Which method? Functions of two variables
In the textbook: Ch. 8 Analysis von Funktionen mit zwei Variablen
The three articles of the chapter took the methods one at a time: partial derivatives, extrema without a constraint, the Lagrange method. In the exam nobody names the method; you recognise it from the task.
Almost every task of the chapter starts with the partial derivatives (“partielle Ableitungen”). What happens to them next is given away by words in the task (“Angabe”): “unter der Bedingung” (subject to the condition), “entlang” (along), “in Richtung” (in the direction of), “ersetzen” (replace).
Here is what one such phrase does. A repair shop splits its working time between bicycles and scooters: hours a week on bicycles, on scooters, and the profit is €. There are two tasks about it:
- The first asks at which and the profit is largest.
- The second asks the same but adds “unter der Bedingung ”: the mechanic has only 12 hours.
In both you are tempted to set both partial derivatives to zero.
Without a condition, that is the whole method: and give , and a profit of 164 €. In the second the same point will not do: hours, and there are only 12. This needs the Lagrange method. At its optimum the two partial derivatives are not zero but equal to each other: , so . Together with this gives , and a profit of 146 €. The function is the same; three words of the task chose the method.
Three questions before every calculation
The repair shop showed that words of the task choose the method. Three questions find such words in any task:
- Is there a constraint (“Nebenbedingung”)? A budget, a set output or an isoquant (“Isoquante”) mean the Lagrange method or the marginal rate of substitution (“Grenzrate der Substitution”). If there is no constraint and extrema are asked for, you need the Hessian matrix (“Hesse-Matrix”).
- Is something moving? If and depend on a third quantity, it is the chain rule. If a direction is given, it is the directional derivative (“Richtungsableitung”).
- Is a number at a point asked for? Then one partial derivative with the point put in is often enough.
The decision table
The three questions narrow the choice to two or three methods. The table below takes it down to one: on the left the sign in the task, on the right the section where that method is explained.
| How to recognise it | Method |
|---|---|
| One variable changes by one unit, the point is given; “Grenzproduktivität” (marginal product) | Partial derivative at a point: marginal product |
| Second derivative or Hessian matrix at the given point, with no question about the type | Hessian matrix at a point: four second derivatives |
| and , “entlang” (along), “im Zeitverlauf” (over time) | How fast the function changes along a curve: chain rule |
| “In Richtung” (in the direction) of a vector | How fast the function changes in a given direction: directional derivative |
| Stationary points, maximum, minimum, saddle point, no constraint | Stationary point: maximum, minimum or saddle point |
| Two demand functions, the pair of prices with the largest profit | Which two prices give the largest profit |
| Slope of the isoquant or indifference curve, point with a given slope | Implicit derivative: slope of the isoquant |
| “ersetzen” (replace), GRS (“Grenzrate der Substitution”, marginal rate of substitution) at a point | Rate of substitution: the quotient of marginal utilities at a point |
| Maximise the utility on a budget | What to buy on a budget: maximum utility |
| Minimise the cost at a set output, question about | How to make a set output most cheaply: minimum cost |
| The output is split between two plants | How to split output between two plants: minimum cost |
| Both quantities change a little, “totales Differential” (total differential) | The total differential |
| Percentage change, “homogen” (homogeneous), “Skalenerträge” (returns to scale) | Percentage change and homogeneity |
The pairs people mix up
The choice table in the previous section helps when the task has a single sign. When there are two, or the methods sound alike, it is easy to go wrong. The first pair in the list is the same as with the repair shop from the introduction. The methods below look almost the same because they all work with partial derivatives, but they answer different questions.
- Hesse or Lagrange. Both look for extrema. The Hessian test holds when and are free. If the task has an equation linking and (a budget, a set output, a sum ), you need the Lagrange method, and the free stationary points are not the answer.
- Hessian matrix at the point or type of the point. “Berechnen Sie die Hesse-Matrix im Punkt” (work out the Hessian matrix at the point) asks only for the four second derivatives; nothing is set to zero. The type is asked for with the words “Maximum”, “Minimum”, “Sattelpunkt” (saddle point).
- Maximum utility or minimum cost. In the first the constraint is the budget, in the second the output; the touching condition is the same. At the end different things are asked for: a quantity, the utility, the cost or .
- or . The GRS shows how much one unit of replaces; the fraction upside down is among the answers. The slope of the level curve is negative, the GRS positive.
- Chain rule or directional derivative. In the chain rule you take and from the given functions; in the directional derivative the vector is given directly. Read whether it is to be normalised.
- Value or point. “Wo” (where) asks for the point, “wie groß” (how large) for the value of the function there.
Practise recognising
Now test yourself on five tasks in which neither the method nor the pair is named. Every task below needs the partial derivatives, so the only question is what happens to them next. Answer without calculating. After you answer, the explanation shows which sign in the task decided the choice.
Your turn1 of 5
A household has 120 €; one good costs 2 €, the other 3 €. Its utility is . Which quantity does it choose? Which method is needed?
Your turn2 of 5
A firm wants to make 600 pieces, . One unit of capital costs 8 €, one unit of labour 2 €. What is the minimum cost? Which method is needed?
Your turn3 of 5
Along the isoquant : about how many units of capital does one extra unit of labour replace at the point , ? Which method is needed?
Your turn4 of 5
The temperature on a plate is . At time a point is at . How fast does the temperature change at ? Which method is needed?
Your turn5 of 5
A firm makes 80 units in two plants, and . How many units should the first plant make for the total cost to be as small as possible? Which method is needed?
Was this article helpful?