Transfer prices of cost centres and a payment at two rates

19 min · 2 drills

In the textbook: Ch. 6.3 Anwendungen linearer Gleichungssysteme

Usually the unknowns in a system set up from a text are quantities, such as a number of orders. Sometimes, though, the unknown is the price of a service or the size of a payment. Then a single division seems to solve the task, and it gets it wrong.

The unknowns in such systems are amounts of money, and each equation is a balance. Solving the system is not hard; setting it up correctly is.

A hotel has two internal departments, the kitchen and the laundry, and they work for each other. Each wants to charge the other a fair price.

At what price should the laundry charge one unit of its service?

The first idea: divide the laundry's costs by the units it gives away. But the kitchen's services are its costs too, and they are paid at the kitchen's price. So the price comes from a balance that holds both prices.

Take figures for one month:

  • the kitchen spends 460 € itself and cooks 100 portions: 20 for the laundry, 80 for the guests;
  • the laundry spends 160 € itself and washes 40 units: 20 for the kitchen, 20 for the rooms.

Dividing 160/40=4 € forgets the 20 portions the laundry ate. Let a kitchen portion cost k € and a laundry unit w €. Everything a service hands out, at its price, equals its own costs plus what it takes from the other:

  • kitchen: 100k=460+20w;
  • laundry: 40w=160+20k, so k=2w−8.

Put the second into the first: 100⋅(2w−8)=460+20w, 180w=1260, w=7 and k=6. A fair laundry price is 7 € per unit, almost twice what the division gave.

With payments at interest the first idea goes wrong in the same way. Lisa pays the same amount into an account at 5 % at the start of two years in a row, and at the end of the second year the account holds 2152.50 €. How much did she pay in each time? Halving gives 1076.25 €, but the first payment sat for two years and the second for one, and each grew differently: X⋅1.052+X⋅1.05=2.1525 X=2152.50, so X=1000 €. When the amount is split between two banks at different rates, there are two unknowns. Then a second equation joins this one: the parts add up to the whole payment.

Check yourself. A task at exam level. Cost centre A delivers 30 units of service to centre B and 70 to the market; centre B delivers 20 units to A and 30 to the market. The primary costs, a centre's own costs, are 440 GE for A and 220 GE for B; GE are money units. What is the transfer price pB, the price of one unit of B's service to the others?

How to set up the system: one equation for each total

Both tasks are set up by the rule from the article “A system from the text: one equation for each total”. The steps are the same, only the contributions to a total are now money: the price of a service times the number of units, and a payment times its interest factor.

Transfer prices of cost centres that supply each other

In the hotel from the start both prices were unknown and the numbers round. In the exam it is the same kitchen and laundry, only with more data and the deliveries in a table:

Exam-style task

Ein Hotel rechnet die Küche (A) und die Wäscherei (B) intern ab. Beide leisten füreinander und für die Gäste (Markt). Für die Küche gilt laut Budget ein fester Verrechnungspreis von pA=10.3 GE je Einheit; die Primärkosten der Wäscherei betragen 1090 GE. Die gelieferten Mengen:

von\anABMarktA301080B5030100

Welche Primärkosten KA (in ganzen GE) hat die Küche, und welcher Preis pB (GE je Einheit, zwei Nachkommastellen) deckt die Kosten der Wäscherei?

  1. a){KA=529pB=7.95
  2. b){KA=927pB=7.95
  3. c){KA=1325pB=7.95
  4. d){KA=564pB=7.27
  5. e){KA=412pB=10.3

Two departments serve each other and the market, there is a table of deliveries, and the question is about the prices they charge each other. Sometimes one price is already set, like the kitchen's budget price here; then the second unknown is the own costs of one of the centres.

The kitchen (centre A) and the laundry (centre B) work for each other and for the guests. A department whose costs are recorded separately is called a cost centre (German: Kostenstelle).

The laundry's own costs are 1090 GE. On top come the services it gets from the kitchen, at price pA. The laundry covers these costs by charging pB for each unit it gives to others: to the kitchen and to the guests. The laundry sells its work for itself to nobody, so that is not counted.

  • Primary costs (German: Primärkosten) are the own costs of a centre: 1090 GE for the laundry; the kitchen's are unknown, written KA, and they are what the task asks for.
  • Transfer prices (German: Verrechnungspreise) are the prices at which cost centres charge each other, here pA=10.3 GE from the budget and the unknown pB.

This gives the balance of each centre; for A it reads like this, for B likewise with the letters swapped:

(given to others)⋅pA=primary costs A+(received from B)⋅pB

given to others: A 90, B 150

Supply table: the row is the supplier, the column the recipient; own consumption is not countedto Ato Bmarketfrom Afrom B3010805030100
Step 1 of 4Read the corner of the table

Corner “from \ to”: the row says who gives, the column who receives.

A gives itself 30 (not counted), centre B 10, the market 80; to others 10+80=90. B gives itself 30, centre A 50, the market 100; to others 50+100=150.

In this task the laundry charges pB≈7.95 GE per unit of service. The first idea would give 1090/150≈7.27 GE: it leaves out the kitchen's services, which add 10⋅10.3=103 GE to the laundry's costs.

The table also comes the other way round. Corner “to \ from”: the rows A, B and “market” are the recipients, the columns A and B the suppliers. Primary costs of A 500 €, of B 600 €.

to\fromABA1550B3010market7090

A gives centre B 30 and the market 70, to others 100. From B it receives 50 (row A, column B).

100 pA=500+50 pB.

B gives centre A 50 and the market 90, to others 140. From A it receives 30.

140 pB=600+30 pA.

pA=5+0.5 pB. Then 140 pB=600+150+15 pB, 125 pB=750, pB=6, pA=8.

Prices of the hour and the kWh. Centre A generates 10000 kWh of electricity, primary costs 6000 €, and receives 100 repair hours from B. Centre B performs 500 hours of work, primary costs 3600 €, and receives 2000 kWh from A. Equations: 10000 pA=6000+100 pB and 500 pB=3600+2000 pA. From the first pA=0.6+0.01 pB. Find pB and pA.

Your turn1 of 2

The primary costs of centres A and B are 100 GE and 40 GE. According to the table (corner “from \ to”) A gives: itself 5, centre B 20, the market 20; B gives: centre A 10, itself 10, the market 40. What is the transfer price pA?

Traps. The wrong options of the task above come about like this:

  • Only the primary costs, option (d), pB=1090/150≈7.27: the kitchen's services are forgotten. Each centre also pays for what it received.
  • Forgetting what A receives, option (b), KA=90⋅10.3=927: the laundry's services, 50 pB, were not taken off the kitchen's revenue.
  • Adding instead of subtracting, option (c), KA=927+397.67≈1325: the kitchen covers the services it receives out of its revenue, so the primary costs are the difference.
  • One price for both centres, option (e), pB=10.3: the kitchen's price was used for the laundry too. The centres have different costs and quantities.
  • Not reading the table of deliveries by its corner: suppliers and recipients swapped. Read the corner first: “from \ to” or “to \ from”.
  • Counting own consumption: the centre covers the diagonal of the table of deliveries itself.

An unknown payment from the final amounts at two rates

With the cost centres, all amounts belonged to the same month. In the second task money is paid in in different years, and before adding, each payment is grown to the end of the term, as with Lisa at the start:

Exam-style task

Ein Sportverein verteilt seine Mitgliedsbeiträge für einen Kunstrasen: Zu Beginn jedes der nächsten drei Jahre werden 8300 GE angelegt, ein gleichbleibender Teil davon bei Bank A zu 7 % pro Jahr, der Rest bei Bank B zu 3 %. Nach drei Jahren stehen bei beiden Banken zusammen 27682.10 GE. Wie viel legt der Verein jedes Jahr bei Bank A an?

  1. a)3595
  2. b)5367
  3. c)4908
  4. d)4432
  5. e)3392

Here the same amount is paid in at the start of each of three years and split between two banks with different rates. The joint balance at both banks at the end of the third year is known. The unknowns are the two yearly parts: X at bank A and Y at bank B. There are two equations: the split X+Y=8300 and the joint balance. The other kind, with different payments each year, is the second example.

Why the factors are what they are. Each year the amount in the account is multiplied by q=1+r, where r is the rate as a decimal: at 7 % by 1.07 (compound interest; on the formula sheet Kt=K0(1+r)t, where K0 is the amount at the start and Kt the amount after t years). Each payment gets as many factors q as it stays years until the end of the third year:

  • the part X invested at the start of the first year stays three years: 1.07 X after one year, 1.07 X⋅1.07=1.1449 X after two, 1.225043 X after three, that is X⋅1.073;
  • the same part invested at the start of the second year stays two years: q2;
  • invested at the start of the third year, it stays one year: q.
Each mark is a payment at the start of a year: the further left the payment, the more years it grows until the end of year 30123XXXend of year 3yearsr = 7 %

Each of the three marks on the timeline above is one part X. Compare the distance to the right edge: the left mark grows for three years and gets q3, the right one only for one year and gets q.

x1⋅q3+x2⋅q2+x3⋅q=E

Here E is the amount in the account at the end of the third year, and x1, x2, x3 are the payments at the start of the first, second and third year. When all three payments equal X, the left side is X (q3+q2+q): the factors add up.

q³, q², q for each bank

One row for each bank: the factors q³, q², q and their sumq³q²qsumA, 7 %B, 3 %1.2251.14491.073.43991.09271.06091.033.1836
Step 1 of 4The factors

Bank A, 7 %: q=1.07, q2=1.1449, q3=1.1449⋅1.07=1.225043.

Bank B, 3 %: q=1.03, q2=1.0609, q3=1.092727.

Use the factors with all their digits: the difference sA−sB=0.256316 is small, and with rounded 3.44 and 3.18 the answer drifts by tens of GE.

A club pays money into an account at the start of three consecutive years, 2000 € in the second year. At the end of the third year there are 7793.82 € in the account at 2 %, and there would be 8404.74 € at 6 %.

How much was paid in the first year?

At 2 %: 1.061208 x1+1.0404⋅2000+1.02 x3=7793.82, that is 1.061208 x1+1.02 x3=5713.02.

At 6 %: 1.191016 x1+1.1236⋅2000+1.06 x3=8404.74, that is 1.191016 x1+1.06 x3=6157.54.

1.06⋅ first −1.02⋅ second: (1.12488048−1.21483632) x1=6055.8012−6280.6908.

−0.08995584 x1=−224.8896.

x1≈2500 €; then x3=(5713.02−2653.02)/1.02=3000 €.

Two payments remain. A municipality receives subsidies at the start of three years, 1800 € in the first year; at 3 % it would come to 6167.25 €, at 9 % to 6946.11 €. After moving the compounded 1800 across, what remains is 1.0609 x2+1.03 x3=4200.34 and 1.1881 x2+1.09 x3=4615.06. Remove x3 and find x2.

Your turn2 of 2

A firm pays money into an account at the start of each of three years; 2000 GE in the second year. At the end of the third year there are 4692.61 GE in the account at 2 %, and there would be 4991.44 GE at 5 %. How much was paid in the first year? Round to whole numbers.

Traps. The wrong options of the exam task and of tasks of this kind come about like this:

  • Simple instead of compound interest, option (b), 5367: factor 1+3r instead of q3 and 1+2r instead of q2. Each year the interest earns interest itself.
  • The wrong account, option (e), 3392: this is Y, the part for bank B. Check which bank the question names.
  • Payments at the end of the year: factors q2, q, 1 instead of q3, q2, q. Here the part for bank A comes out larger than the whole 8300 GE, and that is the signal.
  • The known payment without interest, in tasks of the second kind: subtracting 2000 rather than 2000⋅q2. In the second example that gives about 4351 instead of 2500. The known payment grows just like the unknown ones.

At a glance: transfer prices and payments with interest

The topic in a minute

  • Cost centre: one equation per centre. What it delivers to others times its own price equals its primary costs plus what it receives times the other price:
(given to others)⋅pA=primaryA+(from B)⋅pB
  • Own consumption (the diagonal of the table of deliveries) does not count; the corner of that table says who delivers and who receives.
  • Payments with interest: a payment at the start of year t stays until the end of the third year for 4−t years. One equation per rate:
x1⋅q3+x2⋅q2+x3⋅q=E
  • The known payment is also multiplied by its factor and moved to the right. Take the factors with all their digits.
  • One amount on two accounts: the factors of each account add up, X (q3+q2+q), and the second equation is the split itself.
  • Cost centres

    Two cost centres supply each other and the market; the transfer prices or the primary costs of one centre are asked for.
    (given to others)⋅pA=primaryA+(from B)⋅pB

    Trap: only the primary costs; forgetting or adding the services received.

  • Payments at two interest rates

    Payments at the start of three years and amounts at the end of the third year at two rates: one payment is known, or one amount is split between two accounts every year.
    x1q3+x2q2+x3q=E

    Trap: simple instead of compound interest; the known payment without interest.

On the exam formula sheet the only line for these tasks is Kt=K0(1+r)t for the payments at two rates. The balances of the cost centres are up to you.

The chapter's methods stand side by side, with the signs that tell them apart, in “Which method? Systems of linear equations”.

Now practise it

Transfer prices of cost centres and a payment at two rates

Trainer · Systems of linear equations

Practise
Next: Which method? Systems of linear equations
0/2

Was this article helpful?