Sorting Statements under a Pair of Concepts (Aussagen einem Begriffspaar zuordnen)
The sixth task of the Reading part combines two checks in one. You read a text and see next to it a table with two columns headed by two concepts, for example Vorteile für Mieter and Vorteile für Vermieter (advantages for tenants, advantages for landlords). From a set of statements (German: Aussagen) you choose those that render the text correctly and place each under the concept it belongs to.
The task
The two concepts form a pair (German: Begriffspaar): two groups affected by the same thing, two sides of a phenomenon, two related ideas. The text deals with both. Below the table there are more statements than you need. Only the correct ones are placed; the false ones are distractors and stay where they are. Four statements are to be placed. Do not count on the statements following the order of the text.
The statements often do not name the concept. They begin with Sie, Es or Ihre ('They', 'It', 'Their') and leave open who is meant: that is exactly what you are to work out from the text. A statement is therefore solved only when two things are settled: that it is true, and whom it is about.
The four placements are four of the 34 items in the Reading part and are scored automatically. The raw points of the whole part are converted to a scale from 0 to 20: 5–9 points correspond to TDN 3, 10–15 points to TDN 4, 16–20 points to TDN 5. The provider does not publish how many correct answers are needed for each level.
You have 7 minutes for the four placements. Most of the time goes not into placing but into sorting out the false statements. One way to split it: half a minute for the two concepts, two and a half minutes for one full pass through the text, three and a half for the statements (with eight statements, a little over 25 seconds each), and the last half minute for the final check.
Step by step
- Understand the pair of concepts. Ask yourself along which axis the two concepts differ: two groups of people, two points in time, two systems. That axis is the criterion for the second decision.
- Sort the text by concept. While reading, remember where the text speaks about one concept and where about the other. Signals such as dagegen (by contrast), für … bedeutet das ('for … this means'), auf der anderen Seite (on the other hand) often mark the switch.
- True or false first, then the column. For each statement, find the passage in the text and check whether it says exactly what the statement claims. Only if the statement is true do you ask which concept it belongs to. If you ask about the column first, you easily take a statement to be correct just because it fits the concept well. Making the two decisions separately prevents exactly that. At the passage, also check whether the text states a fact or only a plan, and for which point in time its information holds.
- Settle the reference. For a true statement that names no concept, the passage in the text supplies the reference: if it stands in the paragraph about retailers, is the subject there actually the retailer? Check the grammatical subject (German: Subjekt) of the sentence in the text, not the topic of the paragraph.
- Only the text counts. General knowledge does not help here and often does harm. The false statements are built to sound plausible, and a correct one may well contradict what you would expect.
- Count. You place four statements. If you have five candidates, one is false: check the statements with absolute words first (immer, alle, deutlich, nur: always, all, clearly, only). If you have three, recheck the statements you struck out because the text says them in other words. If the table shows a fixed number of slots per column, that is a check too: three candidates for a column with two slots means one of them is wrong.
Typical traps
The false statements and the placement errors follow six patterns. The examples refer to the pair A: Folgen für Studierende and B: Folgen für Hochschulen (consequences for students, consequences for universities).
True, but under the wrong concept. The statement is correct but belongs to the other column. This happens above all when the sentence in the text names both sides.
In the text: Seit die Hochschulen Teilzeitstudiengänge anbieten, müssen sie mehr Abendkurse planen; die Studierenden können dafür neben dem Beruf studieren.
Statement: Sie müssen mehr Veranstaltungen am Abend organisieren. True, but B: it is the universities that have to plan, not the students.
Features of both sides mixed. The statement combines a feature of one side with the other side or reverses a relationship. Each half occurs in the text; the whole does not.
In the text: Die Studierenden zahlen eine geringere Semestergebühr. Die Hochschulen erhalten dafür einen Zuschuss vom Land.
Statement: Sie erhalten vom Land einen Zuschuss und zahlen eine geringere Gebühr. False: the students pay the lower fee, the universities get the subsidy. For neither side is the whole statement true.
Plausible, but not in the text. The statement sounds like an obvious consequence, but the text does not say it. Often it is a conclusion you would draw yourself, or a generalisation with immer or alle.
In the text: Viele Teilzeitstudierende brauchen länger bis zum Abschluss.
Statement: Sie zahlen insgesamt mehr Semestergebühren. False: fees are not mentioned, only the length of study.
A plan presented as a fact. The statement presents as existing what the text only plans, examines, wishes for or announces. In the text, watch for will (wants to), soll (in the sense of planned), plant (plans), prüft, ob (is checking whether), erwägt (is considering), wünscht sich (would like) or ist noch offen (is still open). A statement about the present without such words claims that things are already so. If the statement itself names the plan, it can be true.
In the text: Die Hochschulen wollen ab dem nächsten Jahr mehr Kurse am Wochenende anbieten.
Statement: Sie bieten mehr Kurse am Wochenende an. False: this is only a plan. Statement: Sie planen zusätzliche Kurse am Wochenende. True, B.
The right figure, the wrong period. The number or property is in the text, but there it applies to a different point in time or period: before rather than after a change, only for one phase rather than the whole year. For every number and every comparison, check when it applies. Signals are vor (before), seit (since), nach (after), früher (earlier), heute (today), in der ersten Woche (in the first week) or insgesamt (overall).
In the text: Vor der Reform brach fast jeder dritte Teilzeitstudierende das Studium ab. Seitdem ist es nur noch etwa jeder fünfte.
Statement: Fast ein Drittel von ihnen gibt das Studium auf. False: this figure applies to the time before the reform; today it is about one in five.
A quantity word that inflates the share. The statement names a quantity (die meisten, most; die Mehrheit, the majority; fast alle, almost all), the text a share. Turn the word into a number and compare: die meisten and die Mehrheit mean more than half, fast alle far more. Ein Drittel (a third), jeder fünfte (one in five), zwei von fünf (two in five) and even knapp die Hälfte (just under half) are less. A smaller share only fits words like einige (some) or ein Teil (part of them).
In the text: Rund 45 Prozent der Teilzeitstudierenden arbeiten mehr als zwanzig Stunden pro Woche.
Statement: Die meisten von ihnen arbeiten mehr als zwanzig Stunden pro Woche. False: 45 percent is less than half. Statement: Ein Teil von ihnen arbeitet mehr als zwanzig Stunden pro Woche. True, A.
A worked example, step by step
Practice text, entirely invented. People, studies and numbers are made up.
Zwei Speicher im Kopf
Wer eine Telefonnummer liest und sie gleich danach eintippt, nutzt das Arbeitsgedächtnis. Es hält Informationen für wenige Sekunden bereit, damit wir mit ihnen rechnen, sprechen oder planen können. Seine Kapazität ist eng begrenzt: Die meisten Menschen können nur etwa vier Einheiten gleichzeitig behalten. Wird man abgelenkt, ist der Inhalt in der Regel sofort verloren.
Das Langzeitgedächtnis speichert dagegen Wissen und Erlebnisse über Jahre. Eine feste Obergrenze für seinen Umfang hat die Forschung bisher nicht gefunden. Allerdings gelangt nur hinein, was wiederholt oder mit bereits Bekanntem verknüpft wird. Ein Teil dieser Verankerung geschieht im Schlaf, wie die Psychologin Ines Hartwig in mehreren Studien zeigen konnte.
Beide Systeme arbeiten eng zusammen. Beim Lesen etwa ruft das Arbeitsgedächtnis Wortbedeutungen aus dem Langzeitgedächtnis ab. Mit zunehmendem Alter lässt vor allem die Leistung des Arbeitsgedächtnisses nach, während gut verankertes Wissen meist erhalten bleibt.
| A: Arbeitsgedächtnis | B: Langzeitgedächtnis |
|---|---|
- Es behält Inhalte meist auch dann, wenn man kurz abgelenkt wird.
- Für seinen Umfang ist bisher keine feste Grenze bekannt.
- Neue Inhalte werden dort zum Teil während des Schlafs gefestigt.
- Im Alter verliert es meist stärker an Leistung als das andere System.
- Es speichert alles, was man einmal bewusst wahrgenommen hat.
- Es kann nur wenige Einheiten zugleich festhalten.
- Es ruft beim Lesen Wortbedeutungen aus dem Arbeitsgedächtnis ab.
- Durch Training lässt sich seine Kapazität dauerhaft verdoppeln.
First step: true or false. Each statement is checked against its passage in the text, without thinking about the columns.
- Statement 1: false. The text says the opposite: Wird man abgelenkt, ist der Inhalt in der Regel sofort verloren ('If you are distracted, the content is usually lost at once').
- Statement 2: true. Eine feste Obergrenze für seinen Umfang hat die Forschung bisher nicht gefunden ('Research has not yet found a fixed upper limit to its size') means, in other words, that no fixed limit is known.
- Statement 3: true. Ein Teil dieser Verankerung geschieht im Schlaf ('Part of this anchoring happens during sleep'). Zum Teil corresponds to ein Teil (partly, a part).
- Statement 4: true. Mit zunehmendem Alter lässt vor allem die Leistung des Arbeitsgedächtnisses nach ('With age it is above all the performance of working memory that declines'), whereas well-anchored knowledge meist erhalten bleibt (is mostly retained). Vor allem (above all) carries the comparison stärker als das andere System (more than the other system).
- Statement 5: false. Only what wiederholt oder mit bereits Bekanntem verknüpft wird ('is repeated or linked to what is already known') gets in, not everything perceived. The statement echoes the unlimited store of statement 2 but says too much.
- Statement 6: true. Nur etwa vier Einheiten gleichzeitig ('only about four units at a time') means few units at once.
- Statement 7: false. Here the sides are mixed. Working memory retrieves aus dem Langzeitgedächtnis (from long-term memory), not the other way round. Since the word Arbeitsgedächtnis appears in the statement itself, its subject can only be long-term memory, and the text does not claim this of it.
- Statement 8: false. The text says nothing about training. The statement sounds like a plausible consequence, nothing more.
Four statements are true: 2, 3, 4 and 6. The number is right, so no candidate is surplus.
Second step: the column.
- Statement 2 → B. The sentence stands in the paragraph on long-term memory, and seinen Umfang (its size) refers there to long-term memory.
- Statement 3 → B. Diese Verankerung (this anchoring) means getting into long-term memory, which the previous sentence talks about. The reference follows from the text, not from which system you yourself would associate with sleep.
- Statement 4 → A. It is the performance of working memory that declines. General knowledge tends to link forgetfulness in old age with long-term memory; the text says the opposite.
- Statement 6 → A. The four units belong to working memory.
Each column holds two statements, exactly as many as the table has slots.
Practise yourself
Both questions refer to the same short text and the same pair of concepts: A: Folgen für Pendelnde and B: Folgen für Anwohnende (consequences for commuters, consequences for residents).
Seit die Stadt die Parkgebühren in der Innenstadt verdoppelt hat, fahren deutlich mehr Pendlerinnen und Pendler mit der Bahn zur Arbeit. Wer im Zentrum wohnt, findet seitdem leichter einen Parkplatz, klagt aber über den zunehmenden Lieferverkehr.
Your turn1 of 2
Statement: 'Sie finden seit der Erhöhung seltener einen Parkplatz.' Where does it go?
Your turn2 of 2
Statement: 'Sie steigen häufiger auf öffentliche Verkehrsmittel um.' Where does it go?
Key takeaways
- First clarify how the two concepts differ, and sort the text accordingly while you read.
- Make two separate decisions: true or false against the text first, then the column. False statements are not placed.
- The reference comes from the subject of the sentence in the text, not from the topic of the paragraph and not from your general knowledge.
- Distractors are true but wrongly assigned, mix features of both sides, sound plausible without being in the text, present a plan as a fact, or take a figure from the wrong period.
- Count at the end: four statements, distributed over the slots of the table.
Was this article helpful?