Writing an Argumentative Text (Argumentativen Text schreiben)

18 min · 4 drills

The first task of the writing part asks for a post on a course's learning platform. A lecturer puts a contested question up for discussion, and you set out what speaks for it and what against it, and finish by taking a reasoned position. You have 30 minutes and write at least 200 words.

The task

The screen shows a short description of the situation, the question and a few instructions, for example: present advantages and disadvantages, make your own stance clear and justify it. In our estimate, perspectives may also be set, such as that of the students and that of the university. You type your text into a text field; a counter shows at all times how many words you have written.

The text is rated by trained raters, not automatically. For writing, the provider names five criteria: relevance to the topic, task fulfilment (German: Erfüllung der Aufgabe), use of the sources, range of language and comprehensibility. Use of the sources mainly concerns the second task, because the first task offers no material besides the question. Both tasks together give a score on a scale of 0 to 20: 5–9 points correspond to TDN 3, 10–15 points to TDN 4, 16–20 points to TDN 5. The provider does not publish how many raw points each level requires.

For the other four criteria, this means in practice for this task:

CriterionHow you gainHow you lose
Relevance to the topicEvery paragraph answers the question asked.You write in general terms about a neighbouring topic.
Task fulfilmentPro, contra and a reasoned position are there; the text type forum post is recognisable.One side is missing, or the position is missing or unjustified.
Range of languageYou vary sentence structure and connectors and use precise words.Every argument starts with "Ein weiterer Vorteil ist".
ComprehensibilityParagraphs, clear references, sentences that are understood on first reading.One block without paragraphs, nested sentences, unclear pronouns.

Time plan

Thirty minutes are enough for 230 to 270 words if you do not start writing straight away. A proven sequence:

PhaseTimeWhat you do
Read the task3 minRead the question and instructions, mark every required element (pro, contra, perspectives, position).
Collect arguments5 minNote two to three arguments per side in key words, each with an example.
Outline2 minChoose the strongest argument on each side, fix your position, decide the order.
Write16 minWrite paragraph by paragraph following the outline.
Check4 minCheck word count, verb position, endings, connectors, greeting and sign-off.

Fix your position during the outline phase, not only when you reach the conclusion. If you know where the text ends, you can present the counterarguments in a way that makes the weighing up credible later.

Step by step

  1. Reduce the question to its core. Put into one sentence for yourself what is to be decided. With "Sollten alle Vorlesungen aufgezeichnet werden?" the issue is a rule for all lectures, not whether recordings are useful. This sentence protects you from a typical topic error.
  2. Use the instructions as a checklist. Every instruction is part of the task fulfilment rating. If it says "from the perspective of the students and of the university", each perspective needs at least one sentence.
  3. Collect arguments, then select. Note more than you need and keep two per side. A good argument consists of a claim, a reason and an example. Three bare claims convince less than two developed ones.
  4. Write to a fixed plan. An introduction with the question, one paragraph pro, one paragraph contra, one paragraph weighing up (German: Abwägung) with your own position, a short conclusion. Put the side you intend to weaken in the end directly before the weighing up: then the weighing up can take it up immediately, and the text leads logically to your position.
  5. Really weigh up. Weighing up means giving arguments weight: which one counts for more, under what condition does it hold, can a disadvantage be reduced? A sentence like "There are advantages and disadvantages" is not weighing up.
  6. Keep to the text type. A forum post (German: Forumsbeitrag) addresses the lecturer and fellow students and ends with a short sign-off, but stays factual. Personal experience is allowed as an example, not as the main argument.
  7. Check in a targeted way. Do not simply read through once more; check specific sources of error one after another: first verb position in subordinate clauses, then case endings after prepositions, finally the word count.

Your turn1 of 4

Which sentence weighs up instead of merely listing one more argument?

Typical pitfalls

Missing the topic. The question is whether all lectures should be recorded, but the text talks about online learning in general. Every sentence may be correct, and the text still loses on relevance to the topic.

Only one side. Anyone convinced from the start writes three paragraphs pro and mentions the other side in a subordinate clause. The instruction requires both sides, so part of the task is missing.

Listing instead of weighing up. Pro and contra stand neatly side by side, followed by "Ich bin dafür." Without a reason why one side counts for more, the position remains a mere claim.

The position flips. The introduction says "Ich bin klar dagegen", the conclusion "Insgesamt überwiegen die Vorteile". Fix your position beforehand and keep the introduction neutral.

Wrong text type. "Hallo Leute, wie geht's?" is too colloquial, "Sehr geehrte Damen und Herren" suits an official letter. In a course forum, "Liebe Frau Dr. Wendland, liebe Kommilitoninnen und Kommilitonen" fits.

Template without content. "Einerseits ist das Thema wichtig, andererseits gibt es auch andere Aspekte." The sentence contains two connectors and no idea. Useful phrases only count when they carry an argument.

Too short or incomprehensible. With 170 words the requirement is not met. Conversely, 400 words do not help if the sentences are so nested that one has to read them twice.

Useful phrases

The following phrases (German: Redemittel) are ordered by function. Learn two from each group that you master securely rather than all of them halfway.

Introducing the topic

  • Die Frage, ob …, wird seit einiger Zeit kontrovers diskutiert. (The question whether … has been debated controversially for some time.)
  • Ob …, ist umstritten. (Whether … is disputed.)
  • Im Folgenden möchte ich die wichtigsten Argumente beider Seiten darlegen. (In what follows I would like to set out the main arguments on both sides.)

Presenting arguments

  • Für … spricht vor allem, dass … (The main point in favour of … is that …)
  • Ein gewichtiges Argument für/gegen … ist … (A weighty argument for/against … is …)
  • Hinzu kommt, dass … (In addition, …)
  • Nicht zuletzt ist zu bedenken, dass … (Last but not least, one must consider that …)

Naming a perspective

  • Aus Sicht der Studierenden … (From the students’ point of view …)
  • Für die Hochschule bedeutet das, dass … (For the university, this means that …)
  • Was die Lehrenden betrifft, so … (As far as the lecturers are concerned, …)
  • Vom Standpunkt der … aus betrachtet, … (Seen from the standpoint of the …, …)

Conceding

  • Zwar trifft es zu, dass …, doch … (It is true that …, but …)
  • Es ist nicht von der Hand zu weisen, dass … (It cannot be denied that …)
  • Zugegebenermaßen … (Admittedly …)
  • Man mag einwenden, dass … (One may object that …)

Expressing contrast

  • Andererseits … (On the other hand …)
  • Dem steht entgegen, dass … (Against this stands the fact that …)
  • Während …, … (While …, …)
  • …, wohingegen … (…, whereas …)

Giving examples

  • Dies zeigt sich etwa daran, dass … (This can be seen, for instance, in the fact that …)
  • Ein Beispiel dafür ist … (One example of this is …)
  • So … (with the verb in second position: So können Studierende …; thus, for example)

Weighing up

  • Wägt man die Argumente gegeneinander ab, so … (If one weighs the arguments against each other, …)
  • Schwerer wiegt meines Erachtens, dass … (In my view, what weighs more heavily is that …)
  • … fällt stärker ins Gewicht als … (… carries more weight than …)
  • Dieser Nachteil ließe sich entschärfen, indem … (This disadvantage could be reduced by …)
  • Das gilt allerdings nur unter der Bedingung, dass … (This only applies, however, on condition that …)

Taking a position and concluding

  • Ich spreche mich daher für/gegen … aus. (I am therefore in favour of/against …)
  • Aus den genannten Gründen halte ich … für sinnvoll/verfehlt. (For the reasons given, I consider … sensible/misguided.)
  • Alles in allem überwiegen für mich … (All in all, for me … outweigh …)
  • Entscheidend ist für mich letztlich, dass … (What is ultimately decisive for me is that …)

Argumentative texts depend on fixed combinations in which only one particular verb fits. Match them:

Your turn2 of 4

A worked example

Practice task, entirely invented. People and situation are made up.

Auf der Lernplattform Ihres Kurses „Einführung in das wissenschaftliche Arbeiten“ hat Ihre Dozentin, Frau Dr. Wendland, eine Diskussion eröffnet: Sollten alle Vorlesungen aufgezeichnet und online bereitgestellt werden? Stellen Sie dar, was dafür und was dagegen spricht, und machen Sie Ihre eigene Haltung deutlich. Schreiben Sie mindestens 200 Wörter.

Core of the question: a rule for all lectures. Required: pro, contra, own reasoned position, forum post.

Notes from the first ten minutes: Pro: attendance despite a side job or children; difficult passages can be listened to several times, especially with a different first language. Contra: empty lecture halls, no spontaneous questions; lecturers more cautious on camera. Position: in favour, but as a supplement. Reason: equal opportunities count for more, the disadvantage can be reduced.

This produces the following post:

① Greeting and introduction: take up the question, announce the procedure

Liebe Frau Dr. Wendland, liebe Kommilitoninnen und Kommilitonen,

an unserer Fakultät wird seit dem letzten Semester darüber gestritten, ob sämtliche Vorlesungen aufgezeichnet und auf der Lernplattform bereitgestellt werden sollten. Im Folgenden möchte ich die wichtigsten Argumente beider Seiten darlegen und anschließend meine eigene Position begründen.

② Pro: two arguments with reasons

Für Aufzeichnungen spricht vor allem, dass sie Studierenden mit Nebenjob oder Kindern die Teilnahme erheblich erleichtern. Wer eine Sitzung verpasst, ist nicht länger auf lückenhafte Mitschriften anderer angewiesen. Hinzu kommt, dass man sich schwierige Passagen mehrmals anhören kann, was gerade für Studierende mit einer anderen Erstsprache eine große Hilfe ist.

③ Contra: two arguments, introduced with a concession

Es ist jedoch nicht von der Hand zu weisen, dass sich die Hörsäle leeren, wenn jede Sitzung online verfügbar ist. Damit fallen spontane Rückfragen und Diskussionen weg, die eine Vorlesung erst lebendig machen. Außerdem berichten manche Lehrende, dass sie sich vor laufender Kamera weniger trauen, unfertige Gedanken oder aktuelle Beispiele einzubringen.

④ Weighing up: give weight, reduce a disadvantage

Wägt man diese Argumente gegeneinander ab, fällt meines Erachtens die Chancengleichheit stärker ins Gewicht. Denn wer wegen einer Schicht im Nebenjob eine Sitzung versäumt, gerät ohne Aufzeichnung schnell ins Hintertreffen. Das Problem der leeren Hörsäle ließe sich zudem entschärfen, etwa indem man die Aufzeichnungen erst nach einigen Tagen freischaltet oder Diskussionsphasen grundsätzlich nicht mitschneidet.

⑤ Conclusion: position with a condition

Ich spreche mich daher für Aufzeichnungen aus, allerdings nur als Ergänzung zur Präsenzlehre und keinesfalls als deren Ersatz. Entscheidend ist für mich letztlich, dass niemand wegen seiner Lebensumstände den Anschluss verliert.

Viele Grüße
Amira

234 words including greeting and sign-off.

The pro paragraph comes first, although the writer is in favour in the end. This puts the contra arguments directly before the weighing up, which takes them up, weights them and partly defuses them. Each instruction of the task has its own paragraph, each side two reasoned arguments, and no connector appears twice.

This practice task sets no perspectives. If a task does ask you to present advantages and disadvantages from, say, the students’ and the university’s point of view, the perspectives do not get paragraphs of their own. The plan stays the same, but in the pro and the contra paragraph you explicitly assign each argument to a perspective. Make sure each perspective appears at least once, ideally on both sides, and name it with a phrase from the group “Naming a perspective” so that the raters see the assignment at once. Applied to the recording question, the pro paragraph could begin like this:

Aus Sicht der Studierenden spricht für Aufzeichnungen vor allem, dass niemand wegen einer Schicht im Nebenjob den Stoff einer Sitzung verpasst. Für die Hochschule wiederum liegt der Vorteil darin, dass sie mehr Studierende erreichen kann, als ihre Hörsäle fassen. (From the students’ point of view, the main argument for recordings is that nobody misses the content of a session because of a shift in a side job. For the university, in turn, the advantage is that it can reach more students than its lecture halls hold.)

Practise yourself

Fill in the useful phrases in this weighing-up paragraph.

Your turn3 of 4

··· trifft es zu, dass Aufzeichnungen Zeit sparen, ··· fällt der Verlust an Austausch stärker ins ···. Dieser Nachteil ließe sich jedoch ···, indem man Diskussionen nicht mitschneidet.

Your turn4 of 4

4 minutes are left. Your text has 185 words, and the conclusion with your position is still missing. What makes most sense?

Key takeaways

  • Reduce the question to one sentence and use the instructions as a checklist.
  • Plan ten minutes before writing: read, collect, outline. Fix your position at this stage.
  • Plan: introduction, pro, contra, weighing up with position, conclusion; two reasoned arguments per side.
  • Weighing up means giving weight or setting conditions, not "there are advantages and disadvantages".
  • Forum post: address the lecturer and the course, factual tone, short sign-off.
  • Vary the useful phrases and let each one carry an argument.
  • Aim for 230 to 270 words and finish by checking verb position and endings in a targeted way.

Now practise it

Argumentative text

Trainer · Schreiben

Practise
Next: Summarising a text and a graph
0/4

Was this article helpful?