Criticising a Measure (Maßnahmen kritisieren)

19 min · 4 drills

In the seventh and last task of the speaking part, you are at an information event held by the city or the university. A planned measure (German: Maßnahme) is announced in a short written notice, and you speak for a group of students: you criticise the measure, justify the criticism and propose something better. You have about 1:30 minutes of preparation and 1:30 minutes of speaking time (German: Sprechzeit).

The task

The screen shows the situation and the notice, for example a notice board posting or an announcement of a few sentences. The situation fixes your role: you are, for example, a member of the student representative council or of a departmental student committee (German: Fachschaft), and your group rejects the measure. The instruction names three things: criticise, justify the criticism, make a better proposal. Preparation and speaking time run automatically with a countdown; notes on paper are allowed.

All three parts count. If you only criticise, you have left out the proposal; if you only make a counter-proposal, you have not said what is wrong with the measure. Because you speak for a group, wir is the natural form, and the tone is that of a public event: polite, factual, but firm.

The recording is assessed later by trained raters according to the provider's five criteria: relevance to the topic, task fulfilment, use of the sources, fluency and pronunciation, and language use. Here the source is the notice. The result of the whole part is converted to 0 to 20 (5–9 TDN 3, 10–15 TDN 4, 16–20 TDN 5); the provider does not publish raw-score cut-offs.

CriterionHow you gainHow you lose
Relevance to the topicEvery criticism concerns exactly this measure.You complain in general about the university administration.
Task fulfilmentCriticism, justification and proposal are audible, you speak as a group.The proposal is missing, or you speak only for yourself.
Use of the sourcesYou name the details of the notice: times, numbers, deadlines, aim.You render the measure wrongly or only vaguely.
Fluency and pronunciationYou speak coherently to the end.Long pauses between criticism and proposal.
Language useCriticism and proposal in the right register, Konjunktiv II for proposals.„Das ist doch Quatsch“ or so cautious that no criticism can be heard.

Time plan

At 120 to 140 words per minute, ninety seconds correspond to about 180 to 210 words. That is enough for two justified points of criticism and one concrete proposal, not for more.

PhaseDurationWhat you do
Preparation, reading the noticeabout 0:20Underline details: times, numbers, deadlines, those affected, aim of the measure.
Preparation, criticismabout 0:40Two points of criticism, for each: who is affected, with what consequence?
Preparation, proposalabout 0:30One proposal that achieves the aim of the measure better.
Speaking, openingabout 15 secondsWhom you speak for, which measure it is about, your stance.
Speaking, criticism 1about 25 secondsPoint of criticism with justification and example.
Speaking, criticism 2about 20 secondsSecond point of criticism with justification.
Speaking, proposalabout 25 secondsAcknowledge the aim, make the counter-proposal concrete.
Speaking, conclusionabout 5 secondsRequest or offer.

The note template for the preparation:

Maßnahme: was, ab wann, Ziel (eine Zeile) K1 … → wer? Folge? K2 … → wer? Folge? Ziel ok: … Vorschlag: statt … lieber …

If you run out of things to say. Make a point of criticism vivid: describe in two sentences what a day concretely looks like for a person affected. Or explain why your proposal achieves the aim of the measure better than the measure itself. Both deepen what you have already said.

If time runs short. The proposal is the third part of the task and comes at the end. Move on to „Wir würden stattdessen vorschlagen …“ at the latest when about 25 seconds remain, even if the second point of criticism has had only one sentence. The conclusion may be dropped entirely; the proposal may not.

Step by step

  1. Read the notice closely. Underline what concretely changes, from when, for whom and with what aim. Good criticism hits a detail („höchstens drei Stunden“), not the measure as a whole, and that is exactly how the raters hear that you have used the source.
  2. Find the aim of the measure. Almost every notice gives a reason: costs, lack of space, safety. You need this aim twice: for the understanding you show, and for the proposal that achieves it better.
  3. Two points of criticism, each with a consequence. For each detail ask: whom does it affect, and what happens then? „Wer in einer kleinen WG wohnt, hat zu Hause keinen ruhigen Platz“ is a justification; „Das ist unpraktisch“ is not.
  4. Speak for the group. State your role at the start, then use wir, uns, unsere Mitglieder throughout. Ich fits only in the first sentence, when you introduce yourself.
  5. Acknowledge the aim. A sentence like „Wir verstehen durchaus, dass der Lesesaal überfüllt ist“ shows that your criticism is constructive and makes the proposal more credible.
  6. Make a concrete proposal. The proposal should achieve the same aim, only without the disadvantages you criticised. Concrete means numbers, times or a clear procedure, not „Man sollte eine bessere Lösung finden“.
  7. Stay polite but firm. State the criticism clearly, without softening it with vielleicht ein bisschen; put the proposal in the Konjunktiv II. Derogatory words (absurd, lächerlich) weaken the effect instead of strengthening it.

Your turn1 of 4

Which sentence criticises politely but firmly?

Typical pitfalls

Criticism without a proposal. Ninety seconds of criticism, then „Wir hoffen, dass Sie das überdenken.“ The third part of the task is missing, and the criticism leads nowhere.

Ich instead of wir. „Ich finde das schlecht, weil ich abends arbeite.“ The situation requires you to speak for a group. A personal example is allowed, but as an example for many: „Viele von uns arbeiten abends.“

Criticism without justification. „Die Regel ist unfair, und das gefällt uns nicht.“ Unfair to whom, and with what consequence? Without that answer, the criticism remains an opinion.

The wrong tone. „Das ist doch Quatsch!“ is too aggressive for a public event. „Vielleicht könnte man eventuell darüber nachdenken, ob …“ is so cautious that nobody hears a criticism. What is wanted is the middle: clear on the matter, polite in form.

Misrepresenting the measure. „höchstens drei Stunden am Tag“ becomes „drei Stunden pro Woche“, or you criticise something that is not in the notice at all. That costs you on the use of the source.

A proposal that ignores the aim. „Die Bibliothek sollte einfach doppelt so groß werden.“ The proposal does not solve the problem the measure is meant to solve and is hardly feasible. A good proposal shows that you take the aim seriously.

A long opening. Thirty seconds of greeting and introduction, and no time is left for the proposal. One sentence on your role, one on the measure, then the criticism.

Useful phrases

These useful phrases (German: Redemittel) suit a public information event: you speak in front of representatives of the city or the university, on behalf of others, factually and politely, but without hesitating. Learn two from each group that you can recall without thinking.

Introducing yourself, speaking for the group

RedemittelMeaning and use
Ich spreche hier für die Fachschaft …'I am speaking here for the student committee of …'; state your role
Ich bin als Vertreterin/Vertreter der … hier.'I am here as a representative of …'; state your role, variant
Wir haben in der Fachschaft ausführlich über … gesprochen.'We have discussed … at length in the committee'; show that the group stands behind you

Naming the measure

RedemittelMeaning and use
Es geht um die geplante Regelung, nach der …'This is about the planned rule under which …'; render the measure briefly
Wenn ich die Mitteilung richtig verstehe, sollen …'If I understand the notice correctly, … are to …'; render the measure, cautiously

Criticising

RedemittelMeaning and use
Wir sehen die Maßnahme kritisch, weil …'We view the measure critically because …'; stance with a reason
Problematisch finden wir vor allem …'What we find problematic above all is …'; name the main point of criticism
Was uns besonders Sorgen macht, ist …'What worries us in particular is …'; criticism with weight
Aus unserer Sicht geht die Regelung an der Realität vieler Studierender vorbei.'In our view, the rule misses the reality of many students'; fundamental criticism, polite
Hinzu kommt ein zweiter Punkt: …'There is also a second point: …'; add the second point of criticism

Showing consequences

RedemittelMeaning and use
Das hätte zur Folge, dass …'The consequence would be that …'; name a consequence
Betroffen wären vor allem diejenigen, die …'Those affected would above all be those who …'; name those affected
Für viele von uns bedeutet das konkret, dass …'For many of us this concretely means that …'; make the consequence vivid

Showing understanding

RedemittelMeaning and use
Wir verstehen durchaus, dass …'We do understand that …'; acknowledge the aim
Das Ziel, …, unterstützen wir ausdrücklich.'We expressly support the aim of …'; share the aim, criticise the means
Uns ist klar, dass …'We are aware that …'; acknowledge a constraint

Proposing

RedemittelMeaning and use
Wir würden stattdessen vorschlagen, …'Instead, we would suggest …'; introduce the counter-proposal
Sinnvoller fänden wir es, wenn …'We would find it more sensible if …'; alternative with an evaluation
Eine Möglichkeit wäre, …'One possibility would be to …'; alternative, open
Wäre es nicht denkbar, …?'Would it not be conceivable to …?'; proposal as a question, polite

Concluding

RedemittelMeaning and use
Wir bitten Sie deshalb, die Regelung noch einmal zu überdenken.'We therefore ask you to reconsider the rule'; request
Wir sind gern bereit, gemeinsam mit Ihnen eine Lösung zu suchen.'We would be glad to look for a solution together with you'; offer of cooperation

Many critical remarks can be reshaped from a reproach into constructive criticism. Match them:

Your turn2 of 4

A worked example

Practice task, entirely invented. University, people and rules are made up.

Die Universitätsbibliothek stellt an einem Informationsabend neue Regeln für ihre Lernplätze vor. Sie nehmen als Mitglied der Fachschaft Sozialwissenschaften teil. Die Fachschaft ist gegen die neuen Regeln, und Sie ergreifen das Wort. Kritisieren Sie die Regeln im Namen der Fachschaft und begründen Sie Ihre Kritik. Schlagen Sie vor, wie die Lernplätze besser vergeben werden könnten.

Lernplätze im Lesesaal: neue Regeln ab 2. März

Damit Lernplätze nicht länger stundenlang mit Taschen und Büchern belegt werden, können die Plätze im Lesesaal ab dem 2. März nur noch online reserviert werden, spätestens 24 Stunden im Voraus. Pro Person sind höchstens drei Stunden am Tag möglich. Plätze ohne Reservierung dürfen nicht genutzt werden.

What the notice lays down: online only, at the latest 24 hours in advance, at most three hours a day, no spontaneous use. Aim: to prevent seats that are blocked but empty.

Notes during preparation:

Maßnahme: Lesesaal nur Reservierung, 24 h vorher, max. 3 h/Tag; Ziel: keine blockierten Plätze K1 3 h → Prüfungszeit ganzer Tag; WG ohne ruhigen Platz K2 24 h + nur reserviert → nichts spontan, Plätze leer Ziel ok: blockierte Plätze = Problem Vorschlag: Hälfte frei, nach 30 min ohne Person freigeben

This produces the following answer:

① Role, measure, stance

Guten Abend, ich spreche hier für die Fachschaft Sozialwissenschaften. Es geht um die neue Regelung, nach der man Lernplätze im Lesesaal nur noch online und höchstens drei Stunden am Tag reservieren kann. Wir sehen diese Maßnahme kritisch.

② Criticism 1 with justification

Problematisch finden wir vor allem die Obergrenze von drei Stunden. In der Prüfungszeit lernen viele von uns den ganzen Tag, und nach drei Stunden müssten sie ihren Platz räumen. Betroffen wären vor allem diejenigen, die zu Hause keinen ruhigen Arbeitsplatz haben, etwa weil sie sich ein Zimmer in einer kleinen WG teilen.

③ Criticism 2 with justification

Hinzu kommt ein zweiter Punkt: Wer morgens merkt, dass ein Seminar ausfällt, kann die freie Zeit nicht spontan in der Bibliothek nutzen, selbst wenn dort Plätze leer stehen.

④ Acknowledging the aim, counter-proposal

Wir verstehen durchaus, dass Plätze, die mit Taschen belegt, aber nicht genutzt werden, ein echtes Problem sind. Wir würden aber vorschlagen, nur die Hälfte der Plätze reservierbar zu machen und die andere Hälfte frei zu lassen. Außerdem sollte ein Platz, an dem nach dreißig Minuten niemand sitzt, automatisch wieder freigegeben werden. Damit würde man genau die blockierten Plätze verhindern, ohne die Lernzeit zu begrenzen.

⑤ Request

Wir bitten Sie deshalb, die Regelung noch einmal zu überdenken.

191 words, about 1:30 minutes when spoken.

The answer states the role in the first sentence and then speaks as wir throughout. Both points of criticism hit a detail of the notice, the three hours and the obligation to reserve, and name those affected and the consequences. The proposal takes up the library's aim, blocked seats, and achieves it by other means; that is what makes the criticism constructive. If time ran short after move ③, the first sentence of the proposal would stay and the request at the end would be dropped.

Practise yourself

Your turn3 of 4

What is missing from this answer? 'Wir sehen die neue Regel sehr kritisch. Drei Stunden sind viel zu kurz, und 24 Stunden im Voraus kann kaum jemand planen. Das benachteiligt viele Studierende. Wir bitten Sie, das noch einmal zu überdenken.'

Fill in the useful phrases.

Your turn4 of 4

Wir sehen die Maßnahme ···, weil sie viele Studierende benachteiligt. ··· finden wir vor allem die feste Obergrenze. Wir würden ··· vorschlagen, einen Teil der Plätze frei zu lassen.

Key takeaways

  • Three parts count: criticise, justify, make a better proposal.
  • Read the notice for details and the aim; good criticism hits a detail, a good proposal achieves the aim better.
  • Two points of criticism, each with those affected and a consequence, plus a proposal fill the 90 seconds (about 180 to 210 words).
  • Your role in the first sentence, then wir throughout.
  • Polite but firm: clear criticism without softening, proposals in the Konjunktiv II, no derogatory words.
  • If time runs short, move on to the proposal at the latest 25 seconds before the end.

Now practise it

Criticising a measure

Trainer · Sprechen

Practise
0/4

Was this article helpful?