A top-up after a rate cut and unequal deposits

29 min · 3 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 2.1 Verzinsungsmodelle

The rate drops in the middle of the term: how much must you top up so the target is still reached? Deposits in different years differ: how much do they add up to on one day? Both tasks use one move: a payment is moved to the day you need by multiplying it by the growth factor q for every year forward and dividing by it for every year back. Where the rule comes from is covered in the article on compound interest.

The goal: 12000 € in 6 years.

  • Today you invest exactly as much as that takes at 4 % a year.
  • After 2 years the bank cuts the rate to 2.5 %.

Will the money be enough after 6 years? And if not, how much do you have to add on the day of the rate cut?

Add exactly what is missing after 6 years? That would be too much: the added money earns interest for another 4 years, so you need less.

Let us compare everything on the day the rate drops. Today you deposit 12000/1.046≈9483.77 €, and after 2 years the account holds 12000/1.044≈10257.65 €. At the new 2.5 % a different amount reaches the target in the remaining 4 years: 12000/1.0254≈10871.41 €. The money falls short, and the top-up is the difference: 10871.41−10257.65=613.76 €.

The basics

Moving a deposit to the day of the rate cut takes three rules from the article “Compound interest: what money is worth today and in a few years”. The rate r is written as a fraction, 4 % is r=0.04, and the factor is q=1+r:

  • in t years a capital K0 grows to Kt=K0⋅qt;
  • you move t years back by dividing, K0=Kt/qt: this is discounting;
  • you may only add amounts moved to the same day, the reference date.

The answer to the question from the start:

  1. Today you invest 12000/1.046=9483.77 €.
  2. After 2 years the account holds 9483.77⋅1.042=10257.65 €.
  3. To grow to 12000 € at 2.5 % in the remaining 4 years, you need 12000/1.0254=10871.41 € on that day.
  4. Missing: 10871.41−10257.65=613.76 €, and that is the top-up. The shortfall after 6 years is larger, 12000−10257.65⋅1.0254=677.47 €, but money that grows for 4 more years covers it.

How much to pay in when the rate falls

In the introduction the top-up for 12000 € was worked out step by step. The exam task asks something else: how much later the device can be bought if nothing is paid in:

Exam-style task

Eine Tierärztin legte genau so viel an, dass bei 6% pro Jahr nach 11 Jahren 187000 GE für ein Röntgengerät da sind. Nach 3 Jahren bekommt sie nur noch 5.25%. Statt nachzuzahlen, kauft sie das Gerät erst, wenn das Konto 187000 GE zeigt. Um wie viele Monate verzögert sich der Kauf? Runden Sie auf ganze Monate.

  1. a)15
  2. b)5
  3. c)14
  4. d)12
  5. e)13

You recognise this task by the setup: exactly as much was invested as would have been enough at the old rate, then the rate drops. Then one of two things is asked: the additional payment, in the task “the top-up”, or, as in the task above, how much longer you wait without one (“Instead of paying in …”).

This is the same move to one day as for the replacement payment, only with the reference date on the day of the rate cut. On that day you compare two amounts:

  • What is needed: enough to grow to the target at the new rate over the remaining years. That is the target, discounted at the new rate over the remaining years.
  • What is there: the amount invested today, grown at the old rate until the day of the cut.

“There” takes three moves. The numbers from the task above: target 187000 GE (money units, the exam's label for money) in 11 years, old rate 6 %, cut after 3 years.

  1. The target was invested, discounted at the old rate over all 11 years: 187000/1.0611=98509.27 GE.
  2. Until the cut the deposit grows for 3 years at the old rate, so it is multiplied by 1.063: 1870001.0611⋅1.063.
  3. The three factors 1.06 on top cancel three of the eleven below (rule am/an=am−n for a number a and exponents m, n, see “Powers: four rules with numbers”): 1870001.0611−3=1870001.068=117326.11 GE. That is the target, discounted at the old rate over the remaining 8 years only.

The additional payment is “needed” minus “there”.

Letters: target T, s years remain after the cut, old factor q=1+r, new q2=1+r2, additional payment A, new term after the cut without one x. These letters are not on the sheet.

A=Tq2 s−Tq s

Without an additional payment, “there” has to grow to the target at the new rate in x years: Tq s⋅q2 x=T, so q2 x=q s and x=s⋅ln⁡qln⁡q2, where ln⁡ is the natural logarithm (how to work with it is in the article “Term and interest rate: when the unknown is in the exponent”). The delay is x−s.

Timeline: invested today, target 187000 planned for year 11, the rate drops after 3 years, without an additional payment the target is reached later02468101298509.27 GEinvested187000 GEplanned targetrate = 6 %rate = 5.25 %× 1.191 = 117326.12 GErate changeyears
Step 1 of 4What is there on the day of the cut

The target T=187000 GE in 11 years, the rate drops after 3 years, so by the plan s=11−3=8 years remain. Invested: 187000/1.0611=187000/1.8982986=98509.27 GE, which grew in 3 years at 6 % to 187000/1.068=187000/1.5938481=117326.11 GE.

Ask yourself: why are the invested 98509.27 GE compounded rather than discounted?

A foundation needs 200000 € in 10 years and today invests the amount that is exactly enough at 5 %. After 4 years the rate drops to 3 %.

How much must it pay in on that day?

Going on with the old rate does not work: after the cut the money grows more slowly, and the amount invested no longer suffices.

Timeline from 0 to 10 years, the rate drops after 4 years, additional payment in year 4012345678910122782.65 €invested200000 €targetrate = 5 %rate = 3 %÷ 1.1941 = 167496.85 €rate changeyears
Step 1 of 4Discount the target to the rate change

After the cut s=10−4=6 years remain at 3 %: 1.036=1.1940523, needed 200000/1.1940523=167496.85 €.

An animal shelter needs 50000 € in 12 years. Today it invested the amount that is enough at 4 %. After 3 years the rate drops to 3 %.

After the cut, the amount invested no longer suffices.

  1. After the cut s=12−3=9 years remain.
  2. Needed on the day of the cut: 50000/1.039=50000/1.304773=38320.84 €.
  3. There on the day of the cut: 50000/1.049=50000/1.4233118=35129.34 €.
  4. What is the additional payment?

Your turn2 of 3

A foundation needs 100000 € in 8 years and today invests the amount that is enough at 6 %. After 3 years the rate drops to 4 %. How much must be paid in after 3 years?

Finding the old rate from the additional payment

The reverse task: in the example “a foundation with a target of 200000 €” the additional payment of 18253.77 € is given, and the old rate r is to be found. Subtract the additional payment from “needed” and you get “there”; “there” equals T/q s:

  1. 167496.85−18253.77=149243.08, which is 200000/q6.
  2. q6=200000/149243.08=1.340096.
  3. You need the number whose 6th power is 1.340096. That is the sixth root of 1.340096. On a calculator, 1.3400961/6=1.05; check: 1.056=1.340096. So q=1.05, that is r=5 %. How to take such a root on a calculator is covered in the article “Term and interest rate: when the unknown is in the exponent”.

If answer options are given, you can also put each one into the additional payment formula:

  • at 4 % the additional payment is 9433.95 €;
  • at 4.5 % the additional payment is 13917.70 €;
  • at 5 % the additional payment is 18253.77 €, as in the task;
  • at 5.5 % the additional payment is 22447.68 €.

The higher the old rate, the less was invested at the start and the more is missing after the cut.

Additional payment traps

  • Using the past years instead of the remaining ones, option (b), 5 months: 1.0525x=1.063 gives x=3.42 and a delay of about 5 months. Check: the exponent holds the years from the cut to the target, s=8.
  • The ratio of the rates instead of logarithms, option (c), 14 months: 8⋅6/5.25=9.14 years. That is only an approximation; the term comes only from q2 x=q s.
  • Turning the fraction of logarithms upside down, option (d), 12 months: 8⋅ln⁡1.0525/ln⁡1.06=7.03 years, shorter than planned. Check: at a lower rate you wait longer, x>s.
  • Calculating the shortfall at the end of the term. This is a trap of the additional payment task: the target sits at the end, and it seems natural to compare there. In the second example this gives 18253.77⋅1.036=21795.96 €. Check: the additional payment is made on the day of the cut, the task says so.
  • Discounting the additional payment to today. After the present value tasks your hand wants to move everything to today: 18253.77/1.054=15017.42 €. Same check: the task sets the day of the payment.
  • Using the new rate for the whole term. The formula is remembered as “target at the new rate minus target at the old rate” and all 10 years go in: 200000/1.0310−200000/1.0510=26036.13 €. Check: the first 4 years still ran at the old rate, the power holds only the remaining s=6 years.

On the sheet: Kt=K0(1+r)t; there is no formula for the additional payment on it, you build it from two discountings.

Unequal deposits: what they add up to on one date

The top-up concerned a single deposit, and it was moved to the day of the rate cut. Here there are several deposits, a different amount each year, but there is still one day for all of them:

Exam-style task

Eine Hausgemeinschaft spart auf eine neue Heizung. Ihr Rücklagenkonto wird mit 3% pro Jahr verzinst. Am Ende jedes Jahres legen die Parteien gemeinsam ein (in GE): Ende von Jahr1234Einzahlung490015009501700 Die erste Einzahlung folgt am Ende des ersten Jahres; der Wert gilt zu Beginn des ersten Jahres. Welchen Betrag müsste die Hausgemeinschaft zu Beginn des ersten Jahres einmalig auf das Konto legen, damit es denselben Wert hat wie die Einzahlungen zusammen?

  1. a)8272.25
  2. b)5763.37
  3. c)8040.81
  4. d)8550.99
  5. e)1889.77

The signal here is different: a table of deposits, a different amount each year, and you need the value of all deposits on one day, the end of the term or the start. In the task above it is the start: “the value is taken at the start of the first year”, and the “single amount” on that day must be worth as much as all the deposits together.

The same move as for the replacement payment works: each deposit sits in the account as a separate investment and grows on its own, and the interest on one deposit does not depend on the others. Up to the end of year 4:

  • a deposit at the end of year 1 sits for 4−1=3 years and is multiplied by q3;
  • a deposit at the end of year 4 is made on the valuation day itself, sits for 4−4=0 years and stays as it is, since q0=1.

Letters: deposits Z1,Z2,… at the end of years t1,t2,…, the term ends at the end of year n. Each deposit is compounded over the years after it, then you add:

Kn=Z1q n−t1+Z2q n−t2+…

If the value at the start of year 1 is asked for, the shift goes the other way. A deposit at the end of year t lies t years after that day, so it is discounted by t years, divided by q t, and the results are added: B=Z1q t1+Z2q t2+… The letter B stands here for this value at the start, the present value. You get the same by discounting Kn as a whole by n years.

A food truck's business account pays 4.75 % interest a year. At the end of each season the owner books the surplus onto it: 2400, 4450, 2800 and 4700 GE at the end of years 1 to 4. The last deposit is made on the reference day and earns no more interest. What is the balance at the end of year 4?

Timeline with the deposits 2400, 4450, 2800 and 4700 at the end of years 1, 2, 3 and 4, all compounded to the end of year 4 at 4.75 percent12342400 GE4450 GE2800 GE4700 GEend of year 4yearsrate = 4.75 %
Step 1 of 3Draw the timeline

The timeline gets 2400, 4450, 2800 and 4700 GE at the end of years 1, 2, 3 and 4. Rate 4.75 %, q=1.0475; the term ends at n=4.

Ask yourself: why does the first deposit get the power 3 when there are 4 years in all?

At the end of years 1 to 4, 1000, 1500, 0 and 2000 € are paid into an account at 3 %.

What are the deposits worth at the end of year 4, and what at the start of year 1?

Adding 1000, 1500, 0 and 2000 does not work: the deposits come in different years, and each is first moved to the day in question.

Timeline with the deposits 1000, 1500, 0 and 2000, compounded to the end of year 4, then the sum discounted to the start12341000 €1500 €0 €2000 €valueyearsrate = 3 %
Step 1 of 4Draw the timeline

1000, 1500, 0 and 2000 € at the end of years 1, 2, 3 and 4; q=1.03.

Take the same table at 3 %, but the deposit at the end of year 2 is unknown, x. At the end of year 4 the account must hold 5000 €.

Adding the deposits without moving them does not help: each one grows for its own length of time.

  1. Compound each deposit to the end of year 4: 1000⋅1.033+x⋅1.032+0+2000=5000.
  2. In numbers: 1092.727+1.0609 x+2000=5000.
  3. Move what is known to the right: 1.0609 x=5000−3092.727=1907.273.
  4. What is x?

This is the task from the sheet above. The residents of a block of flats pay 4900, 1500, 950 and 1700 GE into an account at 3 % a year at the end of years 1 to 4. What single amount at the start of year 1 is worth the same?

The reference day is the start of year 1, time 0. The deposits sit at 1, 2, 3 and 4, all after it: each one is discounted by as many years as it comes after the reference day. q=1.03.

  • 4900 comes after 1 year: 4900/1.03=4757.282.
  • 1500 comes after 2 years: 1500/1.0609=1413.894.
  • 950 comes after 3 years: 950/1.092727=869.385.
  • 1700 comes after 4 years: 1700/1.125509=1510.428.

4757.282+1413.894+869.385+1510.428=8550.989, rounded 8550.99 GE: option (d). Work with three decimals, or the last digit can be off by a cent. Check by the other route: at the end of year 4 the deposits are worth 9624.21 GE, and 9624.21/1.125509=8550.99.

Your turn3 of 3

At the end of year 1, 2000 € are paid in, nothing in year 2, and 1500 € at the end of year 3. How much is in the account at the end of year 3 at 2 %?

If all deposits are equal, you do not need to add them one by one: a single annuity formula gives such a sum. It is derived in the article “Annuities: how to add up a series of equal payments”. For a check: 4 deposits of 1000 € each at 3 % give 1000⋅(1.033+1.032+1.03+1)=4183.63 € by the end of year 4.

Irregular payment traps

  • Compounding each deposit one year too long. There are four deposits, and you want to give the first one the power 4. For the food truck this gives 15999.82 instead of 15274.29 GE. Check: deposits come at the end of the year, the last one earns no interest.
  • Reversing the powers. The largest power goes to the last deposit: 2400+4450⋅1.0475+2800⋅1.04752+4700⋅1.04753=15535.76 GE. Check: the first deposit sits longest, so it has the largest power.
  • Compounding when the start is asked for. Such deposits are usually compounded to the end, and out of habit your hand moves everything there. But “zu Beginn des ersten Jahres” asks for the value at the start, and the deposits are discounted. In the example “the same deposits at the end and at the start” that is 4161.74, not 4684.08 €. Check: for which day is the value asked?
  • Not discounting the first deposit when moving to the start. It seems that the year 1 deposit is “already at the start”. In the example “the same deposits at the end and at the start” this gives 1000+1500/1.03+2000/1.033=4286.59 €. Check: a deposit at the end of year 1 is one year away from the start.
  • Reversing the powers when discounting. The first deposit gets 1.034 and the last only 1.03: in the block of flats task this gives 8272.25 instead of 8550.99 GE, option (a). Check: the first deposit comes earliest, so it is discounted least.
  • Discounting everything over the whole term. The sum 9050 divided by 1.034 gives 8040.81 GE, option (c), as if everything came only at the end of year 4. Check: only the last deposit lies 4 years after the start.

On the sheet: Kt=K0(1+r)t for each deposit separately; for equal deposits the annuity formulas.

What a payment is worth today that only comes if something lasts for years is covered in the next article: “A payment that may not come: what it is worth today”.

Only the sum of two deposits is known: the first is x, the second the sum minus x

In the section on different deposits every deposit was known, and their value on one day was wanted. It also works the other way round: the result is given, and the deposit itself becomes the unknown.

The sum of two deposits is known, not each one. For example, at the end of years 1 and 2 a total of 6000 € was paid in, and at the end of year 4 the account holds 6476.79 € at 3 %.

How large is each of the two deposits? Call the first x, then the second is 6000−x:

  1. Compound each deposit to the end of year 4: x⋅1.033+(6000−x)⋅1.032=6476.79.
  2. Powers: 1.033=1.092727, 1.032=1.0609. We get 1.092727 x+(6000−x)⋅1.0609=6476.79.
  3. Expand the bracket by multiplying each term by 1.0609: 6000⋅1.0609=6365.40, so (6000−x)⋅1.0609=6365.40−1.0609 x.
  4. Collect x: 1.092727 x−1.0609 x=0.031827 x. The equation: 0.031827 x+6365.40=6476.79.
  5. Move 6365.40 to the right: 0.031827 x=6476.79−6365.40=111.39.
  6. Divide: x=111.39/0.031827=3499.86, that is 3500 € (the balance in the task is rounded to the cent).

The second deposit: 6000−3500=2500 €. Check which of the two is asked for: the first deposit is x.

Formula sheet and what to memorise

Both formulas in this article, for the top-up and for the sum of deposits, come from one move: shifting money along the timeline to a single day. The overview shows where each task starts:

  • Additional payment after a rate cut

    Money was invested for the target T at the old rate, the rate drops, s years remain after the cut. Additional payment on the day of the cut: needed minus there. Without one, the new term comes from q2 x=q s.
    A=Tq2 s−Tq s

    Trap: putting the additional payment at the end of the term or at today.

  • Future value of irregular payments

    A table of different deposits by year; each deposit is moved to the required day separately, then they are added.
    Kn=Z1q n−t1+Z2q n−t2+…

    Trap: charging interest on the last deposit.

On the formula sheet (rate r, term t; we write q=1+r):

  • compound interest Kt=K0(1+r)t: in every calculation of this article; read backwards, K0=Kt/qt, it discounts;
  • simple interest Kt=K0(1+t⋅r): only if the task names it.

Memorise yourself:

  • you may only add amounts moved to the same day; before the reference date compound, after it discount;
  • the additional payment is made and valued on the day of the rate cut, the power is the remaining s years; without one, the term after the cut comes from q2 x=q s;
  • an irregular deposit is compounded over the years after it, the last one does not grow.

Practise the top-up and irregular deposits in the “Compound interest” trainer. A payment promised only on a condition is valued differently today, which is the subject of “A payment that may not come: what it is worth today”.

Now practise it

A top-up after a rate cut and unequal deposits

Trainer · Elementary financial mathematics

Practise
Next: A payment that may not come: what it is worth today
0/3

Was this article helpful?