Noting Positions (Positionen notieren)
In the second task of the listening part (German: Hören), two people discuss a question about university or society, usually led by a moderator. For each person you note what they demand and the argument with which they support that demand.
That makes four entries, all in note form. The task tests whether, in a conversation where both sides say a lot, you recognise the core of each position and separate it from everything else.
The task
The screen shows a small table for each of the two people with two fields: on the left "Forderung" (demand), on the right "Argument". That makes four fields. The recording plays once; there is no separate preparation time before listening. After listening you have 3 minutes to write and check your entries. Notes on paper are allowed.
The entries are marked by trained raters (German: Bewerterinnen und Bewerter). In our assessment, no particular wording is required: what counts is whether your note captures the content of the demand or the argument of the right person. If a person gives several arguments, one is enough, as long as it really supports their demand. The listening part as a whole is converted to a scale of 0 to 20 (TDN 3 = 5–9, TDN 4 = 10–15, TDN 5 = 16–20); how many correct answers a level requires is not published.
Step by step
| Phase | Time | What you do |
|---|---|---|
| While the instructions are read out | a few seconds | read the topic and the names, set up two blocks with two columns each on paper |
| While listening | one recording | jot down each person's demand and arguments in abbreviations |
| After listening | 3 min | about 2 min: fill in the four fields; about 1 min: check that each demand is a demand and each argument a reason for exactly that demand |
The three minutes afterwards are generous. This means you need not formulate anything while listening. Your paper notes only have to hold enough for you to turn them into four clear notes afterwards.
- Set up the paper before the discussion starts. Two blocks, one per person, with the name or an initial above it. In each block two columns: "F" for the demand (Forderung) on the left, "A" for arguments on the right. Every note then lands where it belongs, and you do not have to sort later.
- Remember who is who. The moderator usually introduces the people by name and role ("Frau Dr. Hollweg, Ernährungswissenschaftlerin", a nutrition scientist). The role helps with the assignment: it tells you which voice belongs to which block. But do not infer the demand or the argument from it. In this task people often argue differently from what their role would lead you to expect (see "Typical traps").
- Recognise the demand by its form. A demand (German: Forderung) says what should happen. It is often in Konjunktiv II or uses a modal verb: "sollte", "müsste", "wir sollten", "man müsste endlich" (should, ought to, we should, one finally ought to). Other markers are "ich bin dafür, dass" (I am in favour of), "ich fordere" (I demand), "ich plädiere für" (I argue for), "mein Vorschlag ist" (my proposal is), "es braucht" (what is needed is), "ich halte es für richtig, dass" (I think it right that). A rejection ("ich bin gegen ein Verbot", I am against a ban) is not yet a complete demand: keep listening until the person says what should happen instead.
- Recognise the argument by its function. An argument says why the demand is right. Markers are "weil", "denn", "da" (because, since), "schließlich" (after all), "das zeigt" (this shows), "wir haben festgestellt" (we have found), "die Zahlen belegen" (the figures prove), "das sieht man daran, dass" (you can see this from the fact that), "sonst" (otherwise). Often it is a figure, a trial or an experience. The argument may come before the demand: then "deshalb" or "daher" (therefore) leads from it to the demand.
- Separate the speaker's own argument from a concession. Sentences like "das bestreite ich gar nicht" (I don't dispute that at all), "da hat Frau X recht" (Ms X is right there) or "natürlich stimmt es, dass" (of course it is true that) grant a point to the other side. That is not an argument for the speaker's own demand. Their own argument usually follows, introduced by "aber", "nur", "trotzdem" (but, only, nevertheless).
- Note in abbreviations, not in sentences. Numbers as digits, arrows for consequences (↑, ↓, →), abbreviations for recurring words. Two to four words per note are enough.
- Then write in note style. For the fields, turn your abbreviations into notes that a stranger can understand: a noun or an infinitive phrase for the demand ("an zwei Tagen pro Woche nur vegetarisch kochen"), a brief reason for the argument ("70 % der Emissionen durch Fleisch"). No complete sentence is needed, but the person who reads your note must understand the point without the recording.
From sentence to note
In note style, whatever carries no information disappears: the subject, polite formulas, softeners like "meiner Meinung nach" (in my opinion). Verbs become infinitives at the end or nouns. What changes the content stays: numbers, negations, restrictions like "nur" (only) or "nicht in allen" (not in all).
Your turn1 of 3
Typical traps
- The expected argument. The topic and the role suggest a position: from a teacher you expect an argument about pupils, from a business owner one about costs, and with "Pflicht" (obligation) in the topic you think of the strictest form. The people in this task often say something else, sometimes pointing out explicitly that the obvious reason is not the decisive one ("Am Geld liegt es gar nicht", it is not about the money at all). Note what the person says, not what would fit them. Check any note you could have written without the recording with special care in the 3 minutes: did you really hear this reason?
- The other side's argument. A person reports what the opposing side says in order to refute it: "Man hört oft, Ruhezonen in der Bibliothek würden kaum genutzt. Das halte ich für übertrieben." (You often hear that quiet zones in the library are hardly used. I think that is exaggerated.) That is not their argument. For every reason, check whether the person holds it or merely reports it.
- The concession. "Dass das teuer ist, bestreite ich nicht." (I don't dispute that it is expensive.) The person concedes something. A concession does not support the speaker's own demand, so it cannot go into the "Argument" field.
- A bare rejection as the demand. "Ich bin gegen ein Verbot" says what should not happen. If the person later says "wir sollten stattdessen …" (we should instead …), that part goes into the field, because only that part is the demand.
- The moderator's position. The moderator sums up, provokes or proposes something: "Wäre ein Kompromiss nicht eine Lösung?" (Wouldn't a compromise be a solution?) You note only what one of the two people demands or argues.
- Swapped fields. When the reason stands in the same sentence as the demand, it easily slips into the demand field too: "Wir sollten das Angebot ausbauen, denn die Nachfrage ist stark gestiegen." (We should expand the offer, because demand has risen sharply.) The expansion is the demand, the rising demand is the argument.
- The demand with its restriction missing. "Ruhezonen nur in der Prüfungsphase" (quiet zones only during the exam period) is a different demand from "Ruhezonen". If the person narrows down their demand, the limit belongs in the note.
- The add-on in reply to an objection. Towards the end, a person often answers an objection from the other side and adjusts their proposal. One person demands writing courses for all first-year students. The other objects: "Das kostet aber Personal." (But that takes staff.) The reply: "Stimmt, deshalb sollten ältere Studierende die Kurse als Tutoren leiten." (True, which is why older students should run the courses as tutors.) The "Forderung" field still takes "Schreibkurse für alle Erstsemester": the sentence carries every marker of a demand ("sollten", "deshalb"), but it only answers the objection. Likewise, an offer at the end ("Dann bieten wir die Kurse eben online an", then we will simply offer the courses online) is a reaction, not the demand. The demand is what the person argues for on their own initiative, usually early and with a reason. A limit they set from the start is part of the demand; a change the objection forces on them is not. With every late "sollte", ask: would the person have said this without the objection?
An example of the first trap. Topic: "Kostenloser Bus für Menschen über 70?" (free buses for people over 70?). A GP, Frau Lang, says: "Sie erwarten von mir jetzt sicher etwas über Bewegung und Gesundheit. Mich treibt etwas anderes um: Viele meiner älteren Patienten fahren noch Auto, obwohl sie schlecht sehen, weil ihnen der Bus zu teuer ist." (You surely expect me to talk about exercise and health now. What concerns me is something else: many of my older patients still drive although their eyesight is poor, because the bus is too expensive for them.) The "Argument" field takes "Ältere sehen schlecht, fahren Auto, Bus zu teuer", not "gut für die Gesundheit": that is exactly what she did not say.
A worked example, step by step
Practice text, entirely invented. People, universities, studies and figures are made up.
The fields on the screen: Frau Hollweg, Forderung / Argument; Herr Szabo, Forderung / Argument. The recording as a transcript:
Moderator: Soll die Mensa an bestimmten Tagen nur noch vegetarisch kochen? Darüber diskutieren Frau Dr. Hollweg, Ernährungswissenschaftlerin, und Herr Szabo, Geschäftsführer eines Studierendenwerks. Frau Hollweg?
Frau Hollweg: Ich bin dafür, dass die Mensen an zwei Tagen pro Woche ausschließlich vegetarische Gerichte anbieten. Nicht aus Prinzip, sondern weil die Zahlen eindeutig sind: Nach unserer Auswertung gehen gut siebzig Prozent der Treibhausgase, die eine Mensa mit ihren Gerichten verursacht, auf Fleisch zurück, obwohl Fleischgerichte nur ein Drittel der verkauften Essen ausmachen.
Moderator: Herr Szabo, das Studierendenwerk ist skeptisch.
Herr Szabo: Skeptisch gegenüber einem Verbot, ja. Dass Fleisch das Klima stärker belastet, bestreite ich gar nicht. Aber wir haben fleischfreie Tage an einer Partnerhochschule ein Semester lang ausprobiert, und an diesen Tagen kamen rund ein Viertel weniger Gäste. Die sind nicht verschwunden, die haben am Imbiss gegenüber gegessen, und zwar Currywurst. Für das Klima ist damit nichts gewonnen. Ich meine deshalb, wir sollten bei der Wahlfreiheit bleiben, die vegetarischen Gerichte aber deutlich günstiger machen als die mit Fleisch.
Moderator: Wäre nicht ein fleischfreier Tag ein Kompromiss?
Frau Hollweg: Über den Preis kann man reden, aber ein Tag allein reicht nicht.
This is what the paper notes looked like while listening:
| Hollweg F | Hollweg A | Szabo F | Szabo A |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Tg/Wo nur veg. | 70 % THG durch Fleisch, nur 1/3 der Essen | Versuch: 1/4 weniger Gäste → Imbiss, Wurst |
The four fields and how you would have recognised each one while listening:
- Hollweg, demand: an zwei Tagen pro Woche nur vegetarische Gerichte. The marker "Ich bin dafür, dass" is in the very first sentence. The restriction "zwei Tage pro Woche" (two days a week) is part of it; "nur vegetarisch" alone would be a different demand.
- Hollweg, argument: 70 % der Treibhausgase der Mensa durch Fleisch, obwohl nur 1/3 der Essen. The marker "weil die Zahlen eindeutig sind" (because the figures are clear) announces the reason; the figure follows the colon. "Nicht aus Prinzip" (not on principle) is no argument, only a disclaimer.
- Szabo, demand: Wahlfreiheit behalten, vegetarische Gerichte günstiger machen. "Skeptisch gegenüber einem Verbot" (sceptical about a ban) is at first only a rejection; that is why it is crossed out in the notes. The actual demand comes at the end with "deshalb, wir sollten". If you stop at the first sentence, you note only half.
- Szabo, argument: fleischfreie Tage im Versuch: 1/4 weniger Gäste, die aßen stattdessen Fleisch am Imbiss. The "aber" after the concession introduces his own argument. "Dass Fleisch das Klima stärker belastet" (that meat burdens the climate more) is Hollweg's point, which Szabo merely concedes. From a managing director you might have expected an argument about costs; his argument, however, is that the meat is simply eaten elsewhere.
The moderator's question about a compromise and Hollweg's last sentence change nothing in the four fields: the compromise comes from the moderator, and Hollweg rejects it.
Try it yourself
Your turn2 of 3
Which sentence contains the speaker's demand?
Your turn3 of 3
A speaker says: 'Man hört oft, Lerngruppen seien Zeitverschwendung. Das sehe ich anders. Bei uns bestehen Studierende aus Lerngruppen die Klausur deutlich häufiger, und deshalb sollte jede Erstsemestergruppe eine feste Lerngruppe bekommen.' Which note belongs in his 'Argument' field?
Key takeaways
- Before listening, set up two blocks with two columns each: demand on the left, argument on the right.
- You recognise demands by "sollte", "müsste", "ich bin dafür, dass", "ich fordere"; arguments by "weil", "denn", "schließlich", "das zeigt" and by figures and trials.
- A rejection is only half a demand. Keep listening until the person says what should happen instead.
- A person's role tells you who is speaking, not what they say. Note the argument that is made, not the one that fits the role.
- Concessions, reported counter-opinions and the moderator's proposals belong in no field.
- While listening, note in abbreviations, and in the 3 minutes afterwards write understandable notes, with all numbers and restrictions.
Was this article helpful?