Ordering Paragraphs (Textabschnitte ordnen)

18 min · 4 drills

In the second task of the Reading part, a text has been cut into paragraphs (German: Textabschnitte), and you restore the original order. What is tested is whether you see how a text holds together: each paragraph picks up something said before and prepares what comes next. These links are visible in the language, and if you read them, you do not have to guess from the content.

The task

The task counts four items, and only one order produces a coherent text. In the trainer the beginning of the text is fixed, below it come four paragraphs in the wrong order, and you drag them to positions 2 to 5. Each correctly filled position earns one point there.

This leads to a calculation you should know: a single paragraph cannot be wrong on its own. If you drag a paragraph to the wrong place, you displace another one, so at least two positions are wrong. An early mistake at position 2 often shifts the whole chain.

Scoring is automatic. The raw score of the Reading part is converted to a scale from 0 to 20: 5–9 points correspond to TDN 3, 10–15 points to TDN 4, 16–20 points to TDN 5. The test provider does not publish how many correct answers are needed for which level.

Timing

You have 5 minutes for the four paragraphs; then the test moves on, and the task cannot be reopened.

PhaseTimeWhat you do
Read the beginning0:45Read the given beginning closely, above all its last sentence
Read the edges1:30Read the first and the last sentence of each paragraph, note the signals
Build the chain1:45Settle position 2 and the ending, then link the middle
Check1:00Read the whole text once in the order you chose

There is not enough time to read every paragraph twice in full. There is enough time to read the edges carefully, and that is where the signals are.

Step by step

Every paragraph has two edges. At its start it picks up something the reader must already know: it refers back. At its end it leaves something that the next paragraph takes up. The task is to join ends and beginnings into pairs.

  1. Read the fixed beginning. Note what it ends with: a claim, a problem, a person, a year? The paragraph at position 2 links to exactly that.
  2. Check the beginnings of the four paragraphs. Mark mentally whatever refers back: pronouns (sie, er, dies), reference words (German: Verweiswörter) such as diese Entwicklung, dabei, deshalb, and definite articles on something that looks new (die Forscherin, das Verfahren). Each of these words needs an antecedent that stands before it in the text. Ask: where is it?
  3. Check the ends of the four paragraphs. What does the paragraph introduce last? A new term, a question or a demand at the end is a hook on which the next paragraph hangs.
  4. Settle position 2 and the ending. For position 2 only a paragraph whose references are resolved by the beginning can qualify. The final paragraph usually has no hook left at its end. It often starts with schließlich ('finally'), seitdem ('since then'), bis heute ('to this day') or inzwischen ('by now'), draws a conclusion or answers the question the text has raised.
  5. Link the middle. With two fixed points, only two paragraphs remain for the middle, so there are two possible orders. Check which link from end to beginning holds.
  6. Check the chain. Read the text in your order. Every reference word must have an antecedent before it, every person must be introduced with the indefinite article or full name before returning as die Forscherin or sie, and the time order must not jump without the text marking it.

Why these signals hold: an author can treat a topic in many orders, but cannot refer back to something not yet mentioned. Diese Entwicklung ('this development') presupposes that a development has been described. Dagegen ('by contrast') presupposes a statement that is being contradicted. Content leaves room for interpretation, references leave none.

Typical traps

The same word is not yet a link. A key word of the topic occurs in several paragraphs. If Bakterien appears in the beginning and in one of the paragraphs as well, that proves nothing. A link only exists once that paragraph starts with a reference pointing to the beginning, for example Diese Bakterien or Ihre Fähigkeit.

A reference with the wrong antecedent. Dies and dabei can refer to many things. Check whether the antecedent you assume fits in content. If a paragraph starts with Dieser Vorschlag stieß auf Widerstand ('This proposal met with resistance'), the sentence before must contain a proposal, not merely a problem.

The flashback. An early year does not mean the paragraph comes early in the text. Schon 1970 hatte eine Kommission gewarnt ('As early as 1970 a commission had warned') is marked as a look back by the past perfect and schon, and it can stand in the middle of the text. The time order of the events and the order of the paragraphs are two different things.

The contrast with nothing to contrast. Connectors (German: Konnektoren) such as dagegen, hingegen or jedoch at the start of a paragraph require a statement immediately before them to contrast with. If the statement there points in the same direction, the place is wrong.

Reason and consequence the wrong way round. Deshalb (therefore) and nämlich both require an antecedent, but in opposite directions. After deshalb comes the consequence; the reason stands before it. With nämlich comes the reason, and before it stands the claim it explains, often a short or surprising sentence. In this use nämlich stands in the middle field of the clause, never at the start of the sentence. Likewise, trotzdem requires a drawback or objection before it, and erst als a state that held until then and now ends.

Die Mensa am Nordcampus bleibt mittags fast leer. Die meisten Vorlesungen enden dort nämlich erst um halb zwei. (The canteen on the north campus stays almost empty at lunchtime. Most lectures there, you see, end only at half past one.)

The second sentence justifies the first. If a paragraph begins with such a nämlich sentence, the paragraph before it must end with the observation it explains.

Die Miete im neuen Wohnheim liegt deutlich über dem Durchschnitt. Trotzdem waren alle Zimmer nach einer Woche vergeben. (The rent in the new hall of residence is well above average. Nevertheless, all rooms were taken within a week.)

Before trotzdem stands the drawback, the high rent. Without it, it would be unclear what the trotzdem is set against.

The chain fixed too early. If you take the first link that fits and keep building without checking the alternatives, one mistake puts two positions wrong. The check in step 6 is therefore part of the solution.

Signals of text cohesion

SignalExamplesWhat it reveals
Pronouns and demonstrativessie, er, dies, das, dieseThe antecedent is in the sentence or paragraph before.
Summarising reference worddiese Entwicklung, dieser Befund, dieses Problem, ein solcher AnsatzA process, finding or problem was described before and is bundled here into one noun.
Pronominal adverb (German: Pronominaladverb)dabei, dadurch, darauf, dafürRefers to a state of affairs already mentioned.
Definite or indefinite articleeine Forscherin versus die ForscherinThe indefinite article introduces, the definite one presupposes something known.
Additive connectorszudem, außerdem, darüber hinaus, auchContinues a series that has already begun.
Contrastdagegen, hingegen, jedoch, allerdingsBefore it stands a statement that is limited or disputed here.
Concessiontrotzdem, dennoch (nevertheless, still)Before it stands a drawback or objection, and yet something happens here.
Consequence and responsedeshalb, daher, daraufhin, als Reaktion daraufBefore it stands a reason or an occasion.
Justificationnämlich (you see, namely), der Grund dafür (the reason for this)Before it stands the claim that is justified here: the reason follows the claim, not the other way round.
Time orderzunächst, anfangs, später, daraufhin, seitdem, inzwischen, heuteOrders events; zunächst comes early, seitdem and inzwischen late.
End of a stateerst als (only when), erst seit (only since)A state was described before and ends here.
Looking back at the time beforebis dahin (until then)Before it stands a point in time or an event; what follows here is the state before it.
Conclusionschließlich, letztlich, insgesamt, bis heuteOften marks the last paragraph.
Enumerationerstens, ein weiterer Grund, eine zweite SchwierigkeitThe first item of the series must come earlier.

A worked example, step by step

Practice text, entirely invented. People, places and numbers are made up.

Ein Platz ohne Autos

Anfang (vorgegeben): Noch vor zwanzig Jahren war der Marktplatz von Hollbach ein Parkplatz. Wer in der Innenstadt einkaufen wollte, fuhr mit dem Auto bis vor die Ladentür, und die Händler waren überzeugt, dass ihr Umsatz davon abhing.

A Ihre Befürchtungen bestätigten sich allerdings nicht. Weil Cafés nun Tische ins Freie stellten, blieben die Besucher länger, und in den meisten Läden stieg der Umsatz schon im ersten Sommer. Im Herbst stimmte der Gemeinderat deshalb dafür, die Sperrung beizubehalten.

B Diese Überzeugung geriet ins Wanken, als die Stadt im Jahr 2009 eine Befragung in Auftrag gab. Sie ergab, dass die meisten Kundinnen und Kunden zu Fuß oder mit dem Bus kamen und dass die Autofahrer zwar viel Platz beanspruchten, aber weniger ausgaben als vermutet.

C Seitdem ist der Platz autofrei. Aus den Nachbargemeinden kommen inzwischen regelmäßig Delegationen, die wissen wollen, wie sich eine solche Umstellung organisieren lässt.

D Auf Grundlage dieser Ergebnisse beschloss der Gemeinderat, den Platz probeweise für einen Sommer zu sperren. Die Händler protestierten heftig, einige drohten sogar damit, ihre Geschäfte zu schließen.

The beginning ends with the shop owners' conviction. That is the hook.

The beginnings. A starts with Ihre Befürchtungen ('their fears'): someone must have feared something before. B starts with Diese Überzeugung ('this conviction'), C with Seitdem, D with Auf Grundlage dieser Ergebnisse ('these results'). So every paragraph refers back, and each requires a different antecedent.

Position 2: B. Diese Überzeugung is resolved by the last sentence of the beginning: the shop owners waren überzeugt ('were convinced'). Here the same-word trap lies in wait: D also mentions die Händler and therefore looks like a link to the beginning. But D starts with Auf Grundlage dieser Ergebnisse, and the beginning mentions no results.

Ending: C. Seitdem requires an event that establishes a lasting state, and inzwischen looks at the present. There is no hook left at the end of C. The matching event is the decision at the end of A to keep the closure.

The middle: D before A. Between B and C stand D and A. Dieser Ergebnisse in D refers to the survey at the end of B. At the end of D the shop owners protest and threaten to close, and these are the Befürchtungen that A picks up with Ihre. The other order, A before D, fails twice: Ihre Befürchtungen would have no antecedent after B, and the closure that A keeps would not even have been decided yet.

Check. In the order beginning, B, D, A, C, every reference word has an antecedent, and time runs forward: the survey in 2009, then the trial summer, the decision in autumn, since then the car-free square. Solution: position 2 = B, 3 = D, 4 = A, 5 = C.

Practise yourself

The following questions train the individual signals. In each case read only the sentences given.

Your turn1 of 4

Which paragraph opening most clearly presupposes a previous paragraph?

Your turn2 of 4

A paragraph ends with the sentence: 'Die Regierung kündigte daraufhin ein Förderprogramm an.' Which opening fits the next paragraph best?

Your turn3 of 4

Which sentence is most likely to open the last paragraph of a text?

Your turn4 of 4

A paragraph begins with the sentence: 'Der Zug hatte nämlich schon in Berlin eine Stunde Verspätung.' (The train, you see, was already an hour late in Berlin.) Which sentence most likely ends the paragraph before it?

Key takeaways

  • Every paragraph refers back at its start and leaves a hook at its end. Join ends to beginnings.
  • Read the edges closely: pronouns, diese Entwicklung, dabei, definite articles and connectors such as zudem, dagegen, nämlich or trotzdem require an antecedent. Deshalb follows the reason, nämlich follows the claim it justifies.
  • Settle position 2 and the ending first (seitdem, bis heute, schließlich, no hook left); then only two possibilities remain for the middle.
  • The same words prove no link, and an early year proves no early position.
  • One misplaced paragraph costs at least two positions. Check the finished chain by reading the whole text once.

Now practise it

Ordering paragraphs

Trainer · Lesen

Practise
Next: Multiple choice
0/4

Was this article helpful?