wenn wir eine Woche wegfahren würden, gäbe es nur uns und den Stoff. Und zu fünft motiviert man sich gegenseitig: Wenn einer morgens keine Lust hat, ziehen ihn die anderen mit.

③ What speaks against it

Der Haken dabei ist allerdings das Geld. Hundertfünfzig Euro pro Person sind für viele von uns echt viel, gerade jetzt am Semesterende. Und ehrlich gesagt hab ich auch ein bisschen Angst, dass aus der Lernwoche ganz schnell eine Urlaubswoche werden könnte, wenn die Sonne scheint und der See direkt vor der Tür liegt.

④ Weighing

Wenn ich beides abwäge, finde ich die Vorteile trotzdem stärker. Das Geld ist ein Problem, aber eins, das man lösen kann, zum Beispiel mit einer einfacheren Unterkunft oder mit nur vier Nächten.

⑤ Decision with a condition

Unterm Strich bin ich also dafür, aber nur unter einer Bedingung: Wir machen vorher einen festen Plan, wer an welchem Tag welches Kapitel vorbereitet, und lernen jeden Tag bis zum Nachmittag. Dann könnten wir abends mit gutem Gewissen schwimmen gehen.

199 words, about 1:30 minutes when spoken.

The disadvantages come directly before the weighing, which picks up both: the money problem is softened, and the risk of a holiday week is resolved in the condition. Every detail of Sophie's proposal appears: the price, the week, the lake. If time had got short after move ③, the sentence „Unterm Strich bin ich dafür, wenn wir einen festen Plan machen“ would have been the emergency brake. Where the answer pictures what the week would be like, it uses Subjunctive II (gäbe, werden könnte, könnten); what is generally true or fixed in the proposal stays in the indicative.

Practise yourself

Your turn4 of 5

About 20 seconds remain and you are in the middle of the disadvantages; a third disadvantage has just occurred to you. What makes most sense?

Fill in the phrases in this piece of weighing.

Your turn5 of 5

Was auf jeden Fall ··· spricht, ist die Ruhe. Der ··· dabei ist allerdings der Preis. Wenn ich beides ···, finde ich die Ruhe wichtiger. Unterm ··· bin ich also dafür.

Key takeaways

  • Three parts count: name both sides with at least two arguments each, weigh them, decide.
  • Note template for 45 seconds: plus, minus, an arrow to the decision with a condition.
  • Open with a leaning; it secures a position in case time gets short.
  • Name the side you want to weaken directly before the weighing.
  • Weighing means assigning weight or solving a disadvantage, not "there are pros and cons".
  • About 180 to 210 words fill 90 seconds; jump to the decision 20 seconds before the end at the latest.
  • What the proposal would bring about goes in Subjunctive II (wäre, hätte, könnte, otherwise würde + infinitive); facts and your opinion go in the indicative.
  • Speak as in a conversation, not as in an essay.

Now practise it

Weighing options

Trainer · Sprechen

Practise
Next: Summarising a text
0/5

Was this article helpful?