Completing a Lecture Outline (Gliederungspunkte ergänzen)
The fifth task in the listening part (German: Hören) is an excerpt from a university lecture. Next to the lecture is its outline (German: Gliederung) with four points, and the content of each point is missing. You hear the lecture once and complete the four points in note form.
What is tested is whether you can follow a longer academic talk and pull out of many sentences the one statement that an outline point asks for.
The task
In the real exam the lecture is a video: you see the speaker and hear them. The trainer plays the sound only for now. Four things matter for your planning:
- Four outline points, four fields. Each point names what is asked for, such as "Grund für …" (reason for), "Nachteil von …" (drawback of), "Ziel des …" (aim of). You type your note into the field after it.
- The recording plays once. Before it you have 10 seconds to look at the outline, after it 3 minutes to check and write out your answers.
- Notes on paper are allowed. During the lecture you take notes on paper. If you can already type during the recording (the trainer allows it), you can also write directly in the field; otherwise you enter the answers in the 3 minutes afterwards.
- The order is predictable. An outline mirrors the structure of the lecture, so point 1 will probably come first and point 4 last.
The answers are scored by trained raters. In our assessment they check the content: a comprehensible note with the same meaning as the expected solution should count, even with a typo, as long as it stays unambiguous. A note that is vague or belongs to another point, on the other hand, earns nothing. The listening part as a whole is converted to a scale of 0 to 20 (TDN 3 = 5–9, TDN 4 = 10–15, TDN 5 = 16–20). The provider does not publish how many correct answers a level requires.
Step by step
- In the 10 seconds, read the cue words and their qualifiers. Mark, in your head or on paper, the noun that carries the question: Ursache, Nachteil, Ziel, Voraussetzung, Ergebnis. Mark as well what narrows the point down: for whom ("der Lehrkräfte"), when ("heute", "zuletzt"), under which condition ("ohne Training"), which one or how much of it ("insgesamt", "zweiter"). Later this qualifier decides which of several figures or statements is meant. The topic of the lecture is in the heading; the four cue words tell you what is wanted for each part of it.
- Predict the kind of answer for each point. A "cause" (Ursache) is a process or state that brings something about. An "aim" (Ziel) answers "what for". A "limit" (Grenze) names where something stops working. A "result" (Ergebnis) is often a figure or a comparison. If you know you are waiting for a "weil" or a "damit", you recognise the sentence when it comes.
- Follow the signposts. People lecturing at university announce the parts of their talk: "Zunächst möchte ich …", "Damit komme ich zum zweiten Punkt …", "Abschließend …". Each of these signals tells you which outline point is now running. Draw a line on your paper when a new part begins.
- Wait for the core sentence. Each part has one sentence that answers the question of the outline point; the rest is lead-in, examples and side remarks. The core sentence is often marked: "Entscheidend ist …", "Das eigentliche Problem …", "Der Hauptgrund …". What comes before it and starts with "Viele denken …" or "Man könnte meinen …" is usually not the answer.
- Take notes as keywords in nominal style. Nouns carry the information, articles and auxiliaries do not. "Der Boden unter den Straßen ist so verdichtet, dass das Wasser die Wurzeln nicht erreicht" becomes "Boden verdichtet, kein Wasser an Wurzeln". Abbreviations and arrows are fine on paper as long as you can read them later.
- Write out in the 3 minutes. Write each note so that a stranger understands it without the lecture, but stay in note form: no full sentence needed, no explanation, no example. Finally check each note against its outline point: does it answer exactly this cue word?
Typical traps
The example instead of the statement. Lecturers illustrate their points, and the example is often more concrete and easier to remember than the statement itself. Outline point "Risiko einer einseitigen Ernährung von Bienen", in the lecture: "Bienen, die nur Raps sammeln, werden anfälliger für Krankheiten. In einem Versuch starb ein Viertel der Völker." The note "ein Viertel der Völker starb" is evidence, not the risk. What is wanted is "anfälliger für Krankheiten".
The content of the neighbouring point. Between two parts there are transitions in which both topics occur. Outline point 2 "Nachteil der neuen Methode", outline point 3 "Kosten". In the lecture: "Die Methode ist also langsamer als die alte. Und damit sind wir bei den Kosten: Weil sie langsamer ist, braucht man mehr Personal." "Braucht mehr Personal" belongs to point 3, even though the sentence follows on from point 2. The signal "damit sind wir bei" draws the line.
The rejected view. Lecturers like to state first what is commonly believed and then contradict it. Outline point "Ursache für den Rückgang der Besucherzahlen", in the lecture: "Man hat lange die Eintrittspreise verantwortlich gemacht. Unsere Befragung zeigt aber, dass vor allem die schlechte Erreichbarkeit abschreckt." The note is "schlechte Erreichbarkeit", not "Eintrittspreise".
The side remark on the right topic. Sometimes the lecture gives a second piece of information on the right point that is not asked for: a consequence instead of an aim, a side effect instead of the purpose. Check whether your note answers the cue word, not just the topic.
The note that is too vague. "Probleme mit Wasser" hits the topic but not the statement. What is scored is whether the note renders the information precisely. A note must contain the distinction that matters: not "Wasser" but "kein Wasser an den Wurzeln".
Several figures in one part
When an outline point asks for a figure, a share, a duration or a result, the lecture rarely gives only one figure in that part. Next to it stand values that belong to the same topic but measure something else. Which one is meant is decided not by the topic but by the qualifier in the outline point. The same holds when a part names several reasons, steps or actions. The other values usually belong to one of these kinds:
- Another group. The point names a group ("der Fachleute", "bei den Jüngeren"), and the lecture also gives the value of a second group or a comparison group, often in the same sentence.
- Another point in time. If the point says "heute", "nach …" or "zuletzt", the earlier value or the starting value usually comes first. It sticks in your mind easily because the story begins with it.
- Another condition. "mit …", "ohne …", "bei Kälte": an experiment almost always compares at least two conditions, and each has its own figure.
- A part instead of the whole. "insgesamt" or "alle" in the point asks for the overall value, not the more striking value of a single group. Conversely, if the point names such a group, the average is wrong.
- Another step or rank. A worked calculation gives the rule, the starting amount and the result; "am Ende" or "Ergebnis" asks for the last figure. In a sequence of events, "zuletzt" means the last step and "erstes Anzeichen" the first. With reasons, "zweiter Grund" does not ask for the first one, which is often explained at greater length, and "am wichtigsten" does not automatically ask for the one that comes first.
- The counterpart. "Ein Viertel kam mit dem Auto, alle anderen zu Fuß": what is asked may be the remainder, which is never said as a figure, here three quarters.
- Another quantity. A part may give a height, a duration and a share. The point asks for exactly one of them, and its cue word ("Dauer", "Anteil", "wie viele") shows which.
While listening, write down each figure in such a part with a short label: who, when, under which condition. One word per figure is enough. You only have to decide in the 3 minutes: then you choose the figure whose label matches the qualifier in the outline point, and write only that one into the field.
An example. Outline point "Wartezeit mit Online-Termin". In the lecture: "Bis zum Frühjahr warteten die Studierenden im Sekretariat im Mittel vierzig Minuten. Seit man online einen Termin buchen kann, sind es noch zwölf. Wer ohne Termin kommt, wartet allerdings weiterhin eine halbe Stunde." Your paper says "früher 40 / mit Termin 12 / ohne 30". The field takes "zwölf Minuten": forty is the value before the change, and the half hour applies to another group.
Signposts in a lecture
These phrases show you where in the lecture you are. If you recognise them, you know which field is running even without any detail.
A worked example, step by step
Practice lecture, entirely invented. People, places and numbers are made up.
You see this outline:
Stadtbäume im Klimawandel
- Hauptursache der Schäden an Stadtbäumen: (1) ______
- Risiko der bisherigen Auswahl der Baumarten: (2) ______
- Eigentlicher Zweck der „Schwammstadt“: (3) ______
- Wo das Verfahren an seine Grenzen stößt: (4) ______
The 10 seconds. The cue words are "Hauptursache" (main cause), "Risiko" (risk), "Zweck" (purpose) and "wo … Grenzen" (where … limits). So you are looking for a cause (a state that does harm), a possible danger, a "what for" and a place or condition. "Haupt-" and "eigentlich" warn you in advance: there will also be a secondary cause and a secondary purpose.
The lecture as a transcript:
Dozentin: Guten Tag. Zunächst möchte ich klären, warum gerade Bäume in Innenstädten so stark leiden. Viele denken dabei an Abgase oder an Streusalz, und beides schadet tatsächlich. Den größten Schaden richtet aber etwas an, das man nicht sieht: Der Boden unter Straßen und Plätzen ist so verdichtet und versiegelt, dass Regenwasser kaum bis zu den Wurzeln gelangt. In heißen Sommern verdursten die Bäume dann buchstäblich.
Damit komme ich zum zweiten Punkt, der Auswahl der Arten. Jahrzehntelang hat man fast nur Linden, Ahorn und Kastanien gepflanzt. In der Stadt Lerchenau machen diese drei Gattungen bis heute siebzig Prozent des Bestands aus. Das Problem dabei ist nicht, dass diese Bäume schwach wären. Ein einziger Schädling, der sich auf eine Gattung spezialisiert, kann aber einen großen Teil aller Stadtbäume auf einmal befallen.
Ein Gegenmittel, über das gerade viel gesprochen wird, ist die sogenannte Schwammstadt. Unter Gehwegen und Parkplätzen legt man Schichten aus grobem Schotter an, die Regenwasser aufnehmen und speichern wie ein Schwamm. Das Wasser fließt dann nicht in die Kanalisation, sondern bleibt dort, wo die Wurzeln es erreichen. Dass nach Starkregen auch Überschwemmungen seltener werden, ist ein willkommener Nebeneffekt, aber nicht der eigentliche Zweck.
Abschließend noch ein Wort dazu, wo das Ganze an seine Grenzen stößt. Wenn eine Straße ohnehin neu gebaut wird, kostet der Speicher nur wenig mehr. Schwierig wird es unter Straßen, die schon bestehen: Dort liegen unter dem Gehweg Leitungen für Strom, Wasser und Internet, und Platz für den Schotter gibt es nur, wenn man alles neu verlegt.
This is how you would have recognised each point while listening:
- (1) verdichteter, versiegelter Boden: Regenwasser erreicht die Wurzeln nicht. The signal "Zunächst" opens point 1. "Viele denken dabei an …" introduces two causes that the lecturer downgrades with "aber": exhaust fumes and road salt do harm but are not the main cause. The core sentence is announced by "Den größten Schaden richtet … an"; it matches the cue word "Hauptursache" exactly.
- (2) ein Schädling kann viele Bäume auf einmal befallen. "Damit komme ich zum zweiten Punkt" draws the line. The seventy per cent in Lerchenau is evidence, not the risk; "Linden, Ahorn, Kastanien" describes the selection, not its danger. The note "wenige Arten" would be too vague, because the cue word asks what threatens as a result.
- (3) Regenwasser speichern, wo die Wurzeln es erreichen. Here the signal has no number, but "Ein Gegenmittel …" and the keyword "Schwammstadt" from the outline show the new part. "Weniger Überschwemmungen" is explicitly a "Nebeneffekt, aber nicht der eigentliche Zweck", and "eigentlich" was already in the outline point.
- (4) unter bestehenden Straßen: kein Platz wegen der Leitungen. "Abschließend" opens the last part and repeats the cue word "Grenzen". New construction is the counter-example, where the method works well. "Teuer" would be wrong: costs are mentioned only for new construction, and there they are low.
While listening, your paper would have held something like "Boden versiegelt → kein Wasser Wurzeln / 1 Schädling → viele Bäume / Wasser speichern f. Wurzeln / besteh. Str.: Leitungen, kein Platz". In the 3 minutes you write the four notes above from it.
Practise yourself
Your turn1 of 3
Outline point „Nachteil der Online-Sprechstunde“. You hear: „Die Online-Sprechstunde spart Wege, und an unserer Fakultät nutzen sie inzwischen zwei Drittel der Studierenden. Was dabei verloren geht, ist das zufällige Gespräch auf dem Flur, aus dem früher oft Abschlussarbeiten entstanden sind.“ Which note fits?
Your turn2 of 3
You are waiting for outline point 3 „Folgen für die Lehre“. Which sentence in the lecture shows that this point is now beginning?
Your turn3 of 3
Outline point „Häufigkeit der Fehler mit Checkliste“. You hear: „Ohne Checkliste vergaß das Pflegepersonal bei jeder fünften Übergabe einen wichtigen Punkt. Mit der Liste geschah das nur noch bei jeder zwanzigsten. Dafür dauerte eine Übergabe im Schnitt zwei Minuten länger.“ Which note fits?
Key takeaways
- In the 10 seconds, read the cue words of the four points and their qualifiers, and predict the kind of answer.
- Signposts such as "Zunächst", "Damit komme ich zum zweiten Punkt" and "Abschließend" tell you which field is running.
- Note the core sentence as keywords in nominal style, not the example and not the figure that supports it. If the point asks for a result, the figure itself is the statement.
- If a part gives several figures, note each with a label. Which one goes into the field is decided by the qualifier in the outline point: group, point in time, condition, part or whole, step.
- "Viele denken …", "Lange hieß es …" and "Nebeneffekt" announce what is not the answer.
- Content counts: in our assessment a typo does no harm, while a vague note or the content of the neighbouring point costs the point.
- Use the 3 minutes to write out each note clearly and check it against its cue word.
Was this article helpful?