Save first, then pay out: two annuities in a row

25 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 2.3 Geometrische Folgen2.4 Finanzmathematische Renten

Many people save for old age like this: for years they put aside the same amount, and then for years they get the same payout from what they saved. Funds with yearly payouts work the same way. A series of equal payments at equal intervals is called an annuity (more in the article on annuities). Here two annuities follow one another: first the deposits, then the payouts.

First you save up, then you live on the savings, and the bank pays 3 % a year the whole time:

  • for 6 years in a row you put 1500 € into an account at the end of each year;
  • after that you take the same amount out at the end of each year for 4 years, until the account is empty.

How much can you take out each year?

Dividing the saved 6⋅1500=9000 € by 4 payouts gives 2250 € a year, and that is wrong: while the money is being saved, each deposit earns interest, and while it is being paid out, the rest in the account earns interest too.

Let us go phase by phase; the formulas for both are explained below:

  • in 6 years the deposits grow with interest to 1500⋅1.036−10.03≈9702.61 €;
  • this amount is spread over 4 equal payouts so that, with interest on what is left, the account is empty exactly at the last one: 9702.61⋅0.031−1.03−4≈2610.27 €.

You can take out 2610.27 € every year, about 360 € more than plain division gave.

The basics

Both phases of the introduction were worked out with ready-made annuity formulas. Where these three formulas come from is shown in the article “Annuities: how to add up a series of equal payments”. In them a is one payment, t the number of payments, q=1+r, where r is the rate as a fraction:

  • future value E=a⋅qt−1q−1: the value of all payments on the day of the last one, if each comes at the end of a year;
  • present value B=a⋅1−q−tq−1: their value one year before the first;
  • payment a=B⋅q−11−q−t: the same formula solved for a, as in the section on the value of a series of payments.

If the first payment comes at the start of the period (vorschüssig), both values are q times as large, and the payment for the same value is q times smaller.

The answer to the question from the start:

  1. In 6 years E=1500⋅1.036−10.03=1500⋅6.468410=9702.615 € builds up.
  2. On the day of the sixth deposit this money equals the present value of the four payouts. So the payout is a=9702.615⋅0.031−1.03−4=9702.615⋅0.269027=2610.27 €.
  3. Without interest it would be only 9000/4=2250 €.

How much builds up from deposits earning interest

Let us take the phases one at a time. The first, saving up, also appears in the exam as a task of its own:

Exam-style task

Plan einer Gemeinde für ein Kulturfestival. Phase 1: 26 Jahre lang fließen am Ende jedes Jahres 9100 GE in eine Rücklage. Phase 2: 23 gleich hohe Förderbeträge, jeweils zu Beginn eines Jahres; der erste wird am selben Tag ausgezahlt, an dem die letzte Rate von Phase 1 eingeht. Danach ist die Rücklage aufgebraucht. Zinssatz in beiden Phasen: 4.25% pro Jahr.

Wie hoch ist ein Förderbetrag? Runden Sie auf ganze GE.

  1. a)27644
  2. b)28819
  3. c)28169
  4. d)15657
  5. e)21950

In the task, for 26 years, 9100 GE (money units from the task) is put into a reserve at the end of each year.

Signal: equal deposits are saved up with interest over years (“into a reserve at the end of each year”), and the answer needs the balance on the day of the last deposit.

How much is in the reserve on the day of the 26th deposit? Adding 26⋅9100 does not work, just as with the eight deposits of 40 € at the start of the article on annuities: each deposit earned interest for a different number of years. Go from the last deposit to the first:

  • the last one earned interest for 0 years and is worth 9100 GE;
  • the one before it earned interest for a year and is worth q=1.0425 times as much;
  • each further one is worth another q times as much.

This is a geometric sequence with first term x0=9100 and n=26 terms. Its sum Sn=x0⋅qn−1q−1 gives the capital of the reserve. In the figure of the solution below the deposits stand as bars: this shows that each next one is higher by the factor q.

last deposit 9100 GE, the one before 9100 · 1.0425

26 deposits of 9100 GE on the day of the last deposit, from the last to the first051015202550001000015000200002500030000term of the sumvalue of a deposit, GE9100 GEone year longer
Step 1 of 5First term and q

The last deposit is made on the reference day and does not grow: x0=9100. Rate 4.25 %, q=1.0425. The deposit before it earns interest for a year: 9100⋅1.0425=9486.75 GE: each deposit made a year earlier is worth q times as much.

Check the sum with bounds: 26 terms, each no smaller than the first and no larger than the last, so 26⋅9100=236600<417755.82<26⋅25759.83=669755.58.

The same sum also turns up without a bank account: a quantity grows by itself by the same percentage every year (“gegenüber dem Vorjahr”). Then the terms of the sequence are the values of the single years, and nothing has to be moved in time.

A factory produces 4000 ME (“Mengeneinheiten”, quantity units) in its first year, then 5 % more each year.

How much does it produce in the first 8 years?

Multiplying 4000 by 8 does not work: each year the output is larger than the year before.

The plant's output by year: 8 bars, each 5 % higher than the one before024681000200030004000500060007000yearoutput, ME4000 ME5 % more
Step 1 of 4Find the first term and q

x0=4000, “5 % more” means q=1.05.

A bakery sells 500 loaves in its first month, then each month 2 % more than the month before.

How many loaves does it sell in the first 12 months?

Multiplying 500 by 12 does not work: each month it sells more than the month before.

  1. x0=500, q=1.02, months 1 to 12: n=12.
  2. 1.0212=1.268242, minus 1: 0.268242, divide by 0.02: 13.412090. What is S12?

Your turn2 of 3

A society receives 600 € in donations in its first year, then each year 8 % more than the year before. How many € is that over the first 10 years together? Round to two decimal places.

Geometric sum traps

  • Saving up without interest. Adding up the deposits: 26⋅9100=236600 GE instead of 417755.82. With that capital the payout comes out at 15657 GE instead of 27644. It is tempting because the deposits are equal and you want to just multiply one by their number. Check: n⋅x0 is the lower bound of the sum; with q>1 the sum is larger.
  • Putting the number of the last term into the exponent. The first deposit contains q25, and this 25 moves into the sum: 9100⋅1.042525−10.0425=391995.99 GE, the sum of only 25 deposits. Check: the exponent of the sum holds the number of terms, here 26.
  • Counting one term too many. For the factory of the example “a factory's output over 8 years”, the years “0 to 8” give 9 terms and 44106.26 ME instead of 38196.44. Check: in year 1 the output is 4000, which is the first term.
  • Adding the same percentage of the first year every year. For the factory, 5 % of 4000 is 200 ME a year, and you get 8⋅4000+200⋅(1+2+…+7)=37600 ME instead of 38196.44. That is how an arithmetic sequence grows; with “gegenüber dem Vorjahr” the percentage is taken of the year before.

On the sheet: Sn=x0qn−1q−1; for deposits at the end of the year this is Et=a qt−1q−1 with a=x0 and t=n. What n is and what x0 equals you read from the task.

How much can be paid out of saved capital

The reserve in the last task was only built up. Now a second phase is added, as in the introduction, except that the payouts come at the start of the year:

Exam-style task

Plan einer Gemeinde für ein Kulturfestival. Phase 1: 14 Jahre lang fließen am Ende jedes Jahres 7000 GE in eine Rücklage. Phase 2: 21 gleich hohe Förderbeträge, jeweils zu Beginn eines Jahres; der erste wird am selben Tag ausgezahlt, an dem die letzte Rate von Phase 1 eingeht. Danach ist die Rücklage aufgebraucht. Zinssatz in beiden Phasen: 7.25% pro Jahr.

Wie hoch ist ein Förderbetrag? Runden Sie auf ganze GE.

  1. a)14656
  2. b)15128
  3. c)13485
  4. d)8603
  5. e)14105

Now, for 14 years, 7000 GE is put into a reserve, and then equal amounts are paid out of it until it is empty.

Signal: first money is saved with equal deposits (“reserve”, “saving phase”), then equal amounts are paid out of the savings until the account is empty, and you are asked for one payout.

Here two annuities follow each other:

  • deposits a1, their number t1;
  • payouts a2, their number t2.

One day links the two annuities: the day of the last deposit. On that day the account holds the capital K, the future value of the deposits, as at the start of the article:

K=a1⋅qt1−1q−1

From that day on the account works like a loan in reverse:

So K equals the present value of the payouts, worked out on the day of the last deposit, and the payout is found with the same payment formula:

a2=K⋅q−11−q−t2

This formula holds if the first payout comes a year after the day of the last deposit (nachschüssig). If the first payout is on that same day (vorschüssig), the payout is q times smaller: divide a2 by q.

Why q times smaller. Each vorschüssig payout comes a year earlier, so on the day of the last deposit it is worth q times as much, as in step 5 of the example with the reserve built from deposits of 9100 GE. The same capital K covers such payouts only if each of them is q times smaller.

14 deposits of 7000 GE, then 21 payouts a₂

Fourteen deposits of 7000 GE grow into capital; out of it 21 equal payouts, the first on the day of the last deposit51020357000 GE7000 GE7000 GE7000 GEa₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂capital Kyearsrate = 7.25 %
Step 1 of 4Write down both annuities

Deposits: a1=7000 at the end of each year, t1=14. Payouts: t2=21, each at the start of a year, the first on the day of the last deposit, that is at the end of year 14. Rate 7.25 %, q=1.0725.

Check: on the day of the last deposit, 21 vorschüssig payouts of 14105.45 GE are worth 14105.45⋅1−1.0725−210.0725⋅1.0725=160678.67 GE: that is the capital, and the 2 cents of difference come from rounding the payout.

For 10 years a club puts aside 2400 € at 4 % at the end of each year. Then for 8 years it pays the same rent for a pitch out of this account at the start of each year; the first rent on the day of the last deposit.

What rent can it pay so that the account ends up empty?

Dividing the savings by 8 does not work: while the rents are paid, the rest in the account keeps earning interest.

10 deposits of 2400 €, then 8 payouts

Ten deposits of 2400 € grow into capital; out of it eight equal payouts, the first at the time of the last deposit246810121416182400 €2400 €2400 €2400 €2400 €a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂a₂capital Kyearsrate = 4 %
Step 1 of 4Write down both annuities

a1=2400, t1=10; t2=8, the first payout at the end of year 10; q=1.04.

For five years, 1000 € is paid into an account at 4 % at the end of each year. Then for 4 years the same amount is paid out of the savings, the first payout a year after the last deposit. After the fourth the account is empty.

How large can one payout be?

Dividing the savings by 4 does not work: while the payouts run, the rest in the account keeps earning interest.

  1. Capital on the day of the last deposit: K=1000⋅1.045−10.04=5416.32 € (the example with five deposits of 1000 € in the section “What a series of equal payments is worth today and at the end”).
  2. The first payout comes a year after that day: nachschüssig, no need to divide by q.
  3. 1.04−4=0.854804, 1−0.854804=0.145196, 0.04/0.145196=0.275490. What is the payout?

Your turn3 of 3

For 12 years a municipality pays 3000 € into a fund at 5 % at the end of each year. Then for 10 years the fund pays a music school the same grant at the start of each year, the first on the day of the last deposit. After that the fund is empty. How large is the grant? Round to two decimal places.

Two-phase traps

  • Counting the first payout a year later. The payment formula for a loan is written for nachschüssig, and it gets used as it is. In the task above that gives 15128.09 GE instead of 14105.45. Check: “on the day the last instalment of phase 1 comes in” means the first payout is on the day of K, and a2 is divided by q.
  • Saving without interest. 14⋅7000=98000 GE instead of 160678.65 gives a payout of only 8603.10 GE. Check: the deposits earn interest for 14 years, K is clearly larger than the sum of the deposits.
  • Taking the future value factor for the payouts. K has just been worked out with the formula for E, and the hand carries on with the same factor: 160678.65⋅0.07251.072521−1/1.0725=3243.72 GE. Check: 21 payouts of 3243.72 GE are only 68118.12 GE in all, less than the capital, yet the account must be empty at the end. The payouts lie ahead of the day of K, so you need the present value factor, q−11−q−t2.

On the sheet: Et of the nachschüssig annuity for the capital and Bt for the payouts. Remember: both formulas work on the day of the last deposit.

How much debt is left on a loan after some of the payments, and how many payments it takes, is covered in the next article: “Repaying a loan in payments: how much debt is left and how many payments are needed”.

Formula sheet and what to memorise

Each phase is worked out with a formula from the sheet, but the sheet will not tell you the day on which the phases meet. The overview recalls the order:

  • Sum of a geometric sequence

    Equal deposits are saved up with interest, or a quantity grows by the same percentage every year; you need the sum of n terms, first term x0.
    Sn=x0⋅qn−1q−1

    Trap: putting n−1 instead of n in the power of the sum.

  • Payout from saved capital

    First t1 deposits a1, then t2 payouts a2 down to zero. The capital K on the day of the last deposit equals the present value of the payouts.
    a2=K⋅q−11−q−t2

    Trap: first payout on the day of the last deposit: divide by q.

On the formula sheet (payment a, number of payments t; saving runs through q, paying out through d=1q):

  • future value of an annuity: nachschüssig Et=a qt−1q−1, vorschüssig Et=a q qt−1q−1: capital on the day of the last deposit;
  • present value of an annuity: nachschüssig Bt=a d 1−dt1−d, vorschüssig Bt=a 1−dt1−d; payouts from capital;
  • sum of a geometric sequence Sn=x0qn−1q−1: saving up deposits and the sum of a growing quantity.

Memorise yourself:

  • the power of the sum is n, the last term has n−1;
  • the two phases meet on the day of the last deposit: K equals the present value of the payouts.

Saving up and paying out are drilled in the “Annuities, intra-year and continuous compounding” trainer. A loan works the same way, except the money comes first and is paid back in instalments. That is the topic of the article “Repaying a loan in payments: how much debt is left and how many payments are needed”.

Now practise it

Save first, then pay out: two annuities in a row

Trainer · Elementary financial mathematics

Practise
Next: Repaying a loan in payments: how much debt is left and how many payments are needed
0/3

Was this article helpful?