How often interest is paid: why 9 % monthly beats 9.3 % once a year

25 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 2.5 Unterjährige Verzinsung2.6.2 Kontinuierliche Verzinsung

What does a bank mean by “9 % a year” if it credits the interest every month? And what happens to the capital if interest is credited even more often, continuously?

A bank states an annual rate in the contract, but often credits interest not once a year but every month or quarter. Then the money grows a little more in a year than the number in the contract promises. Anyone who compares savings accounts, loans or bonds with different payment frequencies runs into this.

100 € go in for one year, with two offers to choose from:

  • bank A: 9 % a year, interest credited every month;
  • bank B: 9.3 % a year, interest credited once, at the end of the year.

Which bank will have more in the account after a year?

Choosing bank B just because 9.3 is bigger than 9 would be hasty: the interest is credited with different frequency, so the numbers cannot be compared directly.

Let us work out both accounts after one year. At bank A the hundred euros grow 1+0.09/12=1.0075 times every month, which after 12 months gives 100⋅1.007512≈109.38 €. At bank B it is exactly 109.30 €. Bank A wins by 8 cents.

The 9 % in the contract is called the nominal rate. The rate that would give the same growth with one crediting at the end of the year is called the effective rate: for bank A it is about 9.38 %.

Interest on interest within the year

Bank B pays interest once a year. In a year the amount is multiplied by q=1+r, where r is the annual rate as a decimal, here q=1.093 (Compound interest: what money is worth today and in a few years). After a year bank B holds:

100⋅1.093=109.30 €

Bank A splits the 9 % over 12 months. Each month it credits 9 %/12=0.75 %, that is, it multiplies the amount by 1.0075:

  • at the end of January: 100⋅1.0075=100.75 €;
  • at the end of February: 100.75⋅1.0075=101.51 €.

In February the interest is already paid on 100.75 €, not on 100. The 0.75 € from January earned interest of its own. The same happens every month: the amount is multiplied by 1.0075 twelve times in a row.

100⋅1.007512=109.38 €

The answer to the question: bank A gives 109.38 €, bank B only 109.30 €. Bank A's rate in the contract is lower, yet after a year there is more money.

What happens if interest is paid even more often? Take the same 100 € and the same 9 % a year, split into k interest payments a year. Each payment brings 9 %/k, and there are k of them, so after a year the account holds 100⋅(1+0.09k)k:

Interest payments per year kAfter a year, €
1109.00
2109.20
4109.31
12109.38
365109.42

The more often interest is paid, the more money. But each further step adds less than the one before, and the amount runs up against a limit of about 109.42 €.

Nominal and effective rate: the number in the contract and the growth over a year

In the scene, bank A has two different numbers. The number in the contract, 9 %, is called the nominal rate (“nomineller Zinssatz”). On the sheet its letter is c. The growth over a year, 9.38 %, is called the effective rate (“effektiver Zinssatz”). On the sheet its letter is r. The number of interest payments per year is k on the sheet.

Offers can only be compared by the effective rate. In the scene, bank B with a nominal 9.3 % lost to bank A with a nominal 9 %.

Bank A's calculation in general form:

  1. Each interest payment brings the nominal rate divided by k: c/k. In the scene 0.09/12=0.0075.
  2. There are k such payments in a year, and each multiplies the amount by 1+c/k. In the scene 1.007512=1.0938.
  3. The annual factor is 1+r by definition.
1+r=(1+ck)k

With k=1 you get r=c: if interest is paid once a year, both rates are the same. That is why tasks with interest once a year need only one rate r.

Over several years you count in periods. In t years with k interest payments a year, t⋅k periods pass, so Kt=K0(1+ck)t⋅k, where K0 is the amount today and c the nominal rate as a decimal. This is also a line on the sheet. For example, bank A from the scene over 2 years:

  1. Periods: t⋅k=2⋅12=24 months.
  2. Factor per month: 1+0.0912=1.0075.
  3. After 2 years: K2=100⋅1.007524=119.64 €.

Continuous compounding and the number e

In the section “Interest on interest within the year” the amount ran up against 109.42 € as interest was paid more and more often. Paying interest “infinitely often”, at every instant, is called continuous compounding (“stetige Verzinsung”). Let us find what the limit is.

First the simplest case, a rate of 100 %. Then the factor after a year is (1+1k)k:

k(1+1k)k
12
22.25
122.613
3652.715
10000002.718

The numbers grow more and more slowly and run up against 2.71828… This number is called e, Euler's number (“eulersche Zahl”). On the calculator the key ex gives it: e1=2.71828.

Now the rate 9 %. We reduce it to the case of 100 %: the bracket should hold 1+1number.

  1. Let m=k/0.09. Then 0.09k=1m and k=0.09⋅m. With k=12 this is m=133.3.
  2. Put both substitutions into (1+0.09k)k:
(1+0.09k)k=(1+1m)0.09⋅m
  1. Apply the rule for a power of a power, (ab)n=ab⋅n for a number a and exponents b, n (see “Powers: four rules with numbers”). Read it from right to left with b=m and n=0.09:
(1+1m)m⋅0.09=((1+1m)m)0.09

As k grows, m grows too, and the inner bracket approaches e. So the limit is e0.09. Check it on the calculator: 100⋅e0.09=109.42, exactly the limit that the table for 100 € with different numbers of compoundings ran up against. For any rate c the reasoning is the same, and the limit is ec.

Over t years you take the annual factor ec t times: (ec)t=ec⋅t. Hence

Kt=K0⋅ec⋅t

Here K0 is the capital today, Kt the capital after t years, c the rate as a decimal, t the number of years, and c⋅t their product in the exponent.

On the sheet this is K(t)=K(0)ect. The letter c here is the same as for the nominal rate, and that is no accident: as k grows without end, the nominal rate c becomes the continuous rate.

Back to an earlier day you move by dividing by ec⋅t:

  • dividing by ec⋅t means multiplying by e−c⋅t;
  • a minus in the exponent means dividing: e−c⋅t=1/ec⋅t (rule a−t=1/at for any positive number a, see “Powers: four rules with numbers”);
  • in numbers: e−0.3=1/e0.3=1/1.3499=0.7408.

If the term or the rate is unknown, it sits in the exponent. The logarithm from the article “Term and interest rate: when the unknown is in the exponent” gets it out: the exponent comes out of the logarithm as a factor, ln⁡(qt)=t⋅ln⁡q. With base e it is the same: ln⁡(ec⋅t)=c⋅t⋅ln⁡e. The calculator gives ln⁡e=1, so

ln⁡(ec⋅t)=c⋅t

Only ln works here. The log key gives log⁡e=0.4343, and with it log⁡(ec⋅t)=c⋅t⋅0.4343, not c⋅t.

The same way you convert the effective rate into the continuous one. Both rates must give the same growth over a year:

  1. Over a year the factor is ec at the continuous rate c and 1+r at the effective rate r.
  2. The growth is the same: ec=1+r.
  3. Take ln of both sides: c=ln⁡(1+r).

For example, an effective 5 % corresponds to the continuous rate c=ln⁡1.05=4.88 %. The other way round: a continuous 5 % gives e0.05−1=5.13 % over a year.

A check in numbers: e0.04879=1.0500, the same yearly factor as an effective 5 %. So the growth over many years matches too: over 10 years 100⋅e0.04879⋅10=162.89 € and 100⋅1.0510=162.89 €.

Converting the rate when interest is paid several times a year

Above, the nominal and effective rates were compared on 100 € in a bank. In the exam the same pair of rates turns up in a loan:

Exam-style task

Ein Kredit soll effektiv 6.5% pro Jahr kosten. Die Bank verrechnet die Zinsen monatlich mit dem anteiligen Satz (nomineller Jahreszinssatz geteilt durch 12).

Welchen nominellen Jahreszinssatz muss die Bank ansetzen?

  1. a)6.20
  2. b)6.50
  3. c)5.91
  4. d)6.86
  5. e)6.31

A bank wants a loan to cost 6.5 % a year, but it charges interest every month.

How to recognise the task: interest is paid several times a year (“monthly”, “quarterly”, “semi-annually”), and the task has two annual rates: one “effective”, the other “nominal”. One is given, the other is asked for.

In the scene we went forwards: from the nominal rate to the effective one, with the formula from the sheet. In this task it is the other way round: the effective rate is given and the nominal one is needed. Then you go backwards. The annual factor 1+r is the product of k equal factors per period. So the factor per period is the k-th root of 1+r. The k-th root of x is written x1/k; on the calculator that is x ^ (1 ÷ k).

effective 6.5 %: annual factor 1.065

Twelve equal monthly steps that together turn 100 € into exactly 106.50 €024681010010210410612106.5monthbalance, €100 € → 106.50 € in a year
Step 1 of 4Understand what is given

“6.5 % a year effectively” means: in a year 100 € become 106.50 €, however often interest is paid. The annual factor is 1+r=1.065. The nominal rate c is asked for.

The same steps in general form; this formula is not on the sheet:

c=k⋅((1+r)1/k−1)

Picture this: a bond pays a nominal 8 % a year, with interest paid quarterly.

What is the effective rate, and what are 1000 € worth after 3 years?

Taking 8 % as the rate for a year does not work: interest is paid four times a year, and it earns interest itself.

  1. The nominal rate is given, so we go forwards with the formula from the sheet: k=4, per quarter 8 %/4=2 %.
  2. Annual factor: 1.024=1.0824.
  3. Effective rate: r=8.24 %.
  4. In 3 years 3⋅4=12 quarters pass: 1000⋅1.0212=1268.24 €. This is the line Kt=K0(1+ck)tk on the sheet with t⋅k=12.

A bond is meant to yield an effective 8 % a year, with interest paid every half year.

Which nominal rate must it state?

Stating 8 % does not work: with payments every half year a nominal 8 % would yield more than an effective 8 % over a year.

  1. The effective rate is given: annual factor 1.08, k=2.
  2. Factor per half year: u2=1.08, u=1.081/2=1.039230.
  3. Find the nominal rate c.

Your turn2 of 3

A loan is meant to cost an effective 6 % a year, and the bank charges interest quarterly. Which nominal annual rate must it put in the contract? Round to two decimal places.

Effective rate traps

  • Giving the given rate as the answer. With an effective 6.5 % and monthly interest, answering 6.50 %, option b. Both rates are annual, and it seems there is nothing to convert. But when k>1 they always differ.
  • Going the wrong way. With an effective 6.5 %, computing (1+0.065/12)12−1=6.70 %. It is tempting because this formula is on the sheet. But it converts the nominal rate into the effective one, and here the effective rate is already given. Check: when k>1 the nominal rate is less than the effective one, and 6.70 % is more than 6.5 %.
  • Taking ln, as with continuous compounding. With an effective 6.5 %, computing ln⁡1.065=6.30 %: almost the same as the correct 6.31 %. But ln⁡(1+r) gives the continuous rate, and here interest is paid 12 times a year. Check how many interest payments the task names.

On the sheet: 1+r=(1+ck)k and Kt=K0(1+ck)tk. There is no inverse formula: c=k⋅((1+r)1/k−1) you remember or derive with the root.

How much capital grows under continuous compounding

Monthly compounding is converted with the line on the sheet that has k in it. Continuous compounding needs a different line, the one with the number e:

Exam-style task

Eine Stiftung legt 82000 GE an. Das Kapital wird stetig mit 6.8% pro Jahr verzinst; Erträge werden nicht entnommen. Wie hoch ist das Kapital nach 16 Jahren? Runden Sie auf eine ganze Zahl.

  1. a)234938
  2. b)243403
  3. c)98578
  4. d)171216
  5. e)64989

Here 82000 GE, that is money units, stay invested for 16 years, and the interest on them is paid continuously.

How to recognise the task: “continuous” or “continuously”, or the task already contains a formula with e.

A continuous compounding task links four numbers: K0, Kt, the rate c and the term t. There is one relation, Kt=K0⋅ec⋅t from the section on the number e. Three numbers are given, the fourth is asked for. In this task the capital Kt is asked for, so ln is not needed: the ex key is enough.

capital after 16 years: the formula with e

Capital of 82000 GE at a continuous 6.8 % over 16 years024681012141650000100000150000200000250000yearscapital, GE82000 GE
Step 1 of 4Set up the formula

“continuous interest” means Kt=K0⋅ec⋅t with K0=82000, c=0.068, t=16: K16=82000⋅e0.068⋅16.

If the term is asked for, divide both sides by K0 and take ln, as in the section on the number e:

ec⋅t=KtK0⟹c⋅t=ln⁡KtK0⟹
t=ln⁡(Kt/K0)c

For example, at a continuous 9 % capital has doubled when Kt/K0=2: t=ln⁡2/0.09=0.6931/0.09=7.70 years.

If the rate is asked for, take the same middle line c⋅t=ln⁡KtK0 and divide both sides by t instead of c:

c=ln⁡(Kt/K0)t

The example “the rate from two amounts” works with this line.

With continuous compounding, 5000 € became 7000 € in 6 years.

Find the continuous rate.

Dividing the gain by 6 years does not work: with continuous compounding the capital grows by the factor ec⋅t, not by the same amount each year.

5000 € became 7000 € in 6 years

5000 € at a continuous rate c become 7000 € in 6 years0123457200040006000800067000yearscapital, €5000 €7000 €t = 6 years
Step 1 of 4Set up the equation

K0=5000, Kt=7000, t=6, the rate c is unknown. From Kt=K0⋅ec⋅t: 5000⋅e6c=7000.

A town has 50000 inhabitants today. Over the last 10 years the population grew continuously at 3 % a year.

How many inhabitants were there 10 years ago?

Multiplying 50000 by e0.3 does not work: that would give more than today, but there were fewer people before.

  1. Today's number is Kt: 50000=K0⋅e0.03⋅10=K0⋅e0.3.
  2. Backwards: K0=50000⋅e−0.3.
  3. Work out K0.

Your turn3 of 3

4000 € earn a continuous 5 %. After how many years will they reach 6000 €? Round to two decimal places.

Continuous compounding traps

  • Computing as with interest once a year. For 82000 GE at 6.8 % over 16 years, computing 82000⋅1.06816=234938, option a. The familiar compound interest formula pulls you there. But “continuous interest” gives more: e0.068=1.0704 a year, not 1.068.
  • Treating growth as linear. For the same 82000 GE, computing 82000⋅(1+0.068⋅16)=171216, option d. That is simple interest, but with continuous compounding interest earns interest straight away.
  • Mixing up the direction. For the town with 50000 inhabitants today, multiplying by e+0.3 instead of e−0.3: 50000⋅e0.3=67492.94, more than today. If the population grew, there were fewer people 10 years ago.
  • Taking log instead of ln. For 4000 € growing to 6000 € at a continuous 5 %, computing log⁡1.5/0.05=3.52 instead of 8.11. In the article “Term and interest rate” any key worked as long as it stood both on top and below. Here below stands c, not a logarithm, so only ln works: ln⁡e=1.

On the sheet: K(t)=K(0)ect, our Kt=K0⋅ec⋅t. Also the line Aax=A(1+r)x=Aecx, c=ln⁡a: A is the starting value, x the number of years, a the annual factor (our q).

Formula sheet and what to memorise

Both exam tasks start from a line on the sheet. The steps back you add yourself: the root for the nominal rate and the logarithm for the term.

On the formula sheet (r effective annual rate, c nominal rate in (1+ck)k and continuous rate in ect, k number of interest payments per year, t term; we also write q=1+r):

  • effective rate 1+r=(1+ck)k and growth over t years Kt=K0(1+ck)tk: converting the rate, only from nominal to effective;
  • continuous growth K(t)=K(0)ect and Aax=Aecx, c=ln⁡a: continuous compounding.

Memorise yourself:

  • when k>1 the effective rate is greater than the nominal one; offers are compared by the effective rate;
  • nominal from effective: c=k⋅((1+r)1/k−1);
  • continuous: backwards K0=Kt⋅e−c⋅t, term t=ln⁡(Kt/K0)/c, only with ln.

In short

  • Nominal and effective interest rate

    Interest is paid k times a year. Each period brings the nominal rate c divided by k, and the growth over the year r comes out greater than c.
    1+r=(1+ck)k

    Trap: giving the given rate as the answer or converting in the wrong direction.

  • Continuous compounding

    Interest is paid continuously (“continuous”, “continuously”). At the continuous rate c, capital grows ec⋅t times in t years.
    Kt=K0⋅ec⋅t

    Trap: calculating with (1+c)t or removing ec⋅t with the log key; only ln⁡ removes it.

Monthly, quarterly and continuous rates are drilled in the “Annuities, intra-year and continuous compounding” trainer. If the rate or the frequency changes partway through, capital is worked out in stretches; how, is shown in “The interest rate changes mid-term: finding the final capital and the doubling time”.

Now practise it

How often interest is paid: why 9 % monthly beats 9.3 % once a year

Trainer · Elementary financial mathematics

Practise
Next: The interest rate changes mid-term: finding the final capital and the doubling time
0/3

Was this article helpful?