Usually a progression is asked “how much”: how much it is in a given period or how much it adds up to over all periods. Here the question is often the other way round: not “how much” but “when”. After how many months do the savings first reach the goal? In which year is the harvest above the limit for the last time?
Imagine an employee who was promised a pay rise, not every year but after every three full years of service. She wants to know what she will earn in her eighth year to decide whether to stay. The usual formula for a term of a progression goes wrong here: it adds a rise for every year. Let us compare, year by year, how many rises the formula counts and how many there really are:
Year of service
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
By the formula
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
In fact
0
0
0
1
1
1
2
2
By the eighth year the formula counts seven rises, while in fact there are two. Every task in the article turns on a fork like this: steps instead of even growth, the limit “for the last time” and “for the first time”, a sum that has to reach a goal. The formulas are familiar. The mistake lies elsewhere: you are off by one period in one direction or the other. Exactly that wrong number is among the answers. The term an, the difference d and the sum sn are explained in the article “Arithmetic sequences: term and sum”. The formula for quadratic equations is explained in the article “What a function is: cost, revenue, profit and demand”.
The n-th term with steps: how much in year n
For the employee in the introduction the rise comes every three years. In the exam task the rent for a space in an underground car park rises in steps in the same way:
Exam-style task
Die Gebühr für einen Stellplatz in einer Tiefgarage betrug zu Beginn des Jahres 2011 monatlich 135 GE. Alle 2 Jahre wird sie um 15 GE angehoben, erstmals zu Beginn von 2013. Die Garage hat 60 Stellplätze.
Wie viel zahlt ein Mieter für einen Stellplatz von Anfang 2011 bis Ende 2016 insgesamt?
a)10800
b)5411
c)8820
d)10440
e)10098
The fee does not rise every year but in steps, and one number in the task is not needed for the answer. The question asks for a sum over six years, yet every such sum starts with the value in each single year, and that value comes from the formula of this section.
How to recognise the task. A salary, a rent or a fee does not rise every period but every few years by the same amount: “nach jeweils 3 vollen Dienstjahren” (after every 3 full years of service), “alle 4 Jahre im Jänner” (every 4 years in January). You are asked for the value in a particular year or semester, or for the sum of all payments over several years. Usually the task contains a number you do not need.
If a value a1 rises by d after every c full periods, then in period n, n−1 full periods have passed (in the 1st none yet, in the 2nd one), and of those only the whole steps count:
an=a1+k⋅d,k==whole-number part of cn−1
Steps: Count the full periods → Count the whole steps → Find the value after the steps → for a sum, add the values of all periods.
Formula sheet (“Formelsammlung”, the printed sheet): not on it.
Memorise: In year n, n−1 years are complete; round the steps down.
In the task above the fee in 2011 is 135 GE a month (GE, money units, that is money) and rises by 15 GE every 2 years, for the first time at the start of 2013. Counting 2011 as year 1 makes 2016 year 6. The 60 spaces of the garage change nothing about what a single tenant pays.
Step 1 of 4Count the full periods
From the start of 2011 to the end of 2016 there are 2016−2011+1=6 years. In year 6, 2016, 6−1=5 years are complete.
5:2=2, remainder 1: two raises, at the start of 2013 and of 2015. The new amount applies from year 3 and from year 5: those are the marks on the axis.
By the formula the fee in year n is 135+k⋅15, with k=0 in years 1 and 2, k=1 in years 3 and 4 and k=2 in years 5 and 6. That gives 135 GE in 2011 and 2012, 135+15=150 GE in 2013 and 2014 and 135+2⋅15=165 GE in 2015 and 2016.
Each step lasts two years, so the monthly fees of the six years add up to 2⋅(135+150+165)=2⋅450=900 GE. A year has 12 months: 12⋅900=10800 GE, option (a). Counting only up to 2015, because 2016−2011=5, gives 12⋅735=8820, option (c). Forgetting the second raise keeps 2015 and 2016 at 150 GE and gives 12⋅870=10440, option (d).
A care assistant starts on a monthly salary of 1800 €. After every 3 full years of service the salary rises by 120 €, and he also gets 110 € for meals every month. How high is his monthly salary in year 15 of service? In the picture of example 2 the salary rises as a staircase: one step after year 3, 6, 9 and 12.
Step 1 of 3Count the full periods
In year 15 of service, 15−1=14 years are complete.
14:3=4, remainder 2: four raises. The new pay applies from years 4, 7, 10 and 13: those are the marks on the axis.
1800+4⋅120=2280 €; the meal money is not part of the salary.
Calendar years and semesters. “ab 2011, alle 3 Jahre, zum ersten Mal 2014” (from 2011, every 3 years, the first time in 2014): in 2025, 2025−2011=14 years have passed, not 15. The same for semesters: in semester 24, 23 semesters are complete.
An early first raise. If the first raise comes earlier than the usual step, say after 1 year and then every 3 years, count it separately: in year 15, 14 years are complete, 14−1=13, 13:3=4 remainder 1, 1+4=5 raises in total.
Trap. Counting the current year: 15 years instead of 14 give 15:3=5 steps and 2400 €. Without rounding down you get 1800+314⋅120=2360. If you add the meal money, you get 2280+110=2390.
Your turn1 of 3
Since January 2011 a fitness club has charged a monthly fee of 32 €. Every 3 years in January the fee rises by 4 €, the first time in January 2014. The club has 850 members. How high is the monthly fee in 2025?
The last year above a limit: in which year for the last time
The fee per semester only went up. In the next task the quantity falls every year:
Exam-style task
Die Schulbehörde hat beschlossen: Eine Dorfschule bleibt offen, solange sie mehr als 61 Kinder hat. Im ersten Jahr nach dem Beschluss sind es 99 Kinder, und jedes Jahr werden es 3 weniger.
In welchem Jahr hat die Schule zum letzten Mal mehr als 61 Kinder? Geben Sie die Antwort als ganze Zahl an.
a)11
b)13
c)10
d)12
e)14
The number of pupils falls every year, and the question is the last year in which it is still above the limit.
How to recognise the task. A subsidy, a harvest or the number of pupils falls by the same amount every year. “In welchem Jahr liegt sie zum letzten Mal über …?” (in which year is it above … for the last time?) It is about a single term of one year, and the inequality is linear.
Below, this order is worked through with numbers; here it stands on its own:
Steps: Write the term as a function of n → Solve the inequality for n → Find the last year.
Formula sheet:xn=x0+n⋅d; the sheet counts from the zeroth term x0, here the first term is a1=x0, so an=a1+(n−1)d.
Memorise: Last year above the limit: round down and check with an and an+1.
Write down the term with number n and require it to be above the limit. You solve the inequality like an equation; the sign flips only when you multiply or divide by a negative number:
a1+(n−1)d>limit
In the task above a1=99 and d=−3, the limit is 61.
Step 1 of 3Write the term as a function of n
an=99−3⋅(n−1).
99−3⋅(n−1)>61. Subtract 99: −3⋅(n−1)>−38. Divide by −3, the sign flips: n−1<12.67, so n<13.67.
The largest whole n is 13: a13=63 pupils is above 61, a14=60 no longer. The answer is 13.
Take an old vineyard: it yields 2600 kg of grapes in the first year, then 140 kg less every year. It is farmed as long as the harvest is above 1000 kg. In which year is it farmed for the last time? In the picture for example 2 the harvest falls as dots, and the limit 1000 is dashed.
Step 1 of 3Write the term as a function of n
an=2600−140⋅(n−1).
2600−140⋅(n−1)>1000. Subtract 2600: −140⋅(n−1)>−1600. Divide by −140, the sign flips: n−1<11.43, so n<12.43.
The largest whole n is 12: a12=1060 is above 1000, a13=920 no longer is.
Trap. Rounding up: 13 is the first year below the limit. The 11 comes from stopping at n−1<11.43 and forgetting to add 1, and the 19 from 2600:140≈18.6 counts the years until the harvest falls to zero, not to the limit of 1000.
Your turn2 of 3
A magazine has 8400 subscribers in the first year, then 380 fewer every year. It is closed as soon as there are at most 3000 subscribers. In which year does the magazine have more than 3000 subscribers for the last time?
Periods until a limit: when the sum first reaches it
So far the limit applied to the term of a single year, as with the pupils and the vineyard. In this section the sum of all periods together has to reach the limit.
How to recognise the task. “Nach wie vielen Wochen sind insgesamt erstmals mindestens 9000 Exemplare verkauft?” (after how many weeks have at least 9000 copies been sold in total for the first time?) or “in welchem Jahr ist der Fonds erstmals überzogen?” (in which year is the fund overdrawn for the first time?). You need n, and it is about the sum of all periods.
In the sum, n appears twice, in front of the bracket and inside it, so the equation is quadratic:
2n(2a1+(n−1)d)≥limit
A bookshop sells 30 copies of a new book on the first day, then 4 more every day. After how many days has it sold at least 650 copies in total for the first time? In the graph below the dots show the sum after n days, the dashed line the limit 650.
Step 1 of 4Write the sum as a function of n
sn=2n(2⋅30+(n−1)⋅4)=2n(56+4n).
2n(56+4n)=650, so n2+14n−325=0.
n=2−14+196+1300≈12.3; the negative solution does not fit.
s12=624<650, s13=702≥650. The answer is 13 days.
Below you can move the limit and see how the first day on which the sum reaches it changes.
Trap. Rounding down: after 12 days there are only 624 copies. You always round up, even at 12.1. If the task says “mehr als” (more than) instead of “mindestens” (at least) and the solution is a whole number, the answer is one period more: at equality the limit has not been exceeded yet.
Steps: Write the sum as a function of n → Set it equal to the limit → Solve the quadratic equation → Round up and check.
Formula sheet: the sum of the sequence and the formula for quadratic equations (“Lösungsformel”).
Memorise: Round up, check with sn and sn−1.
Your turn3 of 3
A student puts aside 50 € in the first month and then 10 € more every month than in the month before. After how many months has she saved at least 2100 € in total for the first time?
Formula sheet and what to memorise
In all three sections it is easy to be off by one period. The cards below show exactly where that mistake waits:
A quantity grows only every few years: “nach jeweils 3 vollen Jahren” (after every 3 full years). The step d is added to a1 as many times as whole steps k have passed.
an==a1++k⋅⋅d
Trap:counting the current, unfinished year; only full steps count.
A quantity falls by the same number each year; when is it above a threshold for the last time (“zum letzten Mal über”)? Set the term a1+(n−1)d above the threshold and solve the linear inequality.
a1++(n−−1)d>>limit
Trap:rounding n up; that gives the first year below the threshold, and the right step is rounding down (if n comes out whole, take 1 less).
After how many periods does the total first reach a threshold (“insgesamt erstmals mindestens”, in total at least for the first time)? The sum of n terms with a1 and d must be at least the threshold, and the inequality is quadratic.
2n(2a1++(n−−1)d)≥≥limit
Trap:rounding n down; then the threshold is not yet reached, so you round up.
On the formula sheet:
n-th term xn=x0+n⋅d (counted from x0; ours is an=a1+(n−1)d): for steps, the number of steps k replaces the number of single steps; for the last year above a limit, the term goes into the inequality “greater than the limit”
Sum Sn=2n(x1+xn) (ours: sn, a1, an) and the formula for quadratic equations: periods until a limit
Memorise yourself:
steps: an=a1+k⋅d, k is the whole-number part of (n−1)/c; with calendar years, work out the difference of the years
last year above the limit: round down (if n comes out whole, take 1 less) and check with an and an+1
a sum reaches the limit: round up and check with sn and sn−1