Matching Statements to Speakers (Aussagen Personen zuordnen)
In the fourth task of the listening part (German: Hören) you watch a panel discussion (German: Podiumsdiskussion) as a video: a moderator and two guests, person A and person B, who take different positions on a contested question. Next to it are six statements (German: Aussagen). For each one you decide who holds it: A, B, both or neither.
The task does not test whether you recognise a topic, but whether you hear who agrees with a statement. In a discussion a great deal is mentioned, quoted and rejected that nobody holds.
The task
The screen shows a table with six statements and four columns: A, B, beide (both), keiner (neither). Each statement has exactly one correct answer. The discussion plays once: in the exam as a video, in the trainer as audio only. The picture helps at most to tell the voices apart. Notes on paper are allowed.
| Phase | Time | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| Before listening | 45 s | read the six statements, reduce each to a keyword, draw a grid on paper with six rows and columns A and B |
| While listening | one recording | at each keyword, note for A and B: holds it (+), rejects it (−), only mentions it (?) |
| After listening | 45 s | derive the answer from the signs, decide rows without a sign |
Forty-five seconds for six statements is a little over seven seconds per statement. That is enough to read each once and give it a keyword, but not to learn it by heart.
The task is scored automatically. Each statement counts as a separate item. The listening part as a whole is converted to a scale of 0 to 20 (TDN 3 = 5–9, TDN 4 = 10–15, TDN 5 = 16–20); the test provider does not publish how many correct answers a level requires.
Step by step
- Reduce each statement to a keyword. The keyword is the part by which you recognise the statement in the conversation: "Arbeitgeber schauen vor allem auf Noten" (employers look mainly at grades) becomes "Arbeitgeber/Noten". Write the keywords into your grid. While listening, you then compare six keywords with the conversation instead of six whole sentences.
- Mark the word in each statement that makes it narrow. "Vor allem" (mainly), "nur" (only), "alle" (all), "sollte" (should), "mehr als" (more than). A person who raises the topic but does not share the "nur" does not hold the statement.
- Distinguish three ways an idea can come up. A person can hold it ("Ich bin überzeugt, dass …", I am convinced that …; "Da gebe ich Ihnen recht", you are right there; "Damit kann ich gut leben", I can live with that), reject it ("Das glaube ich nicht", I don't believe that; "Das ginge mir zu weit", that would go too far for me) or merely mention it, usually as someone else's opinion ("Es heißt oft …", it is often said …; "Einige Kollegen befürchten …", some colleagues fear …; "Herr B meint ja …", Mr B thinks …). Only holding it counts.
- Note who brings the idea up. If it comes from the moderator, it belongs to neither guest until one of them explicitly agrees. The moderator's questions are often claims from public debate that both guests then reject.
- Follow each statement to the other person's response. A "both" often arises only when B reacts to A: "Da sind wir uns einig" (we agree on that). A concession is agreement too when it concerns the content: "Natürlich kostet das mehr Zeit, das bestreite ich nicht" (of course it takes more time, I don't dispute that) means the person considers the statement true. If, on the other hand, the person only grants that something seems so and then disagrees, that is not agreement (see "'Sounds good, but …'" under Typical traps).
- Derive the answer from the signs. A plus only for A gives A, a plus only for B gives B, a plus for both gives both. No plus, however many minuses and question marks, gives neither.
Typical traps
- Mentioned is not held. "Einige Kollegen befürchten, dass ohne Noten niemand mehr lernt. Unsere Daten zeigen das nicht." (Some colleagues fear that without grades nobody will study any more. Our data do not show that.) The speaker names the idea in order to reject it. If you listen only for the keyword, you assign it to her.
- The other person's opinion, reported. "Herr Demir sagt ja, Druck gehöre dazu." (Mr Demir says pressure is part of it.) That is a statement about B, spoken by A. Whether B holds it is decided by what B himself says.
- The false "both". Both speak about the same topic, but only one person shares the statement. "Bestanden oder nicht bestanden, ja, aber Rückmeldungen für alle, das schaffen wir nicht." (Pass or fail, yes, but feedback for everyone, we cannot manage that.) This person agrees with one part of the proposal and rejects another. Whether a statement fits them depends on which of the two parts it covers.
- The false "neither". Agreement can be brief and easy to miss: "Damit kann ich leben" (I can live with that), "Das bestreite ich nicht" (I don't dispute that), "Insofern ja" (to that extent, yes). If you listen only for detailed reasons, you lose these pluses.
- "Sounds good, but …" "Das klingt zunächst überzeugend. Ich glaube trotzdem nicht, dass es so ist." (That sounds convincing at first. I still don't believe it is so.) With zunächst (at first), auf den ersten Blick (at first sight), klingt (sounds) or wirkt (seems), the person only grants how the idea looks, not that it is true. What decides is the sentence that follows: if they reject the content, you put a minus. Ask: does the person say that it is so, or only that it seems so?
- The moderator as a third voice. The moderator says: "Viele fordern, Klausuren ganz abzuschaffen." (Many demand that written exams be abolished altogether.) Both guests reject it. The statement was often said word for word and still belongs to neither.
- The statement that goes too far. The person says "manche verlieren die Motivation" (some lose their motivation), the statement reads "Ohne Noten lernt niemand mehr" (without grades nobody studies any more). The topic matches, the scope does not.
- Statements about the source. Not every statement is an opinion. "Stützt sich auf eine Befragung" (relies on a survey) or "beruft sich auf eigene Zählungen" (refers to counts of their own) asks where a person's knowledge comes from. Only someone who names exactly this kind of source as their own gets a plus. A: "Wir haben ein Semester lang gezählt, wie voll die Lesesäle sind." (For a whole semester we counted how full the reading rooms are.) B: "Auf solche Zählungen gebe ich wenig. Ich höre lieber, was mir Studierende in der Sprechstunde erzählen." (I don't set much store by such counts. I'd rather listen to what students tell me in my office hours.) The statement "beruft sich auf eigene Zählungen" belongs to A. B picks up the keyword only to play it down, and his own source is of a different kind: conversations. So with such statements, check the kind of source (survey, count, comparison of grades, conversations, personal experience) and who names it as their own.
A worked example, step by step
Practice text, entirely invented. People, universities and results are made up.
The statements as you read them before the video, with the keywords you note in the 45 seconds:
| Aussage | Stichwort | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Notendruck im ersten Jahr führt dazu, dass Studierende eher auswendig lernen als verstehen. | Druck → auswendig |
| 2 | Arbeitgeber achten bei Bewerbungen vor allem auf die Noten. | Arbeitgeber/Noten |
| 3 | Lehrende sollten im ersten Jahr ausführliche schriftliche Rückmeldungen geben. | Rückmeldungen |
| 4 | Ohne Noten verlieren manche Studierende die Motivation. | Motivation |
| 5 | Das erste Studienjahr sollte nur mit „bestanden“ oder „nicht bestanden“ bewertet werden. | bestanden/nicht |
| 6 | Bewertungen ohne Noten bedeuten mehr Arbeit für die Lehrenden. | Mehrarbeit |
A is Professor Albrecht, B is Mr Demir. The discussion as a transcript:
Moderatorin: Sollen im ersten Studienjahr keine Noten mehr vergeben werden? Bei mir sind Frau Professorin Albrecht, Hochschuldidaktikerin, und Herr Demir, Studiendekan einer technischen Fakultät. Frau Albrecht, Sie leiten einen Modellstudiengang ohne Noten.
Frau Albrecht: Ja, und ich bin überzeugt, dass Noten im ersten Jahr mehr schaden als nützen. Der Druck, vom ersten Semester an einen guten Schnitt zu haben, führt dazu, dass Studierende auswendig lernen, statt zu verstehen. Ich schlage deshalb vor, das erste Jahr nur mit „bestanden“ oder „nicht bestanden“ zu bewerten und stattdessen ausführliche schriftliche Rückmeldungen zu geben.
Moderatorin: Herr Demir?
Herr Demir: Bestanden oder nicht bestanden im ersten Jahr, damit kann ich gut leben, solange die Prüfungen selbst bleiben. Dass Druck nur schadet, glaube ich allerdings nicht; ein gewisses Maß brauchen Erstsemester. Und die ausführlichen Rückmeldungen: Wer soll die schreiben, bei vierhundert Erstsemestern in einem Fach? Das ist für die Lehrenden ein enormer Mehraufwand.
Frau Albrecht: Natürlich kostet das mehr Zeit, das bestreite ich gar nicht. Aber diese Zeit ist besser angelegt als in Wiederholungsprüfungen.
Moderatorin: Es heißt ja oft, Arbeitgeber schauen bei Bewerbungen vor allem auf die Noten.
Herr Demir: Das hört man oft. Die Unternehmen, mit denen wir zusammenarbeiten, fragen aber zuerst nach Praktika und Projekten.
Frau Albrecht: Einige Kollegen befürchten außerdem, dass ohne Noten niemand mehr lernt. Unsere Daten zeigen das nicht: Im zweiten Jahr schnitten unsere Studierenden genauso ab wie alle anderen.
Herr Demir: Im Durchschnitt mag das stimmen. Ich kenne aber genug Studierende, die ohne Note erst in der letzten Woche anfangen. Manche verlieren ohne Note schlicht die Motivation.
The grid after listening, and the answers:
| Keyword | A | B | Answer | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Druck → auswendig | + | − | A |
| 2 | Arbeitgeber/Noten | − | keiner | |
| 3 | Rückmeldungen | + | − | A |
| 4 | Motivation | − | + | B |
| 5 | bestanden/nicht | + | + | beide |
| 6 | Mehrarbeit | + | + | beide |
- 1 → A. Albrecht says it almost word for word. Demir contradicts only the claim "pressure only does harm", with the signal "glaube ich allerdings nicht" (I don't believe, though). He does not take up the idea of rote learning.
- 2 → keiner. The claim comes from the moderator, introduced with "Es heißt ja oft" (it is often said). Demir rejects it with "aber", Albrecht says nothing about it. The keyword "Noten" comes up constantly; what decides is that neither of the two holds "vor allem auf die Noten".
- 3 → A. Albrecht proposes it. Demir picks up the keyword, but as an objection: "Wer soll die schreiben?" (Who is supposed to write them?)
- 4 → B. This is the trap of the task. Albrecht speaks first about studying without grades, but she reports her colleagues' fear and refutes it. Demir holds the statement ("Manche verlieren ohne Note schlicht die Motivation"), and in exactly the scope of the statement: some, not all.
- 5 → beide. Albrecht proposes it, Demir agrees with "damit kann ich gut leben". His condition ("solange die Prüfungen selbst bleiben", as long as the exams themselves remain) changes nothing, because the statement says nothing about exams.
- 6 → beide. Demir says it as an objection. Albrecht concedes it: "Natürlich kostet das mehr Zeit, das bestreite ich gar nicht." A concession about the content is agreement, even if the person says "aber" afterwards: Albrecht does not dispute that it is so, she only judges the extra work differently.
Try it yourself
Your turn1 of 2
Moderator: 'Viele fordern, Klausuren ganz durch Hausarbeiten zu ersetzen.' A: 'Das ginge mir zu weit.' B: 'Mir auch, Klausuren haben ihren Platz.' Statement: 'Klausuren sollten vollständig durch Hausarbeiten ersetzt werden.' To whom do you assign it?
Your turn2 of 2
A: 'Herr B meint ja, Online-Vorlesungen seien genauso wirksam wie Präsenzvorlesungen. Das sehe ich nicht so.' B: 'Doch, das meine ich, und unsere Auswertung bestätigt es.' Statement: 'Online-Vorlesungen sind genauso wirksam wie Präsenzvorlesungen.' To whom do you assign it?
Key takeaways
- In the 45 seconds, reduce each statement to a keyword and mark the word that makes it narrow ("vor allem", "nur", "sollte").
- Note separately for A and B: holds it (+), rejects it (−), only mentions it (?). Only the plus counts.
- Ideas from the moderator and other people's reported opinions belong to no one until a person explicitly agrees.
- Brief agreements and concessions about the content ("damit kann ich leben", "das bestreite ich nicht") are a plus and often turn A into "both". A "klingt zunächst überzeugend, aber …" followed by disagreement is a minus.
- Both people on the same topic does not yet make "both": check that both hold the same statement with the same scope.
Was this article helpful?