Simple interest and a loan with two payments: in how many years and at what rate

24 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 2.2 Laufzeiten

Not every account pays interest on interest. With some bonds and short loans the bank pays the same share of the original amount every year. Then the question is how much sooner an ordinary deposit with compound interest reaches the same amount. The second task is the reverse. In it the payments and the outcome (a balance or the loan amount) are known, and you look for the rate.

Two banks each offer 3.5 % a year on 8000 €.

  • Bank A pays every year 3.5 % of the original 8000 €, that is 8000⋅0.035=280 €. In 20 years it adds 20⋅280=5600 €, and the account holds 13600 €.
  • Bank B adds the interest to the account, and the next year interest is paid on it too.

After how many full years will bank B's account also hold at least 13600 €?

It may seem that bank B needs 20 years as well: 5600/280=20. It does not: bank B's interest grows every year because interest earns interest, so it reaches the same amount sooner.

Let us count year by year. At bank B the account holds 8000⋅1.035t € after t years:

YearsBank A, €Bank B, €
1512200.0013402.79
1612480.0013871.89

After 15 years bank B is still short of 13600 €, after 16 years it is past it. Answer: 16 full years, 4 years sooner than bank A. The way bank A pays, the same share of the starting amount every year, is called simple interest.

The basics

In the introduction the term for bank B was found by trying year after year in the table of the two banks. The logarithm gets there faster. When the rate is unknown instead, a root brings it out. Both are covered in detail in the article “Term and interest rate: when the unknown is in the exponent”. Three things from it are needed here. In them q=1+r is the annual factor and r the rate as a decimal:

  • the term from two amounts: if K0 grows to Kt, then t=ln⁡(Kt/K0)ln⁡q; ln is the natural logarithm key on the calculator. For example, 1800 € at 4 % reach 2500 € in t=ln⁡(2500/1800)/ln⁡1.04=8.38 years (section on the term);
  • the rate from one amount: q=(Kt/K0)1/t, the t-th root. For example, if an amount grew by the factor 1.1025 in 2 years, then q=1.10251/2=1.05, a rate of 5 % (section on the root);
  • the value today: a payment R in t years is worth R/qt today. For example, 1000 € in 2 years at 5 % are worth 1000/1.052=907.03 € today (present value).

The answer to the question from the start:

  1. Bank B must turn 8000 € into 13600 €: 1.035t=13600/8000=1.7.
  2. Term t=ln⁡1.7/ln⁡1.035=0.5306/0.03440=15.42 years.
  3. Interest arrives at the end of the year. After 15 years the account holds 8000⋅1.03515=13402.79 €, still too little; after 16 years 13871.89 €. Bank B needs 16 years, four fewer than bank A.

In how many years simple and compound interest give the same amount

Banks A and B were compared at the same rate. Only the term under compound interest was unknown there. The exam puts the two kinds side by side in the same way, but it may ask for the term of either one:

Exam-style task

Bei einfacher Verzinsung mit 2.5 % pro Jahr wächst ein Sparbetrag in 18 Jahren auf einen bestimmten Wert. Die Hausbank bietet für dasselbe Geld 2.5 % pro Jahr mit Zinseszins. Nach wie vielen Jahren ist beim Zinseszins derselbe Wert erreicht? Runden Sie auf eine Nachkommastelle.

  1. a)20.1
  2. b)27.0
  3. c)18.0
  4. d)22.4
  5. e)15.0

In this task the same amount is invested twice at the same rate, once with simple interest and once with compound interest.

Signal: the same task mentions both “simple interest” and “compound interest”. The rate is the same, the term of one kind is given, and the term of the other is asked.

Say 1000 € earn 5 %, and each year the bank adds 50 €, always 5 % of the original 1000 €. After 3 years the account holds 1000+3⋅50=1150 €. With compound interest it would be 1000⋅1.053=1157.63 €: there the interest of the second and third year is also paid on the earlier interest.

Interest like this is called simple interest (“einfache Verzinsung”): each year the same share r of the initial amount is added. On the sheet it reads:

Kt=K0(1+t⋅r)

Here:

  • K0 is the initial amount;
  • t the number of years;
  • r the annual rate as a decimal;
  • t⋅r all the interest of the t years together.

The comparison with compound interest is in “Compound interest year by year”. We write the term of simple interest with the letter s so that it is not confused with the compound interest term t.

In s years simple interest multiplies the amount by 1+s⋅r, compound interest in t years by qt. The initial amount is the same for both kinds, so equal amounts mean equal factors, and K0 cancels:

qt=1+s⋅r

From here on everything depends on which term is unknown. The compound term t sits in the exponent, and the logarithm gets it out, as in the section “After how many years an amount reaches a target”. The simple term s is a factor, and division gets it out.

simple-interest factor: 1.45

By what factor a deposit at 2.5 % grows: simple and compound interest051015200.511.52yearsfactors = 18 yearssimple
Step 1 of 4Simple interest factor

The simple interest term is given: 18 years at 2.5 %. The factor is 1+18⋅0.025=1.45.

Compound interest reached 1.45 in 15.0 years, simple interest in 18. For terms longer than a year compound interest needs less time: from the second year on, interest is also earned on interest. For terms shorter than a year it is the other way round: in half a year at 4 % simple interest gives 1+0.5⋅0.04=1.02, compound interest 1.040.5=1.04=1.0198. The exponent 0.5=1/2 is the square root, as in the section “Interest rate from one amount”; on the calculator 1.04, the xy key, then 0.5.

A deposit stays for 10 years at 4.5 % compound interest.

In how many years would simple interest at the same rate give the same amount?

The same 10 years will not do: simple interest grows more slowly, so the term comes out different.

  1. Compound interest factor: 1.04510=1.5530.
  2. Simple interest must give the same: 1+0.045⋅s=1.5530.
  3. Subtract 1: 0.045⋅s=0.5530.
  4. s is not in the exponent, so no logarithm is needed. Divide by 0.045: s=0.5530/0.045=12.29 years.

A bond pays 4 % simple interest for 30 years.

In how many years would compound interest at the same rate give the same factor?

The same 30 years are not needed: compound interest grows faster, so the term is shorter.

  1. Simple interest factor: 1+30⋅0.04=2.2.
  2. Compound interest must give the same: 1.04t=2.2.
  3. Decide whether you need the logarithm or division is enough, and work out t to two decimal places.

Your turn2 of 3

An investor puts money away for 12 years at 5 % compound interest. His neighbour invests the same amount at 5 % simple interest. After how many years will she have the same capital? Round to one decimal place.

Traps.

  • Answering with the same term. In the task at the start of the section (18 years at 2.5 %) that is 18.0, option c. The rate is the same, and it seems the term should be too. But compound interest also earns interest on interest and reaches 1.45 sooner, in 15.0 years. For terms longer than a year the compound interest answer is always shorter than the simple interest one.
  • Mixing up which kind of interest is given. In the same task this gives 22.4, option d: the compound factor 1.02518=1.5597, then the simple term 0.5597/0.025=22.4. That is the answer to the reverse task. Underline in the task which kind the number of years belongs to. Check: if the compound term came out longer than the simple term, the kinds are mixed up.
  • Taking the logarithm of simple interest. In example 2, ln⁡1.5530/0.045=9.78 instead of 12.29. The hand does what it did for the compound term, even though s is not in the exponent.

On the sheet: Kt=K0(1+t⋅r) and Kt=K0(1+r)t. Setting their factors equal is up to you: qt=1+s⋅r.

The rate from two payments: loan or deposit

In the task on simple and compound interest the rate was given and the term was wanted. Here it is the other way round: two deposits, their dates and the final balance are known, and the rate is not:

Exam-style task

Ein Installateur legt für einen neuen Lieferwagen heute 4600 GE zurück und nach 2 Jahren weitere 5500 GE auf dasselbe Konto. Als er nach 4 Jahren ab heute den Wagen kauft, beträgt der Kontostand 11107 GE. Wie hoch war der Jahreszinssatz (in %)? Runden Sie auf eine Nachkommastelle.

  1. a)3.3
  2. b)5.8
  3. c)2.5
  4. d)10.0
  5. e)6.7

A plumber puts 4600 GE (money units, as the task writes it) into an account today, another 5500 GE after 2 years, and after 4 years the account holds 11107 GE.

Signal: two amounts and a date at equal intervals. It comes in two forms:

  • deposits today and after 2 years, the balance after 4 years;
  • a loan today, two payments after 2 and after 4 years (or after 3 and after 6 years).

The question asks for the “yearly interest rate”, and interest is paid once a year. The task writes the rate as r, as on the sheet.

Where the equation comes from and why it is quadratic:

  1. The deposits, moved to the day of the balance, add up to the balance.
  2. A deposit Z grows in t years to Z⋅qt, where Z is the amount paid in (Present value and replacement payment).
  3. The unknown q sits in two powers at once: q4 for the first deposit and q2 for the second.
  4. The larger power is the square of the smaller: q4=(q2)2.
  5. If you call q2 by one letter, the equation becomes quadratic. A quadratic equation is solved by the formula for its roots on the sheet.

both deposits, moved to year 4, give the balance

Deposits of 4600 GE today and 5500 GE after 2 years, balance of 11107 GE after 4 years012344600 GEdeposit5500 GE11107 GEbalanceafter 4 yearsyears
Step 1 of 5Set up the equation

The balance after 4 years is 11107 GE. The first deposit, 4600 GE, stays all 4 years, so multiply it by q4; the second, 5500 GE, stays 2 years, so by q2: 4600 q4+5500 q2=11107.

For deposits in general form: Z1u2+Z2u=K, where Z1 and Z2 are the deposits today and after t years, K the balance after 2t years, u=qt. For a loan L with two equal payments R after t and after 2t years, again u=qt, the growth over the first t years:

L=Ru+Ru2⟹L⋅u2−R⋅u−R=0,
u=qt=R+R2+4⋅L⋅R2⋅L

Then the annual factor. From qt=u, the t-th root gives q=u1/t, as in the section “Interest rate from one amount”.

  • For t=2 this is the square root: q=u.
  • For t=3 the cube root. On the calculator this is the xy key: enter u, press xy, enter (1÷3). For example, if the amount grew by the factor 1.157625 in 3 years, then 1.1576251/3=1.05.

A loan of 4000 € is repaid with two payments of 2300 € each after 2 and after 4 years, with interest paid once a year.

Find the annual rate to one decimal place.

Adding the two payments and comparing with the loan does not work: they lie in different years and are discounted differently.

  1. The loan equals both payments moved to today: 4000=2300q2+2300q4.
  2. u=q2: 4000u2−2300u−2300=0.
  3. Under the root: 23002+4⋅4000⋅2300=5290000+36800000=42090000, and the root is 6487.68.
  4. u=2300+6487.688000=8787.688000=1.0985.
  5. Per year: q=1.0985=1.0481, a rate of 4.8 %.
  6. Check: 2300/1.0985+2300/1.09852≈4000.

A loan of 2000 € is repaid with two payments of 1200 € each after 2 and after 4 years, with interest paid once a year.

What is the annual rate?

Adding the two payments and comparing with the loan does not work: they lie in different years and are discounted differently.

  1. u=q2: 2000u2−1200u−1200=0.
  2. u=1200+12002+4⋅2000⋅12004000=1200+3322.654000=1.1307.
  3. Find the annual factor q and the rate.

Your turn3 of 3

A loan of 1800 € is repaid with two payments of 1100 € each after 3 and after 6 years, with interest paid once a year. What is the annual rate in %, rounded to one decimal place?

Traps (numbers from the task at the start of the section: deposits of 4600 and 5500, balance 11107):

  • Dividing the balance by the sum of the deposits. 11107/10100−1=10.0 %, option d. It seems the growth is the interest. But that is the growth over the whole term, not per year, and the second deposit stayed only 2 years.
  • Spreading the growth evenly over the years. 10.0 %/4=2.5 %, option c. This ignores interest on interest and treats the second deposit as if it had stayed all 4 years.
  • Compounding with simple interest. 4600⋅(1+4r)+5500⋅(1+2r)=11107 gives r=1007/29400=3.4 %. The answer is close to the right one, and that is what makes it dangerous. But over several years compound interest applies.
  • Stopping at u. u−1=6.7 %, option e, is the growth over 2 years. The annual factor is q=u.

On the sheet: Kt=K0(1+r)t and the formula for the roots of a quadratic equation. Its letters a, b, c stand for the coefficients of the equation: here a=4600, b=5500, c=−11107, in loan tasks a=L, b=−R, c=−R. In the exam you can also go backwards: put the answer options in as q, compound both deposits and pick the one that gives the balance.

Formula sheet and what to memorise

The formulas for both tasks in this article are on the sheet. The equations that tie them together are not, and you set those up yourself.

On the formula sheet (r is the annual rate, interest is paid once a year, t the term; we also write q=1+r):

  • compound interest Kt=K0(1+r)t: both tasks;
  • simple interest Kt=K0(1+t⋅r): simple against compound, where we call the simple interest term s;
  • the formula for the roots of a quadratic equation: rate from two payments.

Memorise yourself:

  • simple against compound: qt=1+s⋅r; the compound term with ln, the simple term by division; for terms longer than a year compound interest needs fewer years;
  • two equal payments: u=qt from L⋅u2−R⋅u−R=0, then q=u1/t; for deposits Z1u2+Z2u−K=0.

In short

  • Term with simple and compound interest

    The task has both simple and compound interest at one rate; the term of one kind is given, the other is asked. The initial amount cancels, and you compare the factors.
    qt=1+s⋅r

    Trap: answering with the same term or mixing up which kind the term belongs to; taking the logarithm of simple interest.

  • Interest rate from two equal payments

    A loan L is repaid with two equal payments R after t and 2t years. The growth up to the first payment, u=qt, comes from a quadratic equation. Or deposits today and after t years give the balance after 2t years: Z1u2+Z2u=K.
    u=qt=R+R2+4⋅L⋅R2⋅L

    Trap: dividing the sum of the payments by the loan, or stopping at u, which is the growth over t years.

Tasks on simple interest and on the rate from two payments are in the same “Compound interest” trainer. What changes when interest is paid monthly or continuously is shown in the article “How often interest is paid: nominal, effective and continuous rate”.

Now practise it

Simple interest and a loan with two payments: in how many years and at what rate

Trainer · Elementary financial mathematics

Practise
Next: How often interest is paid: why 9 % monthly beats 9.3 % once a year
0/3

Was this article helpful?